Mike's Mets - The Waiting Game

 

By Mike Steffanos November 21, 2020

Last week I read that the Mets were going to make a decision on their President of Baseball Operations position within the next week to ten days. It's fairly safe now to assume that this isn't likely to happen within that time frame, unless the Mets are prepared to name former Marlins exec Michael Hill, the only person they've interviewed so far, to the position. Clearly the Mets are operating on a different timetable than was expected, prepared to let Sandy Alderson and the people working under him lay some of the groundwork for the new Mets era. So, while it's a bit surprising that so little has happened up to now, it's not really cause for concern.

Some rumors have been trickling out, like the one that said Cleveland's Mike Chertoff was the frontrunner in the search for a PBO. This prompted a "Not that I'm aware of, wrong again" tweet from Steve Cohen, and the word is that Chernoff really isn't a candidate at all, which probably indicates he has no desire to leave Cleveland. I can't help but wonder if the reason that there hasn't been any interviews beyond Hill yet is that none of their top choices are interested and/or available.

An article in The Athletic by Ken Rosenthal and Jayson Stark that I discussed in Tuesday's post made the point in how much more difficult it is to hire well-regarded PBOs and GMs away from other teams these days. Teams are much less willing to let these guys go these days, and many of them aren't interested in leaving where they are comfortable and successful. It does seem, at least from what I've been able to read, that the Mets have had no success in even getting meetings with the top names on their list.

Then there's the departure of Theo Epstein from Chicago. He doesn't seem interested in any new job currently, and it's always struck me as quite unlikely that he would take on the Mets position. He's already broken "curses" for both the Red Sox and Cubs. While the Mets are considered an attractive organization now since the Wilpons have been replaced by Steve Cohen, this looks to me as almost a no-win situation for Epstein:

• He'd have to work under Sandy Alderson. While I don't think that would be as onerous as working under someone who wasn't a baseball legend and a noted good collaborator, Epstein will have options available in the relative near future of only answering to an owner, perhaps even with an ownership stake in a team.


• He's already won twice with two teams that had waited 86 years and 108 years for a title. If he did it again with the Mets it certainly wouldn't compare as an accomplishment. If he didn't win, however, that would be a stain on his legacy.


• Even if Steve Cohen opens the bank vaults for Epstein, how much money would it take to change his mind? He's made a lot of money from Boston and Chicago, and I don't think even quite a lot of money would be the deciding factor.


• My strong suspicion is that Epstein has a been there/done that feeling about taking another job leading another ballclub. Putting myself in his place, I'm pretty sure that I'd be looking for a new challenge, at least in the near future. He might eventually come back to running a baseball operation, but I'd be pretty surprised if it happened anytime soon.

If I seem somewhat dismissive of Epstein as a candidate, it's not because I don't see the benefit of trying to hire the man who is clearly the top baseball executive of this era. I honestly think the one way that you might possibly attract Epstein here is if you got him to come in for a meeting and sold him on the thought that this organization was going to be making history in some manner with the way it operated going forward, and selling him on the excitement and novelty of being a part of that. I'm a pretty damned creative guy, but I can't come up with anything along those lines. If you can, please forward it to Sandy Alderson ASAP. It would be negligent if Alderson didn't reach out to the guy, but I can't see it happening.

Things are happening pretty slow in baseball right now. The Mets are proactively stockpiling some depth, like the signing of pitcher Sam McWilliams, but there's nothing particularly sexy happening that would satiate the desire of a starving Mets fan for something substantial to take place. Then again, looking around baseball, nothing much is really happening anywhere yet. The nontender deadline in MLB is December 2, and there's a sense around the game that nothing much will happen at all until that date passes. Not only will there be a lot of new free agents on that date, but it's conceivable that some teams will save money on non-tenders and use that money for other purposes. Which I guess is good news for the Mets, giving them more time to make a decision on their PBO job.

Continue reading by clicking here.