Pages

▼

11/17/26

Steve Sica- Are the Mets Better off Without Skubal?

There's no denying that Tarik Skubal would look awfully good wearing a Mets uniform. He's one of the best starting pitchers in baseball, and any team would be fortunate to have him anchoring its rotation.

But should the Mets really be willing to spend an enormous amount of money to bring him to Queens? I'm not so sure.

The Mets have been down this road before, making massive financial commitments to established stars in hopes of taking that next step toward a championship. Unfortunately, those investments haven't always worked out the way the organization envisioned.

Just look at Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander.

The Mets committed three years and $130 million to Scherzer and two years and $86.7 million to Verlander. These were two future Hall of Fame pitchers, and the excitement surrounding their arrivals was understandable. The expectation was that they would help lead the Mets to a championship.

Instead, the 2023 season turned into a disappointment. Scherzer was eventually traded to Texas, while Verlander was sent back to Houston before the trade deadline. That's a tremendous amount of money invested in two players who ultimately weren't part of the organization's plans moving forward.

There's no guarantee that signing Skubal would produce the same outcome. He's younger than Scherzer and Verlander were when they arrived, and he's coming off an impressive career. But the Mets should at least consider the risks before making another massive investment in a starting pitcher.

Build Around the Young Rotation

One reason I would hesitate to pursue Skubal is the young pitching talent the Mets already have in their organization.

Nolan McLean, Christian Scott, Jonah Tong, Zac Thornton and Jonathan Santucci represent an intriguing group of young arms. There's plenty of potential here, and the Mets should give these pitchers an opportunity to establish themselves as important pieces of the rotation.

Of course, young pitchers come with uncertainty. Not everyone is going to develop into a dependable major league starter, and injuries are always a concern. That's part of the reason teams need pitching depth.

But the Mets have an opportunity to build something with this group. Rather than committing an extraordinary amount of money to one pitcher, they could continue developing their young talent while adding some veteran experience at a more reasonable price.

Address the Entire Roster, Not Just the Rotation

There's another consideration that shouldn't get lost in the excitement of potentially signing Skubal: the Mets have other needs.

Even if Skubal pitches like a Cy Young winner, he can only take the mound once every five days. What about the other four days?

The Mets could use that money to address several areas of the roster.

The bullpen could benefit from multiple dependable arms rather than relying on one expensive acquisition. The lineup could use additional offensive depth and another productive bat. Preserving financial flexibility would also give the front office more opportunities to address needs as they arise throughout the season.

And if the Mets decide they need another starting pitcher, there are less expensive veteran options who could provide valuable innings without requiring a historic financial commitment.

At the end of the day, building a championship team requires more than having one outstanding starting pitcher. It takes a complete roster, reliable depth, and contributions from players throughout the organization.

Tarik Skubal is a tremendous talent, and I certainly wouldn't complain about having him in the Mets' rotation. But that doesn't necessarily mean he's the best investment for this particular team.

The Mets have young pitching worth developing and several other areas where significant improvements could make a difference.

Rather than breaking the bank for one superstar, I'd prefer to see the Mets spread that money around, strengthen the overall roster, and build a team capable of competing in October.

7 comments:

  1. You're asking me if the Mets would be better off not having the best pitcher in baseball.

    What are you talkin' bout, Willis?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the Mets need two starters, a 1B, a 4th or 5th outfielder and an approach to DH as a serious position and a couple of relievers., and of course a consistent need to replenish the farm system in sync. All that is compatible with obtaining Skubal. They have lots of money coming off the books and by my calculations their payroll on the big ticket players they are already committed to for this year ad the next will (including Skubal, Soto and Lindor) drop to 130M. I don't see why the team would not pursue Skubal and Gausman or Gray (7rs for the former; 2 for either of the latter); Morejon and Loisaga in the pen and revisit Raley perhaps( 3/4yrs, 2/3 yrs 1/2 yrs respectively; and Contreras at !B (1/2yrs under current contract) and revisit Taylor. Skubal and Gausman together make McLean better and slot others into appropriate roles while giving them time to develop; I don't think it makes sense to count on all of the current crop developing to the ceilings we fantasize for them. It also makes no sense to waste more core years from Soto and Lindor, or not to take advantage of the value of building a winner as soon as possible for its impact on the attitudes of the younger players; and so on.
    I think a long term contract always creates its own set of risks, and one should always expect decline in the latter years. it's unavoidable, but if you want to be among the best for the long haul you will always need to take risks. What you need is an insurance policy to mitigate the risks in the form of an excellent farm system and development program.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Logically, better off without the salary risk of Skubal…but us aging dudes want another Mets championship. Pull the trigger.

    ReplyDelete
  4. To back up Jules and Mack, this is a no brainer. The risk involved was similar to Scherzer’s contract with Washington, but that worked out quite well. If pitchers stay healthy, they are good into their forties. Hitters aren’t the same. If this an elite pitcher right now, and you believe that, you sign him. That isn’t going away soon.

    In fact, on X yesterday I saw a graph comparing Brian Giles to Juan Soto and they were awfully close. Hitters scare me, pitchers don't. I just don’t know that they need anyone else because the problem with the Mets not letting their youth grow is that they lose them and the benefit that comes with them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Giles-Soto comparison is quite interesting.

      Spend a Ruble. Get Skubal.

      Delete
  5. I believe the Mets must make every effort to secure Skubal. This is just their reality. If the Mets want to compete within the next couple of years, they need elite pitching depth. McLean is awesome & would likely accelerate his development working with Skubal. But McLean is a one trick pony for these Mets & one injury away from disaster for the team. We also can’t wait for prospect development (it may come or it may not).

    Two quality pitchers & whatever deadwood remains is on a very short leash next year.

    ReplyDelete
  6. As Steve points out, Skubal differs from Verlander and Scherzer in that he is still in his prime, while the others were well past their glory days when the Mets acquired them. So the performance risk is very low. The injury risk is higher, as it is with any pitcher - but you don't put up $300-$400M on just any pitcher. Prior to any major CBA changes, this is today's game - take big risk for big rewards. In this case the reward is a pitcher that gives the team a chance to win games 1 and 4 of any playoff series. With McLean right behind him, games 2 and 5 are in pretty good shape two.

    ReplyDelete