Pages

12/7/21

Tom Brennan - Retrospective on Mets' Drafts of Years Past: 2017


Wikipedia states:

retrospective is a look back at past events that took place.

I thought it might be fun to get all retrospective and look back at: 

1) How Mets kiddies drafted in rounds 1 thru 5 panned out, and 

2) Which of all the Mets' picks actually made it to the dance. 

Not to get too historical, I thought I’d start at 2005 and work forward towards 2021 from there, a year at a time. 2005 thru 2016 done so far.

Today?  

The Mets' 2017 Draft: 

Round 1 (20th overall) goes to big lefty David Peterson, who debuted nicely in 2020, but ran into the Soph Jinx in 2021.  Will he rebound and prove this to be a successful pick?  I say, "give him more time."  I think at least moderate success lies ahead for the southpaw Peterson.

Round 2?  Listening to the Brennan refrain of "Drafting power arms and power bats", the Mets no doubt said, "Why not?" 

Mark Vientos unloaded major lumber power in the minors in 2021, and likely will bring that heavy lumber to Citifield sometime in 2022.  Nice power pick for a 59th overall snatch.  Any guy who can hit over .300 over his last 210 at bats with an amazing 22 jacks is someone I can only hope is Alonso II.

Round 3 - what a difference a round can make.  Vientos in the second round, but in the third, Quinn Brodey had a simply awful 2021 (.174, 98 Ks in 70 games) in a major regression from a pretty solid 2019, and I am not sure if there is a future for him beyond 2021.   

His 2021 stats say "no" to me, but I don't know what his 2021 difficulties were, so let's see if he can be a comeback kid.

Round 4 - righty Tony Dibrell had in all frankness a so-so career through early July 2021, and then succumbed to major injury of the Tommy John kind in July - we'll see if there is any hope for Mr. Dibs even pitching in 2022.  I'd imagine that 2022 may be a total wash out, given the timing of his 2021 surgery.  Hopefully, he is one of those guys who gets the surgery and comes back throwing better and harder.

Round 5 - Matt Winaker - not in the "power bats" category, certainly, so far at least.   In 2021, in Binghamton, he had a very solid July - and not much else.  He seems like a lesser version of prior draftee Kevin Kaczmarski to me - not much power, but a lower .240 lifetime hitter.  

Matt may need to shake it up by adding 20 pounds of muscle for 2022 to try to reinvent himself.  He does have a career .362 OBP, so to me, that right there shows there is hope.  My armchair advice?  Muscle up, Matt.  Kevin K did not, but Jeff McNeil did so successfully, TJ Rivera did too, and it seems you need to also.

Now that the annual drafts I am writing about are getting close to the current year of 2021, and having missed all of 2020 in the minors, it is unreasonable to expect any Round 6 and lower guys to have gotten to the big leagues.  

But those rounds were seemingly unproductive, save for 37th rounder Josh Walker, who pitched very well in AA and AAA in 2021.  Perhaps the tall lefty can be a clone of sorts to David Peterson in 2022.  In a good way.  A few other guys were still playing in 2021, and we'll see if they still are in pro ball in 2022.

Vientos, Peterson, and Walker are the 3 successes of this draft - just 3 makes this a slim draft, but if 2 of those 3 become impact major leaguers, it will be a fairly solid draft year.

Next article? 2018.



7 comments:

  1. News flash: Santa just got run over by a reindeer.

    Thankfully, Santa was not on the 40 man roster.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I still think Peterson was a great.pick this year. We will see if he proves me right this season.

    2 years of great 2nd picks.

    Vientos and Alonso

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mack, I still think Vientos will be Alonso II. I hope I'm right.

    To be picked that high right out of HS as a young HS graduate - I wold have to imagine he was a top 25 HS pick that draft.

    Peterson - I like what I saw mostly. He has to shake off any Steve Matz-in-NY underperformance. Just believe - you WILL succeed. Location doesn't matter.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's hard to get a good read on Santa because playing in those very cold conditions in the North Pole and the season's only 1 month so hard to assess. Moving him to the "warmth" of Syracuse could do wonders for his fastball and changeup command. Also trimming the hair and beard wouldn't hurt either ask Jake.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Peterson should be solid depth and a decent long reliever, at a minimum, IMO. Or, if he takes a step forward, a good #4/#5 starter moving forward on a reasonable contract (which is also valuable).

    Vientos? Not sure where he plays? Seems like we are overflowing in the areas he could pay (3B, 1B, LF/RF and DH). Maybe if someone like Smith or Davis get traded?

    Still think we need another starter, and a reliever (lefty) once things open back up.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Mike, I think a Smith or Davis needs to move out of Vientos' way, but I can see Vientos needing another half season. Sadly, he only got to the plate 349 times in 2021, in part due to COVID crap. Alonso, who I think he will be very much like, was up 686 times in his last minor league season and Arizona Fall ball, or twice as many ABs. I think 2-3 more months of AAA, and then Vientos comes up as Pete II. I think had Vientos gotten 200 more ABs in the minors last year, he'd be essentially ready, as Pete was going into 2019.

    Vientos is an inch taller than Pete and I bet he comes in more beefed up (still listed at his initial 185, probably more like 215 next spring) and ready to blast away in 2022.

    He likely will be a better fielder than Pete, even if not great. I don't know which of the two wins a foot race, though. Neither is a gazelle - but home run trots can be done at a leisurely pace.

    ReplyDelete