Well, it looks like the Semi-end of an era as last night's announcement started the unravelling of a core of old-time Mets. According to the unofficial release, the Mets will trade Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers for Marcus Semien.
The trade fits with David Stearns' new direction - to strengthen the defense (run prevention) on the team. Semien is a three-time all star and a two-time gold glove winner in the American League with some strong credentials as a middle infielder with both the Toronto Blue Jays and the Texas Rangers. That is not to say that Brandon Nimmo is not a good fielder, but Nimmo has slowed a bit recently, producing 1 and -1 Outs Above Average in the past two seasons. Semien, on the other hand, produced 7 OAA last year and a whopping 19 OAA in his 2024 season.
Both teams get some benefit from this trade, as Semien is owed some serious salary over the next few years and Nimmo is a lower yearly hit, but has a larger contract over the long term. The Rangers get a solid player in all aspects of the game and a positive influence in the clubhouse. The Mets get a gold glove defender who will play every day at second base and leave the Mets with a plethora of options for some other positions both with existing veterans and with upcoming prospects.
As much as this will help the re-build for the future, I am somewhat sad to see Nimmo go, as he represents a home-grown kid with a big smile and a work ethic to get better every year. He was a Met for life until he wasn't, which makes you look wistfully at the rest of the off-season with other Met-for-life guys like Pete Alonso and Jeff McNeil suddenly no longer sure things. I would hate to lose either of them, but the business side of baseball looms large and the Mets are not going to use sentiment as a decision making tool for their future.
Nimmo was a great contributor for the Mets over his ten year career, accounting for 593 runs scored and 463 runs batted in. He slashed .262/.364/.438 over those ten seasons and registered 26.1 WAR. Unfortunately some of his prime years were spent either injured or recovering from injury as his always hustling style caused many collisions with the walls, the turf, and sometimes other players. He is a little more cautious now and a little less injured, but still plays a capable outfield. He struggled in 2024, but otherwise has been a .260-.270 hitter with a high 300's on-base percentage that any team would value.
Brandon Nimmo was a memorable Met, known for sprinting to first on a base-on-balls, letting loose a broad smile frequently during the game, and a positive demeanor during interviews that endeared him to the fans.
He joins a bevy of former Mets in the Rangers organization, including former Ace Jacob DeGrom, former prospect Dom Hamel, and former #1 draft pick Kumar Rocker. I will miss him.







