REMEMBER JONAH TONG’S SEPTEMBER GATORADE MOMENT?
IT WAS HIS LAST ONE FOR A WHILE, IT SEEMS
Nolan McLean?
We all got excited about him in the minors, and he has succeeded as a MLB pitcher. So, our excitement was indeed warranted.
But…
After seeing the struggles of the likes of Tong, Wenninger, Thornton, Sproat, Hamel, and Vasil when they get to AAA, it is hard to get excited about ANY prospect pitcher until they get to, and succeed at, AAA.
Who on earth in 2025 could have envisioned that through June 23, 2026, Tong, Wenninger, and Thornton combined would have given up 110 runs in 168 innings?
If I guessed pre-2026, I would have guessed that figure would have been, at most, 50 runs in 168 innings.
And, when I looked a few days ago, they were a combined 5-15. WHAT!!
No correlation whatsoever to 2025’s outstanding performances by that trio, keeping in mind that performance level was almost entirely below AAA in 2025.
I’m still a believer in those 3, and Thornton was great vs. Philly the other night.
Having thought about it early this year, it hit me that while the average major league team may hit around .250, If you were to teleport an entire average AAA team to the majors, they probably hit about .175, and if you did the same with your average AA team, they would probably hit about .115.
Keeping that in mind should temper any enthusiasm about Mets prospect pitchers in the future. In other words, just because they’ve done well at AA, it doesn’t mean a hill of beans.
My only minors pitcher I’m therefore currently modestly excited about in the short term is Nate Lavender.
Sure, his ERA is 4.78 due to a few bad relief outings, but his 46 Ks in 26 innings grabs my attention.
Will he be any good at the MLB level? Only time will tell.
It is a relief, frankly, that Reid Garrett, Tylor Megill, and Dedniel Nunez will each return from TJS at the start of 2027.
Who, after all, can truly count on any Mets pitching prospects?
Besides McLean, of course.
MY BRIEF TOP 30 METS PROSPECTS THOUGHTS
I will keep this short.
I looked at the list of 30 Mets prospects, at the minor league season halfway point.
I categorize them in three buckets:
Playing better than I expected: number one
Playing about as I expected: number two
Playing worse than I expected or injured: number three
Assessment? Pretty bleak.
In category one, I only have one (3%):
Mitch Voit - as above average, playing really well after a slow season start in frigid and windy Brooklyn.
He can hit, hit with some power, field great, and run like the wind.
In category two, I have just 5 (13%):
Nick Morabito, Elian Pena, Zach Thornton, Cleiner Ramirez and Yovanny Rodriguez.
And, of these five, three of them are in the very low minor leagues, so they are too early to project.
Morabito jumped from Cat 3 in May to Cat 2 with an excellent June. June slash: .304/.390/.478.
Another month like that? Category one.
Keep it up, Nick.
In category three, I have an astounding 23 prospects (77%):
Those 23 are playing below average to well below average vs. my pre-season expectations, or have been injured, or both.
Nope. It doesn’t get much more bleak than that. Only on Bleecker St.
Take a look at the Mets top 30 prospects on the Mets site yourself.
See if you agree or disagree with my categorizations.
Lastly…Categories 1, 2, and 3 above total 29, not 30. Here is why:
I left Cole Mathis out of this list, since the Mets new # 14 prospect was just acquired in a trade. He was doing well enough in High A ball with the Cubs.
Too early to evaluate him as a Met. I am hoping for Category 1.
IMPRESSING THE BOSS? NOT!
You remember that old Account Temps commercial, with the guy calling in sick, and his boss saying, “don’t you worry about it - we’ve got Bob from Account Temps”.
June was IMPRESS THE BOSS MONTH. A few impressed.
But which hitters DEPRESSED the bosses in June?
Mark Vientos 7 for 48 with 4 walks vs. 19 Ks.
Marcus Semien 14 for 78, with 7 walks vs. 22 Ks.
MJ Melendez 7 for 44, 8 walks vs. 19 Ks.
Brett Baty 11 for 75, 10 walks vs. 22 Ks, 0 HR, 4 RBIs, 5 runs.
Ronny Mauricio 1 for 12, no walks, 4 Ks.
Francisco Lindor 3 for 20, 1 walk.
- Lindor has an excuse. Rushed back from rehab. He gets a pass.
The other 5 clunkers? Bring in FIVE Bobs from Account Temps instead.
Then, find the nearest dumpster for the current 5, open the lid of said dumpster, toss in that Funky Five, and send the dumpster detritus off to parts unknown. They are playing like total garbage. Handle accordingly.
Why are fans pissed? These five.
Especially wimpy Brett Baty. Look at those crap #s. deGrom hit better,
Stearns? He let Pete go, and THIS is the garbage he gets from Baty?
What can I do here to utterly piss Baty off and wake him up? I’m trying.
Or is he really just Jarred Kelenic’s twin brother and it is simply hopeless?
Well, Kelenic actually hit much better once demoted to AAA than the next guy I mention below.
Minors?
AAA in June:
Ryan Clifford, incredibly just 8 for 81, 11 walks, 39 Ks. FRAME THAT ONE. He has started 45 games at first base this year and made 8 errors.
Of course, Clifford is representing the Mets in the upcoming Futures Game.
Me?
I’d demote him ASAP via FED X and promote Nick Lorusso, who had a great month in AA.
Nick hit .315/.398/.616, with just 13 Ks in 19 games. And added a HR 7/1.
And Lorusso has one error at first base and a total of 5 others at 2nd and 3rd, so he is flashing leather.
Better than Clifford, obviously. Blatantly. Glaringly. Make the switch, David.
Jorge Polanco? 0 for 13. He wasn’t in the line up on Tuesday nite. No rush.
He’s playing through pain, true - yes, Mets fans ARE in pain here.
I thought I would stop there on the negatives.
Except to note that going into Tuesday’s action, Syracuse, Binghamton, Brooklyn and St Lucie were a combined 33 games below .500. Last year, the 4 teams combined by this point were way above .500.
Anyway…
On a more positive note, Brooklyn (.240) and Binghamton (.228) hit much better from June 1 thru July 1, so they get a pass on hitting criticism. Yes, those numbers are MUCH BETTER than previous months.
OK, CHILDREN, CHILDREN, NOW, NOW…PLAY NICE TOGETHER
The NY Post had some quotable comments from a fella named Steve Cohen, one of which was essentially that there was a chill between Messrs. Soto and Lindor last year.
Why should they be warm and friendly?
The 2 were only paid about $100 million combined last year.
You and I could see them getting along much better if they were paid a reasonable amount last year like, say, $200 million.
Cohen seemed to think that situation with the duo had improved this year.
For $100 million a year, they should, tho’, be the ultimate team-first duo.
One for all, all for one?
That they were any less than that, frankly, is nonsense.
Give me a team full of Benge and Ewing guys, hungry, eager guys.
Any day. And twice on Sunday.
But…I am happy to report that the Yanqueros from El Bronx are 2-8 in their last 10 games. Misery LOVES company. I guess missing Judge does hurt, after all.









