In Parts 1–4, we examined what Milwaukee has built, how it replenishes talent, what Stearns contributed and how the Brewers compare with the Mets.
The finding was clear: Milwaukee has combined sustained winning with affordable production and continued replenishment. New York has expensive stars and an emerging young core, but has yet to turn that combination into dependable contention.
We closed by asking how much of New York’s roster took shape under David Stearns.
Answering that requires examining the larger assignment he inherited. Stearns was expected to stabilize an organization trying to accomplish several difficult things simultaneously, while making it more successful on the field.
Four jobs at once
From the beginning of Steve Cohen’s ownership, the Mets faced four connected assignments:
Assignment | What it required |
Win now | Field competitive MLB teams and reach the playoffs. |
Build durable leadership and infrastructure | Establish continuity and capability in baseball operations, scouting, analytics, coaching and development. |
Build and develop the farm system | Accumulate talent and turn successive groups into productive major leaguers or useful trade assets. |
Continually replenish bridge talent | Replace departing, declining or injured players while waiting for internal solutions to develop. |
The season would not pause while the organization rebuilt itself.
Cohen could authorize spending immediately. Developing players, establishing leadership and improving organizational decisions would take longer.
Experienced major leaguers helped bridge that gap. But the bridge itself required constant maintenance. Contracts expired. Players aged. Injuries created openings. Successful acquisitions became more expensive to retain.
Whenever an internal replacement was unavailable, the Mets needed another external answer.
The investment was sustained. Leadership kept changing.
The ownership-era record captures both the financial commitment and the changes among those responsible for turning it into wins.
Dollar figures in millions.
Season | GM / POBO | Manager | Record | Postseason | CBT payroll | Tax | Payroll + tax |
2021 | Alderson / Scott¹ | Luis Rojas | 77–85 | Missed | $207.7 | $0.0 | $207.7 |
2022 | Billy Eppler | Buck Showalter | 101–61 | Wild Card exit | $299.8 | $30.8 | $330.6 |
2023 | Billy Eppler² | Buck Showalter | 75–87 | Missed | $374.7 | $100.8 | $475.5 |
2024 | David Stearns | Carlos Mendoza | 89–73 | Reached NLCS | $347.7 | $97.1 | $444.8 |
2025 | David Stearns | Carlos Mendoza | 83–79 | Missed | $346.7 | $91.6 | $438.3 |
2026³ | David Stearns | Mendoza / Green | 74–88 | Missed | $358.1 | $100.9 | $459.1 |
Total |
|
| 499–473 | Two appearances | $1,934.7 | $421.3 | $2,355.9 |
¹ Alderson was team president; Scott served as acting GM. Porter departed before the season; Alderson resumed GM duties in September.
² Stearns assumed control after the 2023 regular season.
³ Financial figures remain estimates. Andy Green replaced Carlos Mendoza in June.
CBT payroll uses tax-accounting values, including contract AAVs and benefits. Payroll plus tax is not actual cash spending. Totals use unrounded figures.
Four field managers and several front-office arrangements accompanied that commitment. Turnover alone does not explain the results. It does mean the people making evaluations, setting priorities and communicating expectations repeatedly changed.
Cohen was pursuing immediate success while still establishing the leadership capable of sustaining it.
Stearns was supposed to connect the pieces
Stearns’ arrival offered the prospect of a more durable arrangement.
His Milwaukee experience suggested he understood how to compete while developing players, replenishing talent and managing difficult roster decisions.
The expectation in New York was compelling: combine those capabilities with Cohen’s financial resources.
That would give the Mets greater capacity to retain successful players, purchase coverage and absorb mistakes.
It also raised the pressure. Stearns was the experienced executive expected to bring stability while winning. Organizational development and immediate competition remained simultaneous obligations.
Some progress is tangible
The emerging young group gives the Mets something substantial to build around.
As Part 4 discussed, Benge, McLean, Scott and Ewing supplied affordable production. Fair attribution still matters: McLean, Scott and Ewing entered the organization before Stearns; Benge was drafted under his administration.
Developing inherited talent deserves credit. So do acquisition, rehabilitation, promotion and deployment decisions.
But those contributions must be evaluated alongside the surrounding roster.
The 2024 run demonstrated that the Mets could compete deep into October. The next two seasons demonstrated that they had not established a dependable way to return.
Stearns’ teams have gone 246–240, with one postseason appearance.
Stabilizing through change
There is a tension here. Stearns was expected to stabilize the organization while changing its players.
Some turnover was necessary. Continuity cannot mean preserving an unsuccessful roster indefinitely.
However, every new player, position and role creates adjustment work. A collection of individually defensible moves still has to function together.
That is where my own preseason assessment was too confident. I underestimated how many favorable outcomes needed to align for the 2026 roster to work.
The same scrutiny belongs in evaluating management: how much uncertainty did the construction require the team to overcome?
Where the assignment stands
Cohen supplied financial capacity. The organization has developed useful young players. Stearns has provided continuity at the top of baseball operations.
Those are meaningful ingredients.
The unfinished work is making them reinforce one another: better decisions, more productive players, credible replacements and winning teams.
Milwaukee demonstrated that organizational strength could survive a leadership transition. New York is still trying to demonstrate that its current leadership can make competitive seasons dependable.
The final installment returns to the question that opened this series: how effectively does an organization turn its resources into sustained winning?
For the Mets, the next proof needs to come in the standings.
Sources: MLB records and leadership announcements; final CBT assessments reported by AP/ESPN; FanGraphs’ November 18, 2026 payroll estimate.