10/25/26

MACK – JUST BASEBALL - 2027 MLB Draft – Top 50 College Prospects

  


1. Brendan Lawson – 3B

HT/WT: 6’3/215 | Bat/Throw: L/R | School: Florida | Hometown: Toronto, ON | Projected Age: 21.7

A Canadian-born player has never been selected 1.1 in the draft’s history, though that could change in 2027. Lawson grew up in Ontario and made his way south to P27 Academy, though ailments hampered his efforts as a high school senior. That made him one of the premier bats to reach campus, and over two years in Gainesville, he’s lived up to expectations.

Lawson has undergone some swing and approach changes to achieve his success. As a prepster, Lawson employed a high handset that’s reminiscent of Nolan Schanuel’s and a wider base, electing to lace the ball to both sides of the field. Now, Lawson has become more upright, with his hands starting in front of his face before drifting back into a launching position. This move lets Lawson generate more leverage and torque, leading to ridiculous bat speed through the zone.

He began pulling the ball much more in 2026, with his PullAir% jumping from 19.52% to 27.14% and his PullFlyBall% spiking to 15%. He has double-plus raw power in the tank, registering a 111.2 MPH 90th percentile exit velocity, an outrageous figure to post in college baseball.

The hit tool itself isn’t too shabby either, with his bat-to-ball skills shoring up against secondary offerings and his swing decisions improving drastically. He does show some passivity in the zone, with a 51% swing rate, which he’ll need to improve. That said, his offensive ceiling could be special.

Defensively, Lawson was Florida’s everyday shortstop in 2026, where he fared well and made quality plays. However, Lawson sometimes rushed plays, and he’s expected to add more mass in the coming years. That leaves a move to the hot corner on the table, where his above-average arm strength would fit well.

In a draft class without many up-the-middle options, Lawson’s offensive tools give him the highest upside of any collegiate player in the class. If the defense at shortstop improves in 2027, it’ll be a cherry on top.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 55 | Power: 70 | Run: 50 | Field: 50 | Arm: 55

 

2. Dax Whitney – RHP

HT/WT: 6’5/218 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: Oregon State | Hometown: Blackfoot, ID | Projected Age: 21.5

In the waning weeks of the 2024 cycle, Whitney had significant helium, though he turned down multi-million-dollar bonuses to wind up in Corvallis with the Beavers. He immediately stepped into the weekend rotation and became one of the top arms in the country, striking out 224 batters across 139.2 innings before suffering an elbow injury in late April.

Unfortunately, this injury will sideline Whitney through the 2027 season, but even with this wrinkle, he’s the best arm in this class. We’ve seen injured pitchers taken high before, but Whitney’s track record and stuff keep him in 1.1 contention.

The delivery is a bit unorthodox, with an extremely tight arm circle that turns into an over-the-top slot, but he’s a buttery-smooth mover with repeatable mechanics. Whitney’s stuff is outrageously good, starting with an upper-90s cut/ride monster of a fastball. He consistently cuts the fastball and generates plus carry, which led to a 37% whiff rate in 2026. That’s across a 545-pitch sample size, a truly incredible figure. It’s every bit of a double-plus heater.

He’s more than just the fastball, though, as each of Whitney’s secondary pitches has plus upside. He has a mid-to-upper-80s slider with fantastic snap and sweep. It has gotten upwards of 90 MPH, and he averages over 2,600 RPM. His low-80s curveball has little to no hump out of the hand, diving to the dirt with immense depth and some late lateral action. He kills a lot of spin on an upper-80s change-up that features solid fade and tumble, too.

The fact that Whitney projects to have four plus-or-better pitches with above-average command is astonishing, and it puts him in rare territory. It’s easy to see why scouts and analysts praise him as the best collegiate arm since Paul Skenes, and given the lack of up-the-middle talent in this class, he will have a chance to be taken 1.1 despite his injury.

Scouting Grades: Fastball: 70 | Slider: 60 | Curveball: 60 | Change: 60 | Command: 55

 

3. Gavin Kelly – C,2B

HT/WT: 6’0/175 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: West Virginia | Hometown: Pittsburgh, PA | Projected Age: 21.6

West Virginia has become a legitimate powerhouse in the Big 12, and Kelly was a major catalyst in the program’s first-ever appearance in Omaha this season. After impressing as a freshman for the Mountaineers, Kelly’s game elevated to superstardom in 2026, slashing .382/.477/.725 in 305 plate appearances, racking up 21 doubles and 19 home runs with a 43:45 BB:K ratio.

It’s a well-rounded profile on both sides of the ball. An athletic prospect with hitterish traits present, Kelly has a quick, compact swing that pairs with excellent barrel feel and swing decisions. Kelly led the NCAA in barrels last season and amplifies his power production with a swing that is built to lift the baseball in the air, playing to both sides of the field. His higher-end exit velocities suggest an average power hitter, though his ability to consistently impact the ball the way he does is impressive.

The bat-to-ball skills are just as remarkable, including his affinity for fastballs. While Kelly does have an exaggerated barrel wrap, he whiffed on velocity just 11% of the time in 2026. With improvements against breaking balls in 2027, Kelly could become the best pure hitter in the college ranks.

Defensively, Kelly has utility that will benefit his profile. He has split time between catcher and second base in Morgantown, and he’s also spent time in the grass on the Cape. Kelly’s athleticism and plus speed shine at those positions, and he has the arm strength to hold his own behind the plate. It’s reasonable to believe that Kelly can be an above-average or better defender with multiple places to slot him in on the lineup card.

Repeating his 2026 campaign will keep Kelly firmly in 1.1 discussions.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 60 | Power: 50 | Run: 60 | Field: 55 | Arm: 55

 

4. Tomas Valincius – LHP

HT/WT: 6’2/225 | Bat/Throw: L/L | School: Mississippi State | Hometown: Lockport, IL | Projected Age: 21.9

In a draft class that is filled to the brim with pitching talent, Valincius is the best southpaw available. After performing admirably as a freshman at Virginia, he followed head coach Brian O’Connor to Starkville and led a dynamic Mississippi State pitching staff.

With a thicker build, abundant strength, and remarkable feel for his arsenal, Valincius is one of the more pro-ready talents in the class. An easy mover on the mound with repeatable mechanics, Valincius hides the ball well with a shorter arm circle and has explosive arm speed from a low three-quarters slot. This gives him premium deception and lets the ball jump on hitters quickly.

While his fastball isn’t a bat-misser, it’s a monstrous mid-90s sinker that benefits greatly from the deception, and he can establish a tunnel to his secondaries. It’s also a strong groundball producer, as hitters pound the offering into the dirt at a 60% clip. Valincius’ mid-80s slider is a true plus offering that plays off the fastball tunnel, showcasing tight spin and sharp lateral bite that befuddles hitters. He can command the offering to both sides of the plate consistently, and it boasted a 48% whiff and 39% chase rate in 2026. Valincius rounds out his arsenal with a strong mid-80s change-up that gives him an above-average weapon against right-handed hitters. He sells the offering well, and the pitch tumbles below the barrel, inducing a 51% whiff rate.

It’s a strong three-pitch mix that is tied together with above-average command. As a result, Valincius has mid-rotation upside at the next level.

Scouting Grades: Fastball: 60 | Slider: 60 | Change: 55 | Command: 55

 

5. Landon Hairston – OF

HT/WT: 5’11/195 | Bat/Throw: L/L | School: Arizona State | Hometown: Queen Creek, AZ | Projected Age: 21.5

The Hairston family has a long baseball legacy. Four family members have played in the big leagues, with Scott the most recent to have a successful career. His son, Landon, is next in line, and he has the tools to be just as successful as the others.

After forcing himself into the lineup as a freshman, Hairston was a Golden Spikes Finalist in 2026, slashing a ridiculous .400/.509/.860 with 50 extra-base hits, including 28 long balls. He has one of the most complete offensive profiles in the class, boasting excellent contact skills, burgeoning power, and a polished approach.

Hairston has a rhythmic swing with a compact bat path and robust bat speed. The barrel stays in the zone for a long time, and he’s efficient at creating backspin at contact, with above-average exit velocities in the tank. Adding leverage and pulling the baseball allowed the power production to take a significant jump in 2026, and it came with an improvement in bat-to-ball skills. Hairston torches fastballs in and out of the zone, plus he can adjust his swing plane to cover every quadrant possible. It’s a plus hit tool at the end of the day.

Originally an infielder in high school, Hairston transitioned to the grass in Tempe, where he’s manned left field for most of his career. It’s where he fits best at the next level with decent routes and reads, though with his athleticism steadily improving, there’s a non-zero chance he can stick in center.

If he proves that he can stay at the “eight,” it will improve his draft stock in a class that lacks up-the-middle talent. That said, even if he doesn’t, the bat is good enough to take in the top ten picks without thinking twice.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 60 | Power: 55 | Run: 45 | Field : 50 | Arm: 50

 

6. Jimmy Janicki – C

HT/WT: 6’4/223 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: Troy | Hometown: Downers Grove, IL | Projected Age: 21.4

Every draft cycle, there’s at least one or two mid-major stars with plenty of first-round buzz. This year, there’s a clear-cut leader in the clubhouse. Jimmy Janicki has it all, and it’s difficult to poke holes in his game at this point.

His bat-to-ball skills are stellar for a backstop, with a 19% whiff rate in his sophomore season after posting 13% the year prior. Even more, he recognizes spin exceptionally well and makes contact at a clip well above average, which was a big factor in his low strikeout rate of 13% last year. He does try to expand the zone a touch more than you’d like to see, but he still makes contact at a respectable rate when he does.

More impressively, Janicki’s best feature at the plate isn’t even his contact ability: it’s his otherworldly feel for the barrel. The Illinois native has made a career out of loud ABs, utilizing a pull-side-oriented approach that results in a ground-ball rate below 30%. Oh yeah, and a 110 mph 90th-percentile EV isn’t half bad either. Our newest writer, Josh Catlett, got a couple of up-close looks at him in Omaha from right behind home plate, and he truly might’ve been my favorite watch of the week.

Coming off a season in which he posted a 1.080 OPS with 21 home runs and 26 doubles for one of the final six teams standing, all eyes will be on the Troy star as he attempts to make a final push up draft boards in hopes of earning himself $3 million+ in July.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 50 | Power: 70 | Run: 50 | Field: 50 | Arm: 55

 

7. Chris Levonas – RHP

HT/WT: 6’1/175 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: Wake Forest | Hometown: Holmdel, NJ | Projected Age: 21.4

After adding significant velocity in his senior spring, the Milwaukee Brewers selected Levonas in the second round. However, Levonas turned down millions to enroll at Wake Forest, and after enduring his lumps as a freshman, he put together a fantastic sophomore campaign. Across 15 starts, Levonas struck out 116 batters and posted a 2.82 ERA with an improved arsenal, lining himself up for a first-round selection in 2027.

An elastic, flexible mover on the mound, he creates outlandish extension for a pitcher his size, averaging just under seven feet. That said, there’s a good amount of effort present, which is something to watch moving forward.

Levonas’ fastball velocity ticked up into the upper-90s this spring, peaking at 101 MPH with cut/ride shape through the zone. Despite the velocity and shape combination, Levonas has yet to miss bats at a high clip because of lackluster fastball command, which he’ll need to focus on.

That said, his feel to spin and shape his breaking balls is fantastic. Levonas’ low-80s curveball is a hammer, averaging north of 2,700 RPM with fantastic bite and depth present. It’s a true plus pitch that Levonas likes to lean upon often. His mid-80s slider has significant sweep with spin rates similar to the curveball, and an upper-80s cutter is a great pitch that gives him a firmer option to throw in the zone. He can land all three breaking balls for strikes. A firm low-90s change-up finalizes the arsenal, acting like a two-seam fastball at times with spin-killing traits.

Levonas will need to evolve as a pitcher by tightening his command, but his frame and traits are incredibly enticing for a player development program.

Scouting Grades: Fastball: 70 | Slider: 55 | Cutter: 60 | Curveball: 60 | Change: 45 | Command: 45

 

8. Trent Grindlinger – C,1B

HT/WT: 6’3/211 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: Tennessee | Hometown: Huntington Beach, CA | Projected Age: 20.11

Grindlinger was a highly touted prepster at Huntington Beach, ranking just outside the Top 200 in our 2025 rankings, but he landed at Tennessee after not hearing his name called. Despite a logjam behind the plate, he cracked the lineup full time in April and never looked back, racking up 14 extra-base hits from April 3rd onward. Now a draft-eligible sophomore, he’s ready to take on a full-time role for the Volunteers.

A big, burly hitter, Grindlinger pairs brute strength and solid bat-to-ball skills. He hasn’t changed his swing mechanics a ton since high school, maintaining a slightly crouched stance with a high handset pre-swing. It’s a short, compact swing with explosive bat speed, and his ability to live on the barrel stood out down the stretch.

Grindlinger has yet to sell out for pull-side power, rather lacing line drives up the middle and to the opposite field with ferocity. He has posted plus exit velocities, but he will need to add more loft to his swing. He pairs the power with very good contact skills in the zone, but he can get jumpy on spin and expand the zone at a high clip. We’ll see how the offense progresses across a full season, but the upside is high.

His athleticism has improved, and most scouts believe he can withstand the demands of catching. He has solid catch-and-throw skills and arm strength, though he needs to refine his blocking, receiving, and agility. He will get ample opportunities behind the dish in 2027, and if the defense improves, that will help his case.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 50 | Power: 60 | Run: 30 | Field: 50 | Arm: 50

 

9. Chase Fralick – C,1B

HT/WT: 6’2/227 | Bat/Throw: L/R | School: Auburn | Hometown: Peachtree City, GA | Projected Age: 21.10

Once committed to Virginia on a tennis scholarship, the Peachtree City product has been one of the premier hitters in the SEC since arriving at Auburn.

A career .324 hitter, Fralick has always had feel for the barrel and natural feel for the zone. Arguably the biggest progression from year one to year two was his power, jumping from 4 home runs to 20 while cutting his groundball rate and increasing his flyball rate by 10 percentage points to 33% in 2026.

Standing 6-foot-2, Fralick provides a physical frame behind the dish that has taken big strides defensively, specifically with pitch framing. He displays really intriguing arm strength to bases, throwing out nearly 40% of runners who attempted to steal in 2026. Against southpaws, Fralick does his best damage middle-in, while he succeeds more often middle-away against right-handers. He consistently puts together professional at-bats, knowing when to let an A-swing rip and when to shorten up and move baserunners.

Whether Fralick catches at the next level is up for debate, as he’ll likely play a corner infield spot then. That said, you know what you’re getting offensively: a high-floor bat with an instinctive approach, contact skills, and a track record of production.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 55 | Power: 55 | Run: 30 | Field: 45 | Arm: 55

 

10. Ryan McPherson – RHP

HT/WT: 6’3/215 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: Mississippi State | Hometown: Hollywood, FL | Projected Age: 21.6

One of Mississippi State’s most reliable relievers as a freshman, McPherson made the jump into the rotation and shined before an unfortunate injury derailed his campaign. That said, he came back down the stretch and pitched well at USA Collegiate National Team training camp in June and July.

 

McPherson’s game is built around power. He has a workhorse frame with abundant strength, and he brings solid athleticism on the mound with uptempo mechanics. McPherson’s fastball is strong, sitting in the mid-90s with considerable life through the zone. He’ll add and subtract horizontal action, but one thing stays constant: he has impressive carry and ride due to backspin created at release. McPherson has no issue commanding the baseball on the top rail, and he’ll bully the opposition in that manner.

To pair with the heater, McPherson has a plus kick-change that he sells extremely well. Sitting in the upper-80s, it’s an extremely low-spin offering with tunneling traits, confidence, and shape manipulation. It’s a true out pitch, boasting a 49% whiff and 40% chase rate in 2026. McPherson wraps up his arsenal with two power breaking balls: a potent upper-80s cutter/slider hybrid and a mid-80s downer curveball. Both offerings have above-average upside, landing them for strikes and getting whiffs below the zone.

A strike-thrower through and through, McPherson projects as a starter at the next level, and a darn good one at that.

Scouting Grades: Fastball: 60 | Slider: 55 | Curveball: 55 | Change: 60 | Command: 50

 

FOR THE REST OF JUST BASEBALL’S TOP 50 LIST - https://www.justbaseball.com/mlb-draft/mlb-draft-top-college-prospects/

MACK – Three more possibilities for Mets first pick

 


We continue with three more players that easily could be available when the Mets pick in the first round of the 2027 draft:

 

Chase Fuller - SS/RHP - Lincoln HS (Fla.)

6-3/205 – RHH

Career – 100-G, .313/.470/.488, 8-HR, 47-RBI

    2026 -  . 35-G, .327/.514

Son of NFL star, Corey Fuller.

Perfect Game ranked him as the number one high school prospect in this draft. Baseball America has him as a 5-star prospect.

Offense wise, straight stance with short stride. Rotates violently behind his lead leg with a remarkably quick barrel through the zone. Swings hard and has big bat speed. Not much swing-and-miss… yet. Exit speed clocked at 103. Owns some of the best raw power for the HS class eligible in this draft. Potential for 30+ home run seasons. Also, fast. 6.39 second 60-yard dash.

Defense wise, arm strength is his top tool. Does throw a fastball up to 99, so there is a possibility of him being a 2-way player. Primarily a shortstop but is projected to move to third as he beefs up.

Pitching wise, used as a closer. Fastball is primary pitch.

Me?

First, if the Mets want to draft Fuller, they better pick early. This is one of the top players in this season’s crop of elite players.

Steans is well known for picking ‘the best player available’ but even he might admit that the current Mets have enough middle infield prospects for a while. Add to that the fact that the Mes don’t develop two-way players plus you would never ‘waste’ a first round pick on a reliever, I would pass here and move on to one of the other top players in this draft.

 

Carter Hadnot, SS, Aquinas HS (Calif.)

18/yrs, old - 6-2/175 – SWH –

Perfect Game had him ranked as the 5th top HS prospect for this draft. Baseball America has him as a 5-start prospect.

Offense wise, medium, straight stance from both sides. Knee raised trigger. Very fast hands. Keen ability to back-spin the ball. Short, quick swing from both sides. Right now, contact over power but that will change in the future. Little more polished on the left side. Flatter swing on right. 6.54-60yd. Lots of physical projection remains.

Defense wise, pure middle-fielder. Fluid movements through the ball. Plenty of arm strength and more to come. Quick, twitchy hands. Projected to be a high-level defender. One of the top defensive infielders in the draft. Should stick on short.

Will be 19.2 on draft day. Announced on 10-20 that he was committed to Oklahoma which makes you wonder if he will opt out of the draft. I mean, why commit this late and then turn pro?

Me?

Again, I don’t need to draft a shortstop this early. Plus, in this NIL world, he can go to school and hone his craft there.

Hadnot is very talented, but I would pass.

 

Kinon Bastian, OF/2B, The First Academy (Fla.)

17/years old - 5-11/180 – RHH

33-G, .397, .529-OBP, 31-H, 18-RBI, 35-R

Lean and strong athlete. Compact build who runs well. MVP in 17U UBC East. Perfect Game grade: 10.

Offense wise, pretty swing and potential plus raw power. Medium, open stance. Regular 100+ EV's. 6.67 runner in the sixty. 101.8 exit velo. Standout bat speed and power. Power to all fields. One of fastest hands in draft class. Highly athletic with a strong combination of speed and strength.

Defense wise, solid arm. Center field athleticism and speed. Outfield throws low-to-mid 90s. Overall, rates as a solid defender in the outfield with a strong arm.

Me?

I love strong defensive outfielders so Bastion checks that box. The only downside I see here is no one is bragging on the amount of home runs he had at the high school level. Still, he shows power to all the fields and time plus development can create more balls going over the walls of baseball.

I would consider drafting Kinon and would assign a scout to follow him closely during his senior year.


Tom Brennan - My Mets Prospects #16 Thru #20

 


TODAY, THE 16-20 FIVE!


Here we go with…

Three oft-injured position players, and 2 control-strong pitchers (but no partridge in a pear tree).


16) D’Andre Smith 

Smith I probably have ranked too high here, but when he finally got healthy and on a roll in August and September, he hit .290/.370/.495 needs to sustain his late 2026 surge into 2027. 

His 32 games in AAA, he hit .294/.389/.505 with just 24 Ks plus 14 walks. He stole 20 of 23 in 70 games in 2026. He is a solid outfield defender and can also handle 2B if needed. I wish he had 130 games in 2026, to better gauge him. 

He’s 25, 5’9” 180, and was the 149th overall pick in 2022. I could conceivably see the righty bat as a versatile, cheap 5th outfielder, potentially, in 2027. 

To possibly get there?  Stay healthy.


17) Trey Snyder 

Not to be confused with Dee Snider of Twisted Sister, or Trea Turner, Trey Snyder was injured for much of early 2026.

But the 20 year old, the 144th overall pick in 2024, had a strong second half.  His stat line in 75 games in 2026, some of which were in Brooklyn, was .289/.348/.392. 

He stole 28 of 32, and 69 of 81 in 190 games in 2025 and 2026.

He's played 2nd, 3rd, a little SS, and the outfield, displaying Super Joe versatility.  He will either start out in AA Binghamton or get more seasoning in Brooklyn first.  

Projection? Future utility player, most likely, unless he has a big break out in 2027 at age 21.  

Not small - he is a 6’1”, 200 righty hitter.  I see a big 2027 for Snyder.


18) Boston Baro 

Baro, an overslot 8th rounder in 2023 out of high school, got hurt late in 2025, and it carried over for nearly all of 2026.

He hit well in his 11 games in 2026, but just 11 games is not good. This ain’t football.

The prior season, at age 20 and all in Brooklyn, the lefty-hitting 6 footer Baro hit just .224 in 103 games, stealing 28 of 30 bases.

He needs to get healthy and really strut his stuff in 120+ games in 2027. 

Off to Arizona he goes, and hopefully he tears it up there during the rest of the AFL season. (Slow start, but 2 hits, including a HR and 4 RBIs, in a recent AFL game).


19) Gary Gill Hill 

I am totally over the Hill in favor of Hill. Why? Control.

You see, everyone loves his control. Will Hill be a righty Zac Thornton?

Like Zac, Hill is not a flamethrower, but he is effective nonetheless. 

He was acquired at the trade deadline, having been a 6th round pick by the Rays out of high school in 2022.

Just 29 walks in 140 innings, but 160 hits allowed, pitching as a 21 year old. His low pitch counts allowed him to go 9-3, in 26 starts, in an era of low win, low innings-per-start minor league starters. He had a 4.25 ERA in part because his ERA was 5.50 in his 5th, 6th, and 7th innings. 

PLEASE PASS GILL HILL AN EXTRA PORTION OF STAMINA!

In 5 post-trade starts with AA Binghamton, he was 2-0, 3.76, and in a single AAA start, he allowed just one run over 5 innings.

He surrendered a high 35 home runs over 276 innings in 2025 and 2026, but again, that was at ages 20 and 21. 

I can see him pitching for the Mets at some point in 2027. 

Seems he is a future SP-4 or SP-5.

I probably should have switched Hill to # 16 and moved D’Andre Smith down to # 19, but, no matter: 

It is what the duo achieves in 2027 that will ultimately count.


20) Garrett Stratton 

Stratton quietly (to me, anyway) was an an excellent reliever in 2026. 

A 20th rounder in 2025, I just had to rank him as my #20 here.

Stratton turned 23 this August. The 6’2”, 200 righty reliever went 5-5, 2.51, with 8 saves, an eye-catching 87 Ks in 65 IP, and a 1.08 WHIP. 

He had a 1.52 ERA in 23 AA outings, and 4 outings and 4 runs in 5.1 IP with Syracuse.

Keep climbing. 

I’d expect Stratton to see some opportunity in the NY Mets pen during 2027, which would be a very fast climb for a late round 2025 pick. An impressive final round selection indeed…good job by the draft team.


Next article up? My # 11 thru # 15. Onward and upward.

That’ it for today.

10/24/26

MACK – Just Baseball – Top 10 Prep Prospects in 2027 MLB Draft

 

1              Dylan Seward                    SS

HT/WT: 6’0/177 | Bat/Throw: S/R | School: Norco (Eastvale, CA) | Commitment: Tennessee | Projected Age: 18.10

California hasn’t produced a top-five prep pick since Marcelo Mayer in 2021, but Dylan Seward should end that streak in 2027. The switch-hitting talent is an incredibly gifted athlete with advanced tools and elite speed, and he’s locked in as the top high school player in the class.

Seward will carry a high floor defensively, as he’s one of the more decorated infield defenders available. Playing with confidence and composure, Seward has the makings of a plus shortstop defender. His twitch is evident in his actions, with strong lateral range and a gliding style, paired with a strong internal clock, exquisite body control, and quick exchanges. It’s above-average arm strength across the diamond, too. He should contend for Gold Gloves at the next level.

At the plate, Seward offers tantalizing upside, though there are some rough edges to smooth over in the coming months. Both iterations of his swing show repeatable mechanics, with a rhythmic waggle and a compact path. Scouts currently prefer the right-handed swing, which features a flatter plane and better barrel control than his left-handed swing, which has more loft through the zone. Seward isn’t afraid to use the entire field to his advantage, driving the ball into gaps with authority from the left side and showing a more pull-oriented approach from the right.

He has surprising power for his stature, coiling well and producing electric bat speed from both sides thanks to lightning-quick hands and explosive hips. He has generated robust exit velocities with wood bats, up to 107 MPH at times, and most believe he has above-average juice at the end of the day. With 80-grade speed in the back pocket, he’s not afraid to use his legs to produce extra-base hits, and he’ll be a legitimate base-stealer at the next level.

 

2              Malachi Butler                   SS

HT/WT: 6’3/190 | Bat/Throw: L/R | School: McEachern (Powder Springs, GA) | Commitment: Georgia Tech | Projected Age: 17.10

In a polished crop of prep shortstops, Malachi Butler looks to be the best of the bunch. He’s got the size, hitterish traits, and defensive prowess to be an early first-round pick, and that’s without mentioning he’s one of the youngest eligible players (17 years, 10 months old on draft day).

Butler possesses a silky-smooth left-handed swing with a wide base, excellent balance, and a calm move through the baseball. He’s direct and quick to the ball, with pristine bat-to-ball skills. Butler rarely whiffs, stays on velocity consistently, and adjusts well to secondary pitches. He’s unafraid to spray the ball around the yard and regularly attack the gaps with ease. Butler will make sound swing decisions, and he’s added a bit more aggression at the plate to stave off passivity concerns. There’s not a ton of holes to poke in the hit tool.

Power isn’t a big part of his game yet, though scouts believe he’ll add more as he develops. He has developed more bat speed and consistently finds the barrel, though he sometimes lacks leverage in his swing. However, he hits the ball hard enough at this stage to project average power, especially if he can pull the ball more.

While he’s merely an average runner, Butler moves extremely well at shortstop, and he has the actions and arm strength to stick at the position long-term. Crisp actions, strong lateral range, and smooth transfers point to above-average defense at a key position on the diamond. If he moves elsewhere, his size and tools fit best at third base.

Boasting this kind of well-roundedness at this age is impressive, and it should lead to the Georgia Tech commit being selected in the first half of the first round next summer.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 60 | Power: 50 | Run: 50 | Field: 55 | Arm: 55

 

3. George Ferguson – RHP

HT/WT: 6’4/216 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: Abilene (Abilene, TX) | Commitment: Texas | Projected Age: 18.8

A native of Abilene, Texas, Ferguson is looking for a storybook ending to his high school career after an incredible summer showing.

A physical athlete with an unorthodox delivery, he is the best prep arm in the class thanks to outstanding arm strength, pitchability, and arsenal strength. It’s not a delivery you’d expect from a starting pitching prospect, with violence and recoil at release and a tall-and-fall style that lacks efficient lower-half drive. Despite this, Ferguson repeats his mechanics well and frequently pounds the strike zone, throwing strikes over 70% of the time during the summer circuit.

His fastball has all the makings of a plus pitch, sitting in the mid-90s with downhill plane and a robust mix of ride and run through the zone. It’s a true bat-misser (54% whiff rate in 2026) with impressive spin rates, consistently ranging from 2,500 to 2,800 RPM.

He pairs this with a hard, diving change-up in the upper-80s with excellent conviction and feel, racking up empty swings and chases below the zone. He mostly reserves it for left-handed hitters, though he’s shown confidence throwing it against right-handed hitters. It’s an easy plus offering at this stage, and some scouts will slap a double-plus grade on it depending on who you ask. His final offering is a mid-80s slider that has added power and sharpness, with a mix of depth and sweep that makes it an out pitch against righties. It lags behind the fastball-cambio combination, but it has enough traits and power to reach above-average upside.

The Texas commit is as well-rounded as they come on the mound, and despite the inefficiencies that require additional polish, Ferguson has a chance to be the first prep arm off the board in July.

Scouting Grades: Fastball: 60 | Slider: 55 | Change: 60 | Command: 55

 

4. Graham Houston – SS

HT/WT: 6’1/175 | Bat/Throw: S/R | School: Venice (Nokomis, FL) | Commitment: Louisiana State | Projected Age: 18.11

By now, amateur baseball fans should be well acquainted with the Houston family. Graham’s older brother, Marek, was a first-round pick of the Minnesota Twins in 2025 after a stellar three-year career at Wake Forest. Graham has the same polish and tools, though many believe he’s a better prospect than his brother at this stage.

A true switch-hitter, Houston is a bat-to-ball artist with super quick hands and a direct path to the ball. He covers every quadrant of the zone exceptionally well, posting a 96% in-zone contact rate this summer, and his affinity for fastballs is equally impressive, with north-of-90% contact overall and in the zone. Houston is an aggressive swinger, posting chase rates around 30%, but the pure contact skills and adjustability help keep strikeouts to a minimum.

He won’t be a huge power threat, but Houston has a knack for lacing line drives into the gaps and letting his above-average speed do the work. He does have better power projection from the right side because his swing plane has more loft, though most expect him to have fringe-average power at best.

Like his brother, he’s a smooth shortstop defender with exceptional lateral range and controlled actions. His instincts are great; he gets solid reads off the bat, takes a quick first step, and has above-average arm strength and accuracy across the diamond. Scouts expect Houston to become a plus defender.

His profile is incredibly well-rounded, and he could be drafted higher than his brother. If he goes undrafted, Houston would enroll at Louisiana State.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 60 | Power: 45 | Run: 55 | Field: 60 | Arm: 55

 

5. Carter Hadnot – SS

HT/WT: 6’2/175 | Bat/Throw: S/R | School: Aquinas (Rialto, CA) | Commitment: N/A | Projected Age: 19.2

Hadnot is a perfect example of how you draw up a prospect. With a wiry, lithe build and plenty of projection, he’s an explosive athlete with an outstanding glove and offensive upside that has trended up over the past calendar year.

Hadnot projects to be the best glove in the shortstop class. He glides across the dirt with little effort, controls his body extremely well, and has a bouncy style to his game. His exchanges are smooth and quick, and he adjusts to the ball extremely well. Additionally, Hadnot has shown more arm strength, now grading as above average. As a result, Hadnot can be a double-plus glove, which makes him the best defender among the top shortstops in this class.

Offensively, Hadnot grew into more extra-base impact on the summer circuit. As a switch-hitter, scouts prefer his smooth, controlled left-handed swing to the right-handed version, which has less barrel control and a flatter plane. It’s been serviceable so far, though scouts are split on whether he can remain a full-time switch-hitter. From the left side, he backspins the ball well and has loft to his swing plane, which has led to a few balls over the right-field fence.

That said, most of his impact will come in the gaps, where he’ll use his plus speed to generate doubles and triples. Hadnot rarely expands the zone, though he can get too passive on pitches inside the zone, leaving him behind in counts early. Despite this, he has solid bat-to-ball skills and should play more aggressively.

His glove gives him a high floor as a prospect, and if the bat continues to surge in production, Hadnot has all-star appearances in his future. In late October, Hadnot announced his commitment to Oklahoma.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 55 | Power: 40 | Run: 60 | Field: 70 | Arm: 55

 

6. Jack Leeper – OF

HT/WT: 6’2/200 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: St. Francis (Menlo Park, CA) | Commitment: Stanford | Projected Age: 18.5

Possessing some of the best offensive upside in the class, Leeper looks the part walking off the bus. He’s a physical athlete with broad shoulders and strength throughout his body, and he stands out on the diamond among his peers. It’s not just his physicality and athleticism; his bat is extremely potent from the right side of the plate.

Leeper’s operation looks unorthodox, but it works. He starts with an open front leg and a noteworthy bat waggle that loads his hands into the launch position, then flicks his hands forward with a flatter entry into the zone than most. This lets Leeper cover the top rail of the strike zone well, and he’ll consistently barrel up pitches in the zone, posting a 93% in-zone contact rate this summer. He tends to expand the zone frequently, though he’s shown the ability to barrel up the ball regardless of its location. It’s an impressive hit tool that projects as plus.

While he hasn’t yet sold out for power in-game, he’s shown robust bat speed and plus raw power in batting practice. With an exit velocity of 110 MPH already attached to his name with a wood bat, scouts expect that power to translate in due time.

Leeper has turned in plus run times, which help him cover plenty of ground in the outfield, where he can play all three positions with average defense. He’s been trotted out primarily in center, though below-average arm strength will likely limit him to left field as he adds more mass to his frame. This will put pressure on the bat to perform, but it’s hard to envision Leeper not producing in bunches.

His demographic and Stanford commitment may scare some suitors off, but based on talent level, Leeper has earned a first-round grade.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 60 | Power: 60 | Run: 60 | Field: 50 | Arm: 40

 

7. Sebastian Castillo – SS,3B

HT/WT: 6’0/195 | Bat/Throw: R/R | School: Byron Nelson (Justin, TX) | Commitment: Louisiana State | Projected Age: 18.8

Considered one of the more balanced profiles on this list, Castillo has a track record of success against elite competition over recent years.

In the box, he features a slightly open stance with a calm load and leg lift, followed by tight turns and premium bat speed. His swing decisions and contact ability also rank among the best for his age, evidenced by an in-zone whiff rate below 10% and multiple triple-digit exit velocities across premier circuit events. Castillo sees the baseball best on the outer half, unafraid to rifle balls to the opposite field while still letting his hands fly against pitches middle-in.

Defensively, he projects to stick on the dirt, showcasing good glove work and plus arm strength. Whether he stays at shortstop is up for debate, as his projection could push him to third base. Castillo is a fine runner, posting average home-to-first times and using his athleticism to create good angles on the left side of the infield.

Though most scouts view him primarily as a bat, he’s been up to 93 MPH on the mound, filling the zone with a tight, bullet-shaped breaking ball. Regardless, Castillo’s tools, headlined by his bat, rightfully place him near the top of our rankings. Castillo is committed to Louisiana State, led by head coach Jay Johnson.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 60 | Power: 50 | Run: 50 | Field: 50 | Arm: 60

 

8. Juan Diaz – SS,2B

HT/WT: 6’0/180 | Bat/Throw: S/R | School: IMG Academy (Hialeah, FL) | Commitment: Florida | Projected Age: 18.10

He might not be the most imposing in stature, but Juan Diaz is one of the most frustrating at-bats in this entire prep class. A former Florida State commit, Diaz flipped to the Noles’ in-state rival from Gainesville in early September, though he may not make it to campus. The Miami native’s profile has a couple of standout qualities, at the plate and beyond.

His bat-to-ball is at the very top of the class, as evidenced by his sub-15% whiff rate on the summer circuit. In fact, he didn’t swing and miss at a single pitch during his weekend at East Coast Pro this year. You could argue he’s a top-three switch hitter in the entire prep class, with positive returns from both sides of the dish. His swing is fluid and definitely a little longer from the left side, where he’s gotten most of his reps to date, but it’s more compact and connected from the right side as well. That length as a left-handed hitter has created some issues getting to his pull side, but this profile seems designed to pepper the gaps regardless.

The upside isn’t confined to the bat either. He’s a plus runner, if not better, with sub-6.5-second 60-yard dash times this summer and multiple 60-grade home-to-first times from both sides of the plate.

It’s hard to fully own the heralded shortstop position at IMG Academy, but Diaz has shown this summer he can maintain that role through his senior season and into his professional career, despite likely having to split time with Max Hemenway this spring.

Overall, there’s a lot to like here. Diaz has quick hands, lots of twitch, and next-level instincts. That’ll be good enough to get him a seven-figure deal this summer alongside a couple of his teammates.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 55 | Power: 40 | Run: 70 | Field: 55 | Arm: 50

 

9. Lubin Rincon – SS

HT/WT: 6’3/185 | Bat/Throw: L/R | School: The Bennett School (Pearland, TX) | Commitment: Texas | Projected Age: 18.9

One of the class’s more polished shortstop prospects, Rincon is a lean, wiry athlete with a gorgeous left-handed swing, and scouts believe there’s another version of his game waiting to be unlocked. He has a track record of hitting at big events, and while he’s not as flashy as some of his peers, his instincts and high IQ make him a high-floor prospect to follow.

Rincon’s swing is low-effort and balanced, with a simple, direct path to the ball and tight turns through the zone. His contact prowess stands out the most in his profile, dominating pitches inside the zone and adjusting well to secondary offerings. He makes smart swing decisions and will rack up plenty of walks, making him a legitimate on-base threat.

He’s not as twitchy as others, which limits his power projection moving forward, but he has solid bat speed and barrel feel. Most of that power will play to his pull side, and most believe he’ll grow into fringe-average power, if not average. He will need to incorporate consistent leverage in his swing to do that, as he tends to let his hands do most of the work right now.

On defense, Rincon projects as more of a consistent defender than a flashy one. His actions are smooth and controlled, and quick exchanges let his average arm strength play up. His tools may ultimately play better at second base, though he should stick at shortstop unless he comes across a better defender. A Texas commit, Rincon will likely climb the board if his tools improve during the spring.

Scouting Grades: Hit: 55 | Power: 45 | Run: 50 | Field: 50 | Arm: 50

 

10. Connor Salerno – LHP

HT/WT: 6’4/225 | Bat/Throw: R/L | School: Sun Valley (Indian Trail, NC) | Commitment: Mississippi State | Projected Age: 19.0

A well-built southpaw who has performed across multiple summers, Salerno enters the fall as the top southpaw in the prep class. He’s a unique arm to dissect because his quick-paced mechanics and herky-jerky motion create significant deception, even with head-whack and violence. Despite the noise in the operation, Salerno repeats his delivery extremely well, peppering the strike zone.

He sinks well into his back hip and drives himself down the mound, creating a lower arm slot with width at release. Salerno operated in the 92-95 MPH range this summer, peaking at 97 MPH in shorter spurts. The fastball shape leans more toward a dead zone profile (similar carry and run metrics), though his command and VAA traits will let the heater play up from its perceived velocity. It’s particularly impressive on the top rail, boasting a 40% whiff rate in the upper-third and higher. It’s an above-average heater right now, and with more velocity, it should become a plus pitch.

His best secondary is a low-to-mid-80s slider that mixes lift and sweep, and his feel and command of it stand out. It’s a tough pitch to pick up out of his hand, and he can land it in the lower quadrants of the zone, with a 71% strike rate and 56% whiff rate this summer. He relied on this one-two punch often, sprinkling in a fringe-average mid-80s cambio with alright shape and feel at this stage. Scouts would like to see it sharpened and used more to earn a starting role at the next level.

Given the size, command, and pure stuff, the Mississippi State commit should be a rotational piece once fully developed. If he makes it to Starkville, he would be eligible as a sophomore in 2029.

Scouting Grades: Fastball: 55 | Slider: 55 | Change: 45 | Command: 55

 

For the rest of Just Baseball’s Top 50 List - https://www.justbaseball.com/mlb-draft/2027-mlb-draft-top-50-prep-prospects/#entry-244782

Guest opinion becomes big question: DOES LINDOR BOUNCE-BACK IN 2027?



We value the input from our readers, and sometimes a reader comment becomes a source of great internal discussion.  Such was a recent input from reader 
Zozo, who compiled this impressive look into the hamate health of Francisco Lindor, and whether his surgery negatively impacted his 2026 season.

He wrote the following and left us with the question, "Does Lindor fully bounce back in 2027?"

If I had to choose I would keep Lindor and sign Michael king. Linder numbers will be better next season, when he is not injured. Here is an AI synopsis of all 3 of Lindor, Holliday and Carroll who had the same injury last year. They all had down years, they are both younger but numbers are similar. 


So give Lindor a break on all this trade/drop him IMO.


1. Francisco Lindor (New York Mets)

• The Season: Lindor endured a deeply frustrating year. After breaking his left hamate bone in February, he rushed back, only to suffer a left calf strain in late April that sidelined him for an additional two months.
• The Impact: His trademark power-speed combination evaporated, yielding just 21 home runs and a career-low 3 stolen bases. Uncharacteristically, the lingering effects also led to rare mental lapses and a noticeable defensive decline at shortstop.

2. Corbin Carroll (Arizona Diamondbacks)

• The Season: Of the three, Carroll handled the initial recovery the best. After fracturing his right hamate bone in early February, his elite physical conditioning allowed him to rapidly progress through rehab and remarkably make the Diamondbacks' Opening Day lineup.
• The Impact: While he showed great durability by playing 156 games, the classic post-hamate injury side effect—a lack of grip and wrist strength—capped his offensive ceiling. His batting average slipped to .239, and his overall OPS dropped by nearly 90 points from the previous year.

3. Jackson Holliday (Baltimore Orioles)

• The Season: Holliday had the most grueling year. The young infielder missed the first 48 games of the season following his February hamate surgery. He showed a brief flash of brilliance in July (.368 AVG), but heavily fatigued down the stretch.
• The Impact: His season came to an early end in September when separate left wrist inflammation revealed a partial tear, requiring a second, season-ending surgery. He finished his sophomore campaign with just 7 home runs in 98 games.

Francisco Lindor has had a career that was spotted with injuries, and he has had the tendency to try to return too early which Zozo pointed out. If the on-field recovery time is removed from the record, Lindor actually has a pretty good track record of bouncing back. At 33 years of age next season, he is a little older than most shortstops in their prime.  He brings a .270/.340/.812 career slash line into the 2027 season and is once again expected to be a team leader and major contributor to the top of the lineup.

Question: Will he bounce back and perform to career norms?

Reese Kaplan --- Were Stearns' Pitching Choices Any Better?


Let’s continue with the David Stearns positives...

Buckle up as we will skip over the Jorge Polanco and Marcus Semien moves and shift our attention to pitching. Here we have to take our hat off in deference to the Stearns strategy, right...?

Well, topic number one would be the horrific contract for Sean Manaea.  As a refresher, Manaea is an eleven year veteran southpaw who actually owns a winning record of 85-74 with a middle of the road ERA of 4.16.  He has a moderate WHIP and generally exhibits good control.  

When he was brought on board for his first Mets season he turned in a good one.  He finished the year with a 12-6 record, a 3.47 ERA and finished 11th in the NL Cy Young voting.  

For that  effort he was paid $14.5 million on a single year free agent contract though it only cost the Mets $12 million as $2.5 was covered by an option paid by the San Francisco Giants.  His final number was a 2.9 WAR, a level he’d reached three other times in his career.  That turned out to be a good Stearns move.

Then came the 2025 off season.

Stearns bid against himself, more than doubling the salary to be paid to Manaea. Then to make matters worse he was going to take home his $25 million annual salary for not a single year but for three of them

How’d he do?

Let’s put it this way.  He was so bad when healthy that he was booted out of the starting rotation.  Between 2025 and 2026 Manaea has a losing record of 8-12 with a 5.03 ERA. That certainly does not look like $50 million well spent.  (And remember there’s another $25 million owed to him for 2027).  Stearns won’t make it to the World Series like his former employer making deals like that one.

Clay Holmes was a solid Stearns addition particularly when he made the successful transition from effective reliever to effective starter.  The same cannot be said of now Rays starting pitcher Freddy Peralta who crumbled horribly in New York.  That’s yet another negative outcome of a Sttearns roster decision.

Now Kodai Senga’s foibles as a starting pitcher cannot be blamed on Stearns as his contract was signed prior to the flight to the Big Apple for the former Brewers head baseball honcho.  

The way the season ended with Nolan McLean, Christian Scott and Zac Thornton turning in credible performances on a regular basis.  Some of the other younger pitchers are still works in progress.   

The bullpen was another up and down part of the Stearns roster construction.  On the up side were most definitely Brooks Raley, AJ Minter, Luke Weaver and Huascar Brazoban.  Naturally none of them are Mets anymore.


On the down side you had Edwin Diaz replacement Devin Williams who turned in his second consecutive subpar season, as well as a revolving door of AAAA personnel who were not able to fill the housecleaning vacancies created by the trade deadline moves.  

10/23/26

MACK – 2027 MLB Draft - An Early Mock From MLB.com

 


1. Royals: Dylan Seward, SS, Norco HS (Calif.)

Seward is a dynamic switch-hitting shortstop committed to Tennessee. He’s a double-plus runner with outstanding bat-to-ball skills from both sides of the plate. He has more than enough range and instincts to play short for a long time. He might be only 5-foot-11, but there’s plenty of impact to come.

 

2. A’s: Brendan Lawson, SS, Florida

Lawson was a solid high school prospect in 2024, but his strong commitment to Florida led to him being drafted in the 19th round, so he headed to Gainesville. He’s hit well there, getting to his power a lot more as a sophomore (19 homers, .699 SLG). He plays short for the Gators but probably moves to third as a pro.

 

3. Rockies: Tomas Valincius, LHP, Mississippi State

Valincius spent his freshman year at Virginia, then followed coach Brian O’Connor to Mississippi State and was one of the best college arms in the country in 2026 (12.3 K/9, 1.8 BB/9). He does it with a very good three-pitch mix: a fastball that sits around 95 mph, a mid-80s slider with depth that missed bats at a 48-percent clip, according to Synergy, and an effective mid-80s changeup.

 

4. Mets: Landon Hairston, OF, Arizona State

A Golden Spikes Award finalist this year, the son of former big leaguer Scott Hairston could give the family a fourth-generation big leaguer. Hairston had one of the best seasons of any college hitter in the nation, finishing his sophomore year with a .400/.509/.860 line to go along with 28 homers, 11 steals and more walks than strikeouts.

 

5. Angels: Dax Whitney, RHP, Oregon State

Whitney might have topped this list as the best college arm in the class had it not been for a torn UCL that required a hybrid Tommy John/internal brace procedure. When he’s healthy, he comes at hitters with a fastball up to 101 mph and three excellent secondaries in his slider, curve and changeup. It seems unlikely that he’s going to pitch competitively in 2027, but he could be ready to throw bullpens for teams as the Draft approaches.

 

6. Orioles: Gavin Kelly, C/2B, West Virginia

Kelly is a big reason why West Virginia made it to Omaha this year, slashing .382/.477/.725. He’s caught and played second mostly for the Mountaineers, but he’s also played plenty of outfield, using his plus speed well on both sides. There’s plenty of power to tap into, as evidenced by his 19 homers this past season.

 

7. Reds: Chris Levonas, RHP, Wake Forest

The Brewers selected Levonas No. 67 overall in 2024, but he opted to head to Wake Forest instead of signing. He’ll be one of the top college arms to consider, especially if he builds off his 10-3, 2.82 ERA, 116/33 K/BB, .171 BAA sophomore season. His fastball sat at 97 mph this year, and he uses a curve and cutter-like-slider behind it.

 

8. Tigers: Tague Davis, 1B, Louisville

Do you like power? Then Davis might be the guy for you. He led all of Division 1 with 34 homers in 2026 while slashing .355/.443/.848 for Louisville. There’s some swing-and-miss he’ll have to work on, but he fits the corner infielder masher profile well.

 

9. Blue Jays: Connor Salerno, LHP, Sun Valley HS (NC)

We interrupt this run on college players for the top high school arm in the class. Committed to Mississippi State, Salerno features a mid-90s fastball, can spin a breaking ball and has good feel for a change, all while competing well in the strike zone consistently.

 

10. Giants: Chase Fuller, SS/RHP, Lincoln HS (Fla.)

Fuller’s father, Corey, was an NFL defensive back, and Chase offers similar athleticism and strength. He’s got a terrific right-handed swing and has produced well. Most seem to prefer him as a position player, but he’s up to the low 90s on the mound, too.

Reese Kaplan -- So What Good Things Did David Stearns Do?


One of my friends recently posed a challenge to me to evaluate the positive things David Stearns has done for the Mets.

Hmmm...

Well, let’s start with run prevention.  By year’s end in 2026 the Mets outfield was markedly better than it had been in the recent past.  You’ve got to give him credit for that improvement, right?

Maybe not.

First of all, right fielder Carson Benge was indeed a revelation not only with his bat but also with his glove and his arm, too.  No one is taking potshots at Benge for anything he accomplished on the field.  There is, however, a bit of history that many people have simply not acknowledged.

We all knew that AA player Benge had a cup of coffee in AAA where over the course of 90 ABs hit a cringe worthy .178.  He was going to get a long look in Spring Training, but at the time there was a veteran around named Mike Tauchman who’d played in the majors for the Rockies, Giants, Yankees, Cubs and White Sox and was was already penciled in as the spare oufielder with Tyrone Taylor.  

The man unfortunately suffered a torn meniscus in a March 21st game which required surgery to be performed five days later.  He was then gone and it opened up a spot for Benge to make the Opening Day roster though it had not been the David Stearns plan. 

Well, it had to be better with A.J. Ewing, right?

For reasons unknown to rational thinking baseball fans, writers and executives the Mets made a puzzling deal to pry loose the overpriced and injury prone Luis Robert from the White Sox.  He was going to anchor the defense out in center field while providing ample home run power and stolen base speed.  As we all know, that scenario never quite unfolded as intended.

While Robert was on the IL the Mets reached onto the AAA roster to pluck speedy Ewing to take over as a part time player in the majors to help fill the void.  While Ewing didn’t exactly hit the ground running with the offensive side of his game but his defensive acumen was revealed almost from day one.  

He quickly went from spare part to starting center fielder which enabled the Mets to cut ties with Robert to correct this colossal failure.  So that move wasn’t apparently a planned success by David Stearns either. 

We will give credit to Stearns for the 26th guy on the bench who turned into a starting first baseman in the form of Jared Young.  When he made the roster no one was overjoyed as this now 30 year old AAAA level player had failed to establish himself as a starting caliber offensive tool during his trials in the majors dating back to his 26 year old rookie season with the Cubs in 2022.  

During 2024 in AAA he hit 21 HRs and drove in 72 while hitting a robust .310 in just over a half season’s worth of ABs. 

From there he wandered off for an appearance in Korea and then split time between the various levels of the Mets minor league organization, finally reaching Citifield in 2025 where he hit a lackluster .188.  Consequently a 300 AB Mets season with 9 HRs and 39 RBIs with a .266 average was unexpected, to say the least.  

Still, as much of a surprise as it was, not too many people are confident the Mets have anything more than a decent bench player for 2027.  Stearns does get credit for this 2025 addition.

MACK - Chain Position Analysis - Third Base

 


MACK – Chain Position Analysis - Third Base

 

We move further right to my old home… third base. 

We just left analyzing a position with tremendous depth (shortstop)… now we move on to one that seems to be depending on one future player and a bunch of also-rans.

Let’s jump right in.

 

RED PROSPECTS

 

MLB/Mets - Bo Bichette – (28) – RHH - let’s face it… if the Mets could secure the services of this guy for the next three seasons, none of us would have to worry about this position until the next decade. Bichette got off to the kind of start many new players do, but by the end of the season, he proved to all Mets fans how talented he is. Right now, where he plays next season is up for grabs. 

If he comes back, the immediate future of the other RED PROSPECTS listed here comes to a screeching halt. 

If not, you could see him on opening day. 

Either way, this looks like quite the one-two punch.

 

AAA/Syracuse – Jefferson Rojas – (21) – RHH - Thank you, David Stearns. IMO, you couldn’t have gotten a better return for Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor. Rojas’ 2026 season consisted of 27-HR, 93-RBI, 21-SB, .274/.338/.505/.843. Played 35 games for the Mets… hit 12-HR. That’s good, right? Hit .280 for AA/Binghamton and then .308 for AAA/Syracuse. .929-OPS for AA/Binghamton, followed by 1.037 for AAA/Syracuse. 32-K in 144 Mets at-bats. 

Only downside here is only 26-AB at the AAA level. I simply wouldn’t rush him whether Bo comes back or not. Let him play upstate up to the ASB then show him the way to where David Wright played. 

This looks like a great trade.

 

BLUE PROSPECTS

 

MLB/Mets – Christopher Morel – (22) – RHH - also plays DH, 1B, and OF – signed with Mets on July 1, 2026 after being released by the Marlins. Dominated in AAA/Syracuse (.321/.382/.716, 1.098), 12-HR in 109-AB (only 28-K). 30-AB for the Mets (.200). Look, you can’t ignore a four digit OPS at any level, especially the one just below the majors. Morel was a breath of fresh air and offers this team utility versatility. 

He played every field position last season other than catcher. Having him on your major league 26 opens up at least two other slots. 

Me? He opens in Queens next season.

 

AAA/Syracuse – Christian Arroyo – (31) – RHH – also plays 2B & SS – has already produced 2.1 MLB WAR – played 2026 exclusively for AAA/Syracuse: 237-AB, 44-K, 8-HR, 45-RBI, 18-BB, .278/.331/.435/.765. Another pleasant surprise from someone signed to fill a slot. Me? 

A perfect AAAA infielder to play everyday at the AAA level and keep fresh in case of any MLB injuries going forward. Needs to stay healthy himself (2026 wrist injury).

 

AA/Binghamton – Jacob Reimer – (22) – RHH – also plays 1B (well) – 4th rd. 2022 - let’s face it… Reimer should be a RED Prospect, but… he isn’t due to his inability to prove his cred. I’ve seen him as high as the 5th Mets prospect. I currently don’t have him in my top 20. Played four levels in 2026 but primarily for AA/Binghamton: 297-AB, 87-K, 8-HR, 40-RBI, 45-BB, .232/.335/.384/.719. .280 last 90 days - .179 vs. LHP  

I’m sorry. Stats like this aren’t worthy of being ranked as the 5th top team prospect. Reimer needs to show me a lot more before I even consider believing in him again.

 

A/St. Lucie – Jake Ogden – (22) – RHH – also plays SS & 2B – UDFA 2026 – batted .315 for the University of Miami in 2026… .336 in 2025. Have no idea why no one drafted him. Our find. Only 41 professional at-bats (St. Lucie) this year: .268/.404/.366/.770. I know he didn’t play much, but I’m replacing Colin Houck in A+/Brooklyn with this guy. Houck? Might drop so fast he’s quickly forgotten. Ogden could make things interesting in a few years.

 

ALMOST PROSPECTS

 

FCL/Mets – Roybert Herrera – (19) – LHH – signed as IFA 1-15-2024 - also plays 1B & 2B – played 2026 exclusively for the FCL Mets: 86-AB, 25-K, 1-HR, 15-RBI, 13-BB, .244/.359/.314/.673. Solid .285 season in 2025 for the DSLO Mets team. Spent time on 7-day IL in 2026. Has shown contact ability, some power potential, and speed. Gets on base additionally through walks and HBPs. Raw. Gained experience last year that I see him applying this season for one of the Florida teams, if not both.

 

MACK SPIN: 

There is a lot of nice things I can say here about all of these players, but the bottom line is that the future of this position for the Mets is currently dependent one player (Rojas). If he goes down with a season-ending or career-threatening injury, the Mets will have to turn to one of their middle infield prospects and convert that player to third or look for someone not currently on the roster.

As I said earlier, everything would be A+ if Bo stayed around for three years. However, this post graded out that he doesn’t. Too much to be determined on one future prospect that hasn’t played one major league inning, against major league pitching.

 

RATING - B