The stages of complex negotiations
Any classification of the stages of negotiations is going to be somewhat arbitrary. I break down the stages as follows:
* Awareness
* Clarification
* Signaling
* Negotiation
* The Paper Agreement
* Interpretation of Agreement (Reframing by both sides of what they have agreed to: this is where both parties claim victory and at the same time enter into a reconciliation period)
* The Living Agreement
I will have something to say about each of these phases as I cover the negotiations from a game and decision theory perspective as they proceed in the coming months.
This week marks the end of the Signaling stage of the negotiating process, so that is where we start in this post.
MLB and MLBPA have been in the Signaling stage for past few months. During this phase, parties moving to actual negotiations use media forums and public spaces to send signals. The questions are: to whom are the sending the signals, and what are they signallng?
It may surprise you, but for the most part, the representatives of each side are signaling to the parties they are ostensibly working for. In situations like the current one, they are signaling to the public as well. Only at the end of this period are they signaling directly to the other side.
The message is different in all three cases.
They are signaling to their clients that they (the reps) will do all the talking, that the owners should keep quiet in order to maintain a unified front; that achieving the clients' goals depends on displaying no fractures or substantial differences of opinion. The public will take differences as.a lack of discipline or preparedness. The other side will take it as vulnerabilities to be exploited. The others within the group, for example, owners, will take it as reason to pursue their own interests and not agree to limits imposed on how they can use their own comparative asset advantages.
Secondarily they use the media to amplify their message to the public, which is designed to garner support and to help shape the way in which negotiations are framed in the public eye.
In the Signaling stage, MLB has a distinct advantage since so many of the teams have contracts with radio and TV stations they own (more on this in the next post and others who have sports talk shows.
The owners must 'win' this stage because, let's be frank, not many fans' lives have much in common with the lives owners live. The owners are trying to secure a cushion of good will that will no doubt erode as the negotiations proceed.
The signaling stage reaches its peak when one or the other side firmly sets the line beyond which they will not go: the bridge too far. They explicitly do this in a way that makes it clear that they intend this to be a signal to the other side. In other words, no more talking to ourselves. It's time to talk to one another; and just so you know. This is where we are prepared to make our stand.
(Signaling to one's own side that you should trust us/me is real and important. Signaling to the public is required PR. Signaling to the other side is, neither; it is pure theater, designed to heighten the drama, and, whatever the intention, able to accomplish little else.)
The past week the Signaling stage peaked and soon will pass altogether
But in a way that MLB has ample reason to and should regret.
This week Rob Manfred turned to the media to make two announcements.
First, that a salary cap is non-negotiable.
Second, according to Manfred, polling of the fans has established that 70% of them are in favor of a salary cap. And that MLB felt something akin to a moral obligation to give the fans what they overwhelmingly want. It would be repugnant to serve the interests of a mere 30% at the expense of an overwhelming number of fans who crave a salary cap.
The salary cap is not an advantage the owners seek but a moral imperative they are required to deliver. Really?
Need I point out that the fans would strongly favor free hot dogs and beer, and would vote overwhelmingly to have the owners fund their stadiums themselves instead of being subsidized by city residents through a variety of different means.
There is probably no end to the number of things MLB might find itself morally compelled to do were they to rely on answers fans would give to poorly formulated questions presented by pollers.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Four things caught my eye about Manfred's action.
It is one thing when the representatives of MLB assert that a salary cap is non-negotiable. It is quite another when Das Kommisar does.
There is no additional signaling that owners could offer now that would be any more clear or precise once the Commissioner has spoken.
His announcement effectively means the Signaling stage has run its course and the transition to actual negotiations is officially underway. (Notice the spat of FA signings that have occurred since midweek!)
If putting an end to indirect signaling was the owners' intent, they achieved that goal as soon as Manfred took to the microphone.
On the other hand, having Manfred play this role will backfire, if it hasn't already. After all, owners have long benefitted from the fact that most people think of the Commissioner as a neutral figure representing equally the interests of all the main participants in professional Major League Baseball in the US.
Why risk reminding everyone that he is chosen by the owners to run their business and he serves at their discretion.
Baseball may be America's Pastime, but it is the owner's business -- collectively speaking. And while it couldn't proceed without the players, that just means that owners have to treat the players well enough to make it an attractive way to make a living for enough of them to populate enough entertainment worthy teams.
Players well being is a constraint on owners' ability to maximize revenue and the value of their asset. But the better view is that baseball is committed to a set of personal and collective moral values, that are not constraints of profit or value maximization but are worthy ends in their own right: including the values associated with treating others, including those with whom you work to achieve collective goals, with dignity and respect.
But then again, owners are constrained by any number of factors beyond their control. They price in those constraints and manage the risks those factors present as best they can. And yet, constrained though they be, the value of owning a team continues to grow as do the number of individuals anxious to buy their way into the business.
But make no mistake. Players benefit when baseball flourishes.
My point here is very different.
The Commissioner is the owners' man in NYC, not the players; nor the players and the owners' jointly. Never was, and likely never will be.
In one fell swoop, the Mighty Manfred, (apologies to Little Steven's Underground Garage mainstay) has reminded baseball fandom who he works for, whose interests he represents; and who, for 20M+/year he is prepared to be a spokesperson for, and on whose behalf he has presented a ludicrous moral case for a salary cap.
Leader, spokesperson and moral philosopher. Not my Linkedin page. His?
C'mon, it's disingenuous and worse, but...
You all know me by now. I am always looking for the positives in every situation, however grim it may appear to the naked eye.
Were I representing the MLBPA, I would do as they have done in response.
Nothing. Let Manfred's action speak for itself. There's nothing to add
On the other hand, the owners have signaled to the players that they are in fact willing to compromise on just about every other potentially disputed issue. I would take that as an invitation I might want to cash in on at some point during the negotiations.
That's the best I can do on the bright side of the road -- for now.
One question I can't get out of my head, and a teaser
First the question.
At some point during a conversation I had today about this post with my editor, Paul, he said something along the lines of, "I wonder what the polling results would have been had the question been put differently: 'Would you support ownership insisting on a salary cap were that to result in no baseball in 2027?' Good question Paul. Which one? Both actually.
Now the teaser
Months ago I wrote that I would be covering the CBA negotiations focusing less on particular issues and more on the underlying structural features of the negotiations
In one of the few papers I have written that I still fully embrace, I argued that in complex group interactions, whether negotiations or joint activities, so much of the difficulty in finding success comes from the fact that at least one of the groups, and more often all of them, are trying to externalize the costs of problems that are endogenous to their group to other groups who are trying to do the same.
In other words, the deep structure of issues that on the surface appear to be between Groups A and B, are really best understood as issues internal to group A or group B (or both) that neither group can solve and wants instead to have those costs borne in part or whole by the other group.
That is precisely what is happening in the current situation. Most of the really hard problems facing MLB and the MLBPA are internal to the respective groups .i.e. the owners face problems that arise among the ownership group itself -- problems that may fracture them if they are not resolved. The same holds for MLBPA. In the next post I argue that this is in fact the deep structure of the problems that are being cast in terms of a salary cap. .
Hopefully, you will see that the salary cap demand has far less to do with a problem traceable to any real issue between players and owners and has everything to do with a series of issues endogenous to the owners group.










