It came as no surprise whatsoever that the Mets assigned top prospect Jefferson Rojas to the 40-man roster. While releasing pitcher Dylan Ross was a bit of a surprise as there were numerous other less than exceptional players in the existing 40-man group, everyone knew it was a necessity to create the vacancy for Rojas.
Now the 2026/2027 off season is indeed a strange one without a traditional Rule V Draft the risk in losing players not currently on the 40-man roster is somewhat minimized. No one knows how this lockout-induced mechanism will be reintroduced if and when the 2027 season begin. For now it is only conjecture to recommend what the Mets could or should do given the uncertainty of how prospects will be treated.
Earlier this week we examined some of the implications of what the do-nothing front office will do regarding the first base vacancy. Now it’s time to do the same exercise with second base.
Right now incumbent Marcus Semien who has been an All Star, won a Silver Slugger and won a Gold Glove more than once for each award. He has a highly credible career and when he does retire not only will he have a very healthy bank account but he’ll also have a mantle full of performance awards. It’s a fine story and a great legacy.
Of course, you could write that same story for many other players who in their prime were among the best in the game and then their subsequent diminished output as they aged and their former strength and agility seemed to begin to abandon them.
Semien’s last good season was in 2023. By anyone’s measure that was three full years ago. Then he hit .276 with 29 HRs and 100 RBIs. It wasn’t his best season of his career but it was one any player would be proud to have on the back of his baseball card.
After that the decline began. In 2024 he scaled down his totals considerably. His batting average dipped to just .237. The run production numbers were respectable — 23 HRs and 74 RBIs — but also down from his 2023 level of performance.
In 2025 it got markedly worse. The batting average slipped to just .230 and the run production plummeted. The HR total was just 15 and he drove in just 62.
He was traded to the Mets in what can best be described as a financial mitigation transaction. Brandon Nimmo was going to earn more money on the remainder of his contract than Semien would and with Semien’s track record it was questionably reasonable to expect that a change of scenery and better health could make it all a reasonable deal.
That outcome, of course, did not happen. For the Mets last year Semien hit just .215 with the same 15 HRs as he did the previous year but the RBI total slipped down to just 49. Having plummeted in the performance metrics now for three straight years it would appear Semien is indeed in his twilight years as a baseball player.
Now unsurprisingly David Stearns has publicly proclaimed Semien will get the opportunity to be the everyday second baseman as the club desperately attempts to extricate themselves from the cellar they owned for the 2026 season. Hmmn...
There are alternatives that exist. Outfielder AJ Ewing has ample time at the second base position. Finding another outfielder is probably easier than finding an offensively productive second baseman. The problem is that Ewing is at least competent and sometimes better playing alongside Juan Soto and Carson Benge. As a second baseman he’s not going to make anyone remember the skill of Doug Flynn in the field.
Then there are the younger minor leaguers.
Behind him you have Mitch Voit whose primary position is not second base. He could likely move there but he has even less pro experience than Rojas.
The other newcomer, Emilien Pitre, is a natural second baseman and is a couple of years older. He’ll likely begin the year in Syracuse as well, but his contact hitting skill and stolen base abilities make him into a viable future infield option.
So here we go again...settling for the convenient and certainly not the best option. Part of it is a vain attempt to justify yet another bad deal made by Stearns but part of it is acknowledgment that the alternatives are either not good enough yet to justify benching a guy owed $46 million for the 2027 and 2028 seasons. It is unfortunate but salary often dictates playing time.







