11/17/26

Cautious Optimist -- Laddering Up: Part IV (The Bullpen)

 


The changing role of relievers and the relief they provide

There is no denying that the changing conception of what it means to be a starting pitcher in the modern game has had the greatest impact on what it means to be a reliever, and how teams construct their bullpen. 

In 2016, 23% of starts lasted into the 7th inning or beyond.  Pitchers averaged 95 pitches per start.  By 2026 those numbers were reduced to 9% and 84, respectively.

Starters are rarely allowed, let alone asked, to pitch beyond the sixth inning, and often end up pitching less than that. The average in 2026 was a hair over 5 innings per outing. 

The success and durability of starters are no longer measured by innings per outing having been replaced by the number of total appearances: taking the ball every sixth day.

Relievers have always been asked to provide relief (an insightful banality, that one).  Two things have changed.

    * Relief is required more often and earlier than ever.  

    * As the role has expanded, it has also become significantly more               structured, as relievers fall into ever more well defined specific roles,        each defined by a distinctive task and set of expectations.

Let's consider aspects of both.  First, why the increased reliance on relief pitching earlier and earlier in games?

Let's use the analytics as a proxy for what the underlying causal factors are. 

Apparently, the relevant analytics indicates that:

    * Starting pitchers make the greatest positive impact on the game on           average by pitching with maximum available effort for however long           they can sustain that effort.

    * Whatever strategic advantage, if any, the starting pitcher is able to           create over the opposing team's line-up on average dissipates rapidly        after the second time through the line-up.

The result is, more often than not, an early call to the bullpen.

Maintaining the initial competitive advantage requires replacing the starter with a reliever (and then another and invariably others to follow as the task changes during the course of the game).

The conventional view is that (especially) the first relievers called into service should offer something different than the starter: perhaps a different combination of pitches or a different sequencing of the same pitches, perhaps a different arm angle, and so on.

The underlying thought is that just when the offense has figured out the starter, replace him with someone else who offers a new and distinctive challenge.

I like to call this the video-game strategy, because it is exactly as how one would envision creating a video baseball game.  

Like much conventional wisdom, there is some truth in it, but less than one is asked to believe.  After all, hitters have 'books' on all pitchers and if there is something new on offer, it is only a matter of time before the word spreads and a method of attack develops.

Whatever the explanation-- maximum effort leaving starters with less in the tank and thus rendering them effective for shorter periods of time, or simply an effort to take advantage of presenting hitters with different challenges throughout the game and thus not giving them a chance to get comfortable in the box -- the striking fact is that the vast majority of  games are  turned over to the 'Pen' around the time the game is barely halfway completed.

(We will set aside the irony of the fact that teams look to have a stable group of starters, while juggling their bullpens regularly on a yearly basis.)

The unhappy fate of Middle Relievers

Given their typical entry point into the fray, it is only fitting that the first group out of the pen have are typically referred to as 'middle relievers.' 

That may be no more than coincidence, but apt nonetheless.

I prefer to characterize those who take over from the starters by their primary task or functional role, which is primarily either to buy time for their team's offense either to cut into a deficit they face or to an extend a lead they have attained. 

In a sense they are brought in either to affirm continued control of the game or to establish it if the starter has failed or to re-establish it if it has been lost or is slipping away.

It's actually hard to imagine a more significant role for a reliever to play; and it should come as no surprise that the outcomes of a statistically significant number of games is determined during the time middle relievers are on the mound.

What is harder to square with the importance of the role they play is the compensation they tend to receive for the work they are being asked to perform. 

Why are middle relievers undervalued?  

Here's my take. Every year, there is an abundance of potential middle relievers available through free agency.  The supply vastly exceeds the demand, thus driving prices down. The relatively low price they can command is naturally understood in the market as reflecting their value, that is, their relative importance or contribution. 

They are viewed more or less as commodities, which are resources, services or assets that are differentiated from one another largely by price.  In the market price is often identified with value, and so it is the fate of middle relievers to be undervalued and undercompensated.

In my view, the pricing of middle relievers is an unreliable signal of value that attentive GMs and FO personnel should, can, and sometimes do, exploit.  Doing so was the KEY factor in the outsized positive performance of the Mets bullpen last year. 

Arguably, it was Stearns' greatest achievement in roster construction. Unfortunately his eye for talented middle relievers is not matched by a talent for secondary position players.

The specialists

Until recently we thought of specialists as pitchers brought into games to face a particular hitter or two, often a lefty on lefty matchup, or a super high velocity pitcher against a hitter with a known deficit in catching up with fastballs, or a ground ball expert with the lead runner on third and less than two outs; and so on.

This has changed with the three batter rule to some extent, but not completely.  Specialists are better thought of as maximum effort performers that feature an outsized advantage in particular circumstances, combined with a competence to complete an inning's worth of work if need be.  

Built for purpose, specialists are typically not workhorses.  They have distinctive skills that play in short bursts and cannot be called upon to face a diversity of batters, more than a day or so in succession, and almost never for more than an inning at a time.  

Raley was a specialist in this sense; and for comparison, Brozaban was a paradigm of the middle reliever.  Minter was, by my lights neither, nor was he the sort of high leverage back of the bullpen arm.  He was a kind of B/B+ at all three, but an A at none of them.  Handy but not essential in my view.

The back of the bullpen

Ironically, perhaps, back end of the bullpen relievers have much the same role as middle relievers in that they have to keep the game where it is, but because they enter later in the game, it would be odd to think of them as buying time.   Or if you like, you can think of them as  buying time, the time they are buying is more precious, the danger of falling short in their mission more consequential.  They are paid accordingly.

Closers have the privilege of pitching in the most pressure packed circumstances and are paid accordingly.  They are the insurance a team pays in order to minimize the probability that all the effort the team has put into the game to this point is no wasted.

I am not convinced that the data would support the narrative around closers as there is almost certainly an argument for distributing the risk among the group at the back end of the bullpen. 

The typical bullpen has 7 or 8 pitchers: 3 at the back, 2 or 3 in the middle and 2 specialists deployed as needed.  When there are 8 relievers, one can triple as long reliever, mop up man and spot starter from time to time.

So who should we hope to see in the Mets bullpen next year -- who fits in what role?

We can pencil Williams in as one of the high leverage relievers.  I am not sure he should be the closer but then again I think that role designation is more restrictive than helpful.  

I would much prefer Morejon as the closer. I am very high on Loisaga who has found himself again as a high leverage righty who presents a different challenge to hitters than both Williams and Morejon.  He is also an ex-Yankee and Stearns can't resist signing at least one ex-Yankee for the bullpen every year. 

Like every group, there are questions about all three of these pitchers.  Morejon hasn't closed in the past (but only because the Padres have the best closer in the league).  Williams has been up and down, recently more down than up. Loisaga had a great year, but has had a previous injury history.

There are other combinations that make sense.  If, as I suggested in my previous post, the Mets pursue Morejon as a top tier starter, they might plausibly pursue Alex Vesia as a late innings reliever. 

I am sure there are other potential options available, and perhaps at some point next year Lambert will earn a spot at the back of the pen.

I am not counting Senga among this group for two reasons.  First, I believe his performance at the end of last year has increased his trade value. 

Second, if he is not traded, I don't believe that his performance late last year is likely to be repeated; certainly it would be unwise to count on it. I don't see him having the mentality or the physical durability to show up as often as someone at the back of the pen must. He is not a workhorse.  He would be a high priced specialist, but is more suited to that role temperamentally and physically.

For me, Lavender is the other specialist on the staff.  In addition to getting lefties out in critical circumstances, he has the demeanor to give good innings over and over again, and not allow the games in which he fails to do so bother him.

That's five, which leaves two more openings, both middle relievers.  Over the course of the season, I see several pitchers performing in this role: Garrett and Megill, but not until they are both healthy.  Nunez and Duarte have made a case for consideration. I am sure there are others who will earn a shot over the course of the season.

If Manaea is not traded or released, he is likely to be a 6th (spot) starter, long reliever and a lefty jack of all trades in the pen.

I am not a believer in Yan yet.  The one thing you cannot afford to have in the pen is someone who offers too many free passes, and right now Yan's command is volatile.  

Conclusion

I don't think it is possible to feel as good about the Mets bullpen going into next year as we did about how the bullpen performed last year before it was dismantled.  But then again, I don't think we felt as good about that bullpen going into the year last year as we did about them just prior to their being dismantled.

We would certainly have reason to feel as good about this projected bullpen (or modest variations of it) as we did about last year's prior to the season starting: better in fact.

I am not predicting that Stearns will see things as I do, but I would predict that he will fashion a bullpen that complements the starters and forms a strong foundation for the team going forward.



11/16/26

MACK = Perfect Game's Pick for Mets 1.1 2027 Draft Pick

 

https://www.perfectgame.org/Players/Playerprofile.aspx?ID=630036

 

Pick    Team    Player        Pos.       School           

1       Colorado Rockies        Dylan Seward                    SS           Norco

2   Los Angeles Angels    Brendan Lawson                       SS           Florida

3      Athletics                Dax Whitney                      RHP        Oregon State

4     Kansas City Royals    Tomas Valincius                LHP        Mississippi State

5     New York Mets          Chris Levonas                    RHP        Wake Forest

                GROK:

                Chris Levonas (RHP, Wake Forest Demon Deacons) has a deep, high-quality (“plus”) pitch repertoire featuring multiple above-average to plus offerings, strong swing-and-miss ability, and premium velocity.⁠ Baseballamerica

He is a 6'1"/6'2", ~175–180 lb right-hander from Holmdel, NJ (Christian Brothers Academy). Born February 11, 2006, he was selected 67th overall by the Milwaukee Brewers in the 2024 MLB Draft but did not sign and enrolled at Wake Forest. As a sophomore in 2026 he went 10-3 with a 2.82 ERA, 116 strikeouts in 73.1 innings (14.2 K/9), and held opponents to a .171 batting average, earning First-Team All-ACC and multiple All-American honors. He is a top prospect for the 2027 MLB Draft (often ranked among the top RHPs or overall in the class) with elite Stuff+ grades (around 125 overall in recent tracking) and a reported 43.1% whiff rate across a large sample. ⁠Godeacs 

Pitch Arsenal / Repertoire

Scouting and tracking data describe a four- or five-pitch mix with plus fastball and secondary weapons that tunnel well and generate high miss rates:

Fastball — Primary plus (or better) pitch. Sits mid-to-upper 90s and has touched 100–101 mph (reports of 100.5+ in starts). Features high spin, good carry/induced vertical break (elite when >19" IVB), and extension. Stuff+ grades frequently in the 113–120+ range. ⁠X

Slider — Plus offering with high spin (often 2800+ rpm historically), wipeout action, and velocity into the upper 80s/low 90s (up to ~90 mph noted). Strong Stuff+ (~110–111) and solid whiff rates.⁠ Baseballamerica

Curveball — Above-average to plus 12-to-6 “hammer” with high spin (historically 3000+ rpm) and depth in the upper 70s/low 80s. Excellent tunneling with the fastball and high whiff rates in tracked outings (Stuff+ often ~96–103).⁠ Threequarterslot

Cutter — Present in his mix and grades well on Stuff+ models (~107–109).

Changeup — Firm upper-80s to low-90s offering with armside fade/run. It flashes plus quality and has posted strong Stuff+ (102–114) and high whiff rates in samples. ⁠X

High-school/early reports (pre-college) already graded the fastball and slider as plus (BA tools: FB 60, SL 60, CB 55, CH 50), with velocity jumping into the mid-90s (up to 97–98) and high-spin breaking balls. College development has added velocity, consistency, a cutter, and improved command while maintaining the swing-and-miss profile.⁠ Baseballamerica

In short, Levonas pairs elite velocity and carry on the fastball with multiple plus or near-plus secondaries (especially the breaking balls), producing one of the stronger pure-stuff profiles in the 2027 college draft class. Command has been the relative question mark historically but has shown progress.

6     Cincinnati Reds        Malachi Butler                   SS           McEachern

7     Detroit Tigers          Carter Hadnot                   SS           Aquinas

8    Seattle Mariners       George Ferguson                   RHP        Abilene

9    Washington Nationals    Gavin Kelly                          C/UTL    West Virginia

10  San Francisco Giants       Dylan Volantis                   LHP        Texas


Paul Articulates - First things first


As the off-season ticks away heading towards the expiration of the CBA and the inevitable lockout, very little has been happening in the trade and free agent markets.  

Sure, there are a bunch of players being signed to minor league deals and small trades of low impact players, but the only signing of significance so far was the Red Sox addition of Jack Bauer at an above market value $14.5M per season.  And the Sox already had Willson Contreras.

Jack is one of the few first basemen out there that have been written about as potential free agent targets, with the other being the as-yet-unsigned Ty France.  France is a better defender and has had a statistically better career than Bauer, so one could only imagine that he will command better numbers when signed.  That is a lot of money for a first baseman that doesn’t deliver huge power numbers.

First base, as we all know, is a weak point for the Mets.  We currently have Jared Young as the default incumbent, and his career numbers are not much worse than Bauer, but it is still a weak position.  So one may ask, “What else is out there”?

Let’s start with durable players at the position.  Over the past three seasons, only eleven players have played at least 100 games at first in each season. 


A quick look at this table confirms that most of the notable first basemen are pretty unavailable – Olsen, Alonso, and Freeman cannot be pried away from their current teams for a reasonable amount of collateral.  

The same goes for Bryce Harper and Munetaka Murakami who is not on the list because he played in NPB in 2024 and 2025.  No one else on that list had an OPS over .800 last year, so all of us armchair GMs are immediately into the value trade of durability versus power production versus defense.  There is also the question of age.  Walker is 35, Harper is 34, and France is 32.

There are a few new names out there that are worthy of a look. This includes rookie of the year (it hurts to say that) Sal Stewart, 24-year-old Nick Kurtz from the A's, 25-year-old Nolan Schanuel from the Angels, and a trio of 29-year-olds Busch, Naylor, and Pasquantino.  Let’s take a close look:



Clearly Stewart is not a trade candidate – you would have to give up someone like Benge for Stewart and I would much rather have Benge.  The same probably goes for Kurtz, although the A’s have been a trade partner before.  But with only two more controllable years, Busch and Schanuel could be had, and Pasquantino is even more likely.

Do the options of trading for either Busch, Schanuel, or Pasquantino look more attractive than paying big bucks for Josh Naylor with his -9 DRS?  Yes, in a word.  

Is it more attractive than Jared Young, Brett Baty, or Mark Vientos?  Probably – although the grass always looks greener on the other side.  LAA and CHC are big market teams, so those players are used to life under the media microscope.  Pasquantino would have a big step up if he were the next guy to try to fill Pete Alonso’s shoes.

The reason I have brought some of these names to your attention is because I struggle when I hear that the Mets are talking to Alec Bohm or that anyone would consider bringing Rafael Devers’ attitude into the Mets clubhouse.  Since we are not likely going to be able to acquire any of the big name first basemen out there, the Mets are better off getting a young, coachable player with MLB experience at first base than any of the other options, including playing some of our young prospects at an unfamiliar position as they break into the majors. 

Reese Kaplan -- A Fresh New Approach or More of the Same?


As the 2026 season stumbled and then spiraled into oblivion the most frustrating aspect of the demise could be debated almost equally between the roster construction filled with a passel of underperformers just as easily as it could the annoyance at the front office doing absolutely nothing until the long lost season’s August trade deadline house cleaning took place.  Surely things would change during the upcoming preparation for 2027, right?

Or not...

Friday word came out that another team — the Boston Red Sox — made a conspicuous foray into roster reinforcement by executing a somewhat questionable $14.5 million per year contract to  2026 former Brewers slugger Jake Bauers for the period of 2027 through the end of 2030.  For a guy who has had ample opportunity to prove himself in the major leagues Bauers delivered in a big way for the now World Series Champion Milwaukee team.  In 2026 he hit .266 which was decidedly out of character for a lifetime .223 hitter and delivered 86 RBIs while sending 26 long balls over the fence.


On the surface many would wonder where David Stearns was while this transaction took place.  First base is obviously one of the glacial holes the Mets need to address and being a player with his former team made Bauers a less than creative option for the former Milwaukee executive.  

For those folks who were not on the Johnny come lately Bauers bandwagon the implication as to what this $58 million investment will do to the rest of the available free agent market is a concern that bears scrutiny.  The other one-time flavor of the week — Ty France — is likely salivating over what he can now expect to earn when you consider he posted similar numbers with a .295 batting average, 21 HRs and 72 RBIs over the course of the 2026 season while also providing his usual Gold Glove level of defense at first.  

As far as fit goes, France batting right handed is a better match for the Mets current roster with lefty swinging AAAA player Jared Young having worked his way into a regular’s spot in the lineup last year while also posting uncharacteristic numbers.  While many felt France could be a reasonable option for the upcoming year, his 2026 salary of just $1.35 million after signing with the Padres during the previous off season on a minor league deal.

Now the guy who makes the New York Mets personnel decisions must face the reality that if Bauers set he bar unreasonably high with his AAV of $14.5 million, you can only wonder how high the previously affordable France will now get is anyone’s guess.  His defense and batting average are superior to Bauers and his run production is similar.  The Stearns strategy of doing nothing is once again looking as if it will bite him in the rear pocket holding his wallet as a result watching others make the market instead of him doing so.

We’ve already seen the public proclamation that Stearns is happy to allow the 2026 barely over Mendoza line Marcus Semien return as the starting second baseman, you’re kind of left wondering if a similar and questionable endorsement land on Jared Young’s back.  Bear in mind once again that the Mets are not looking to replace the production of the rag tag patchwork ensemble who spent time at first base last year for the cellar dwellers. He’s actually needing to address what was lost when he didn’t even bid on league leading slugger and current Baltimore Oriole Pete Alonso. 

Well, the clock on the wall continues to click and while other teams are making efforts to improve, thus far the Mets are reiterating the very same approach that failed them so spectacularly last year.


11/15/26

MACK – Three more possibilities for Mets first pick

 


We continue with three more players that easily could be available when the Mets pick in the first round of the 2027 draft:

 

Teddy Tokheim, 3B/OF/1B, Stanford

20/years old – 6-3/215 – RHH

2026/Stanford -           199-AB, 36-K, 17-HR, 47-RBI, 21-BB, .352/.414/.704/1.118

Most player’s OPS is round what this guy’s slugging percentage is. And, this was as a freshman.

Offense wise, one of the top draft eligible sophomores in the draft. Terrific bat speed. Plenty of power. Physically imposing. Can pummel a baseball. Starts slightly open in crouched stance. Big leg kick. Impressive hip-shoulder separation that generates easy bat speed. Plus, raw power designed to lift baseballs. Impressive barrel length through the zone. Makes ton of contact. Played well in summer wood bat leagues. Maintains a healthy strikeout rate. Could be the best overall offensive approach/swing in the draft.

Defense wise, projects to either third or a corner outfield position. Fring-average runner. A lot of question regarding his defensive game. Will be forced to first or DH in the pros though, his bat will carry him wherever he plays.

 

 

Lubin Rincon, SS/3B, Shadow Creek HS (Tex.)

6-3/180 - LHH

Perfect Game rating: 10. Tall and lean. Projects more to come.

Offense wise – comfortable straight stance. Fluid hands. Plenty of extension out front. Great approach to the plate. Outstanding balance in the box. Short and compact. Current hit over power, but, don’t worry… raw pop to the pull side developing.  it will come. The final package could end up being an above-average hit, above-average power combination. 6.67 in the 60. 101.9 exit velo.

Defense wise – primarily a shortstop with soft and sure hands. Easy arm strength and carry. 93 infield velo. Slightly above-average runner which plays also well defensively. Some think he will stick on short.

 

 

Jacob Seamon, OF/SS, Metrolina Christian Academy (NC)

17/years old - 6-5/205 – LHH

2026    -           .528/.595/1.104          13-HR, 50-RBI, 31-SB

 

Offense wise, has all the offensive tools. Plenty of power already. Does come with some swing-and-miss concerns (doesn’t every power hitter suffer from this?).

Scouts say he runs like a gazelle. Grades up to 70-run. Currently has a monster power projection. 30+home runs are already being projected for him. Premium bat speed (projected for more).

Defense wise, has all the defensive ones too. Projected to stay in center.

 Seamon is simply an elite athlete for a player of his size and length.


 

We continue with three more players that easily could be available when the Mets pick in the first round of the 2027 draft:

 

Teddy Tokheim, 3B/OF/1B, Stanford

20/years old – 6-3/215 – RHH

2026/Stanford -           199-AB, 36-K, 17-HR, 47-RBI, 21-BB, .352/.414/.704/1.118

Most player’s OPS is round what this guy’s slugging percentage is. And, this was as a freshman.

Offense wise, one of the top draft eligible sophomores in the draft. Terrific bat speed. Plenty of power. Physically imposing. Can pummel a baseball. Starts slightly open in crouched stance. Big leg kick. Impressive hip-shoulder separation that generates easy bat speed. Plus, raw power designed to lift baseballs. Impressive barrel length through the zone. Makes ton of contact. Played well in summer wood bat leagues. Maintains a healthy strikeout rate. Could be the best overall offensive approach/swing in the draft.

Defense wise, projects to either third or a corner outfield position. Fring-average runner. A lot of question regarding his defensive game. Will be forced to first or DH in the pros though, his bat will carry him wherever he plays.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lubin Rincon, SS/3B, Shadow Creek HS (Tex.)

6-3/180 - LHH

Perfect Game rating: 10. Tall and lean. Projects more to come.

Offense wise – comfortable straight stance. Fluid hands. Plenty of extension out front. Great approach to the plate. Outstanding balance in the box. Short and compact. Current hit over power, but, don’t worry… raw pop to the pull side developing.  it will come. The final package could end up being an above-average hit, above-average power combination. 6.67 in the 60. 101.9 exit velo.

Defense wise – primarily a shortstop with soft and sure hands. Easy arm strength and carry. 93 infield velo. Slightly above-average runner which plays also well defensively. Some think he will stick on short.

 

 

Jacob Seamon, OF/SS, Metrolina Christian Academy (NC)

17/years old - 6-5/205 – LHH

2026    -           .528/.595/1.104          13-HR, 50-RBI, 31-SB

 

Offense wise, has all the offensive tools. Plenty of power already. Does come with some swing-and-miss concerns (doesn’t every power hitter suffer from this?).

Scouts say he runs like a gazelle. Grades up to 70-run. Currently has a monster power projection. 30+home runs are already being projected for him. Premium bat speed (projected for more).

Defense wise, has all the defensive ones too. Projected to stay in center.

 Seamon is simply an elite athlete for a player of his size and length.

Tom Brennan - PROSPECTS: The Best Guesses…Are Still Guesses…Sato vs. Amick…and Don’t Give Up on Ryan Lambert


SOME LISTS?

THEY TURN OUT TO BE A BUNCH OF BLARNEY

“EENIE MEENIE MINIE MO”

“OK, THAT IS MY GUESS…AND I AM NOT STICKING TO IT”


Each season:

Lots of blood, sweat and tears go into formulating the Mets top 30 prospects list. 

I took a look at the painstakingly prepared 2024 list, formulated with great care just 2 years ago. 

You know, the one on the Mets’ MLB site.

Let’s take a quick look at how those dudes panned out over the last 2 years.


1) Jett Williams - SHORT; no majors for Li’l Jett. Hit .238 in Brewers AAA in 2026.

2) Drew Gilbert - SHORT; .238 in majors. Decent year, but not great for a #2.

3) LuisAngel Acuna - SHORT;  Weak major league hitting. Speedy. Overranked.

4) Ryan Clifford - at # 4, ranked 40 or 50 slots too high, based on his awful 2026.

5) Christian Scott - 5? very appropriate rank, based on fine 2026 pitching for Mets.

6) Ronny Mauricio - certainly seems overrated at # 6. Say, 10 spots too high.

7) Colin Houck - at # 7, ranked 50+ slots too high, based on his awful 2026.

8) Marco Vargas - he rallied in late 2026, but was overrated in 2024 at # 8.

9) Kevin Parada - 20-25 slots too highly ranked. A decent 2026, but bad 2024-25.

10) Blade Tidwell - ranking about right. Can’t predict arm issues.

11) Mike Vasil - about right. Can’t predict arm issues.

12) Jeremy Rodriguez - ranked 40 or 50 slots too high, based on his awful 2026.

13) Brandon Sproat - deserved to be ranked in top 10. Not a great 3-9, 5,43 so far.

14) Dom Hamel: way overrated. NOT top 30 pitcher. Go overseas, like Chris Flexen?

15) Jacob Reimer: seems about right. His injuries drop him 10 slots. Gotta play more.

16) Alex Ramirez - bad in 2024 & 2025, but # 16 is about right after his solid 2026.

17) Yovanny Rodriguez - ranked about right.

18) Tyler Stuart - later arm injury, but seemed a bit overrated at # 18 regardless.

19) Nolan McLean - sure got that one wrong, huh? He’s awesome. Numero UNO.

20) Ronald Hernandez - probably overranked, by ten or more slots. Must hit more.

21) Jesus Baez - way underrated, after his stunning offensive season in St Louis AA.

22) Calvin Ziegler: huge health issues - ranking  at # 22 still seems wishful thinking.

23) Wilfredo Lara - Wilfredo who? Overrated. Not top 30.

24) Nate Lavender - we know who he is now…way underrated. Lavender is Gold.

25) Boston Baro - ranked about right,  with upside from there if he stays healthy.

26) Nick Morabito - under-ranked by a lot. I’d say 10 or more slots too low in 2024.

27) Raimon Gomez - so far, he doesn’t deserve top 30. Injury prone and WILD.

28) Joander Suarez: late 20s rank is about right. Not all guys ranked 28 will make it.

29) Saul Garcia - he is now a lot better than # 29. Ranked 10 slots too low?

30) Rhylan Thomas: he deserved to be in late teens. His power void holds him back.


So…some were accurate, in hindsight, but many were significantly over-ranked or under ranked. I’d say 60% were incorrectly ranked by 10-50 slots, most of those being OVER-RANKED TREMENDOUSLY IN 2024 based on what we know today.

Lots of guesswork. I guess some were good, more than “some” were not so good. 

The only 3 who made it impactfully since the 2024 ranking are McLean, Scott, and Lavender. Maybe Vasil. 

Baez looks like he may soon make a thundering impact.

And the list lacked AJ Ewing. And Benge. And Santucci. Ouch.


FWIW, here is my ranking done in October 2024. 

I think I guessed pretty good:

1) SPROAT

2) JETT

3) TONG 

4) BENGE

5) MCLEAN

6) GILBERT

7) MAURICIO

8) MORABITO

9) BARO

10) ACUNA

11) CLIFFORD

12) J RODRIGUEZ

13) TIDWELL

14) VARGAS

15) SANTUCCI

16) DOHM

17) SNYDER

18) JESUS BAEZ

19 GUTIERREZ

20) YOVANNY ROD

21) EWING

22) VASIL

23) REIMER

24) R HERNANDEZ

25) W YOUNG

26) HAMEL

27) LANTIGUA

28) ALEX RAMIREZ

29) GEBER

30) LAVENDER

And, notably, while they had Houck at # 7, he was already out of my top 30. 

Why?  K Machines don’t often self-repair.

My final note on the topic: 

I had Forgotten all about my # 27 Eddie Lantigua. I realize why. 

He played just 49 games in 2025, with a scant 9 games and 60 day IL in 2026. 

Apparently, an injury to his core. Must have been a DOOZY.

How do you rank THAT currently, even though he will be just 20+next year? 

Baseball is a PARTICIPATION SPORT. PLAYING ACTUAL GAMES BEATS THEORIZING.

I guess he is both agile…and fragile.

He’s currently out of my top 50.  

May he get in 120 games in 2027 and returns to top 30.


SPEAKING OF PROSPECTS…

The question always is…will Mets prospects have a future MLB impact.If the Mets pursue Japan’s slugger Sato, maybe they don’t perceive Billy Amick to be a future answer? Here are some thoughts.

Then I want to hear yours.

SATO VS. AMICK

Question: 

Should the Mets attempt to acquire the left-handed power hitting Sato?

He put a big power numbers in Japan and hit .306, but he tends to strike out a lot. Meanwhile, we have Bill Amick in the minor leagues, not hitting us high average-wise, but with comparable power. He is an alrighty righty hitter.

So, is it worth considering Sato?  

Or is he facing similar pitching quality as our guy Billy has been facing in AA and AAA?

Much of that has to do with the quality of pitching in Japan. Just how good is it?

So I asked my tablet the question, and got this useful answer in reply:


Nippon Professional Baseball (NPB) pitching is far superior to Double-A (AA) and is widely considered to be "AAAA" or "Quad-A" talent. 
While it sits just below Major League Baseball (MLB) in overall depth, NPB pitching easily clears both AA and Triple-A (AAA) in terms of sophistication, command, and overall quality. 
The comparison between NPB pitching and the U.S. minor leagues breaks down across several key areas:
1. Repertoire and Sophistication
  • NPB: The average Japanese starting pitcher features an incredibly deep repertoire, routinely throwing four to five distinct pitch types with elite command. Off-speed pitches, devastating splitters, and breaking balls are heavily prioritized over raw velocity.
  • AA / AAA: The minor leagues are developmental. Pitchers in AA or AAA are often working on developing a specific third pitch or fixing a mechanical flaw. You see much higher variance and raw, unrefined talent.
2. High-Velocity Arms vs. Pitching Command
  • Minor Leagues: The U.S. minor league system is flooded with "max-effort" arms that throw with extreme velocity but often lack fine command.
  • NPB: While average velocity is slightly lower than in MLB, NPB pitchers benefit from using a slightly smaller, tackier baseball with higher seams. This allows them to generate exceptional spin, sharp movement, and pinpoint control that frustrates free-swinging hitters. 
3. Competitiveness vs. Development
Opinions on the exact gap can vary slightly, but data analysts and players who have played in both systems point out a massive structural difference: 
  • The NPB is a winning-focused major league. Pitchers face established, highly disciplined professionals who lock in on contact and plate discipline. Walk and chase rates in Japan closely mimic MLB averages, whereas AAA and AA lineups feature highly aggressive, free-swinging prospects.
  • The Elite Ceiling: The best pitchers in Japan (such as Shohei Ohtani, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, or Yu Darvish) bypass the minor leagues entirely because their talent level transitions directly to the top of MLB rotations. 

How the Talent Transitions
When models project how an NPB pitcher's stats will translate to the Major Leagues, a common benchmark is that a great NPB pitcher will experience a modest inflation in their numbers due to the sheer power of MLB lineups. For instance, an elite 3.00 ERA in Japan typically translates to a very respectable 3.50–4.00 ERA in MLB—a transition that is much more successful than what you would expect from an average AA or AAA call-up

So…would you pursue Sato? 
Or sit back and hope our boy Billy the Kid Amick explodes in 2027?
Many are naysayers on Amick. I am not. I am a yay-sayer on Amick.

FINALLY…DON’T GIVE UP ON RYAN LAMBERT
Lambert scuffled all of the minors regular season in 2026…badly. 

Then, the fireballer went to the AFL.

He pitched very well in the AFL where, frankly, so many pitchers in the six team league pitched horrendously. No runs or hits allowed.

There was another pitcher who scuffled in the minors - back in 2013.

4.51 ERA…1.45 WHIP….allowed 10.2 hits per 9…walked or hit more than 3 guys per 9…and fanned just 7.3 batters per 9 innings (just 18.7% of the batters he faced).

Sucked, right? Yes. 

Would continue to suck? Wrong.

That was Jake deGrom. So…don’t give up on struggling fireballers. Ever.




11/14/26

MACK - DRAFT STUFF

 


MACK - Draft News Update

 

FLOSPORTS – top 10 draft prospects –

Brendan Lawson, SS, Florida

Dax Whitney, RHP, Oregon State

Dylan Seward, SS, Norco (CA)

Tomas Valincius, LHP, Mississippi State

Gavin Kelly, C/2B, West Virginia

Landon Hairston, OF, Arizona State

Malachi Butler, SS, McEachern (GA)

Chris Levonas, RHP, Wake Forest

Jimmy Janicki, C/3B, Troy

Ryan McPherson, RHP, Mississippi State

 

Bleacher Report – Top 5 Draft Picks & Teams:

1. Colorado Rockies – Brendan Lawson, SS, Florida

A .315/.464/.602 hitter in his first two seasons, Lawson hit 19 HR in spring 2026. While some scouts see him as a potential 2B/3B, his bat and defensive tools keep him near the top

2. New York Mets – Dax Whitney, RHP, Oregon State

A 6'5", 218‑lb righty with a three‑pitch mix and frontline potential if he builds on his sophomore success

3. Los Angeles Angels – Dylan Seward, SS, Norco HS (CA)

A quick‑twitch, 80‑grade speed player with elite bat‑to‑ball skills and defensive range. Projected as a top‑of‑the‑draft shortstop

4. Athletics – Gavin Kelly, C/2B, West Virginia

A standout from a College World Series‑winning team, Kelly projects as a versatile infielder with strong defensive skills

5. Toronto Blue Jays – Landon Hairston, OF, Arizona State

A .400/.509/.860 hitter with 28 HR and 81 RBI in 2026, combining hit tool and raw power

 

Teams with the Most Draft Prospects – MSN

 

Texas Leads With Six Top 100 Prospects

Dylan Volantis (No. 11), Sam Cozart (25), Ian Armstrong (38), Adrian Rodriguez (41), Linkin Garcia (52) and Brett Crossland (91) give Texas the largest group. Volantis has transitioned from closer to starter with a five-pitch mix and strong strike-throwing ability.

Cozart posted a 1.72 ERA as a freshman closer and has the arsenal to develop into a starter. Armstrong offers contact skills and solid receiving, while Garcia brings raw power and arm strength. Rodriguez adds contact ability and defensive versatility.

 

LSU Has Five Prospects In The Rankings

Casan Evans (No. 15), William Schmidt (34), Bino Watters (50), Dawson Park (69) and Jason Wachs (99) represent LSU. Evans’ fastball has reached 99 mph, although his command needs improvement. Schmidt’s slider and curveball offer strikeout potential, while Watters and Park bring power and defensive ability, respectively.

 

Florida’s Four Include No. 1 Brendan Lawson

Brendan Lawson (No. 1), Aidan King (21), Jackson Barberi (26) and Joshua Whritenour (67) make up Florida’s group. Lawson combines left-handed power with strong contact skills, while King earned SEC pitcher of the year honors in 2026. Barberi and Whritenour have each reached 101 mph.

 

Tennessee Matches Florida With Four Prospects

Trent Grindlinger (No. 13), Landon Mack (33), Blaine Brown (89) and Chris Ramirez (93) give Tennessee four representatives. Grindlinger hit .345 with eight home runs as a freshman, and Mack’s fastball has reached 100 mph. Brown offers substantial raw power, although Tommy John surgery could limit him to designated hitter.


Reese Kaplan -- How Good or Bad Is the 2027 Starting Pitching?



So the GM Meetings have come and gone  While everyone expected an accelerated array of free agent signings and trades being made with the early December lockout just weeks away, not a whole lot in that regard happened.  Yes, the Reds lost their closer Emilio Pagan in free agency to the Detroit Tigers and the Braves signed their own former reliever Evan Phillips in free agency from the Dodgers.  The Mets, of course, did nothing. 


With 17 days left before the end of November the holes in the roster still exist and the 2026 free fall into the cellar hasn’t seen any corrective actions taken.  Yesterday we discussed finding a left handed reliever.  Today let’s consider the prospect of who will be in the 2027 starting rotation with and without the addition of Tarik Skubal. 

As it stands right now before that free agent negotiation comes to a conclusion the Mets five man army of starting pitchers is OK but not great.  The top three — Nolan McLean, Christian Scott and Zac Thornton should be better than average though Thornton’s limited track record in the majors makes him a bit of an uncertainty for projection.

After that it gets a bit murkier.  They could go with starters Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga if they wanted to use current roster options in that role. They could insert less likely people like Justin Hagenman, Tobias Myers, Tylor Megill and other patchwork names to occupy the 4th and 5th spots.  None of them are that good but then neither of the above pair of veterans would fill anyone’s heart and head with confidence either.  Jonah Tong belongs here, sometimes showing brilliance but other times being treated as a batting practice pitcher.

There has already been narrative about Senga receiving trade interest given his one year commitment of a modest $15 million salary.  There has been no chatter whatsoever about Manaea other than the piece suggesting a swap of ending salaries with the Rangers for their fist baseman, Christian Walker.

Consequently it is indeed looking as if the Mets will need not just one new starting pitcher but perhaps a pair of them since the alternatives are less than appealing if they are indeed serious about returning to contention.  Skubal is indeed ace material but the questions about him are both about his conditioning and the king’s ransom it will require per year and for many, many years to lure him onto David Stearns’ woefully constructed last place team that he did not improve.  The obvious pitchers behind him — Michael King and Clay Holmes — combined would cost less than Skubal and fill both of those vacancies.  


Trade possibilities including prominent names like the Twins’ Joe Ryan and the Rays’ Drew Rasmussen do exist but in this case preserving some of the team’s better minor league assets by opting to go the free agent route could be a better approach.  No one is going to give you one of the latter two for a package of the already written off players the Mets wish they could peddle elsewhere. 

For now it’s a frustrating waiting game to see what, if anything, takes place in the pitching rotation improvement.