11/16/26

Reese Kaplan -- A Fresh New Approach or More of the Same?


As the 2026 season stumbled and then spiraled into oblivion the most frustrating aspect of the demise could be debated almost equally between the roster construction filled with a passel of underperformers just as easily as it could the annoyance at the front office doing absolutely nothing until the long lost season’s August trade deadline house cleaning took place.  Surely things would change during the upcoming preparation for 2027, right?

Or not...

Friday word came out that another team — the Boston Red Sox — made a conspicuous foray into roster reinforcement by executing a somewhat questionable $14.5 million per year contract to  2026 former Brewers slugger Jake Bauers for the period of 2027 through the end of 2030.  For a guy who has had ample opportunity to prove himself in the major leagues Bauers delivered in a big way for the now World Series Champion Milwaukee team.  In 2026 he hit .266 which was decidedly out of character for a lifetime .223 hitter and delivered 86 RBIs while sending 26 long balls over the fence.


On the surface many would wonder where David Stearns was while this transaction took place.  First base is obviously one of the glacial holes the Mets need to address and being a player with his former team made Bauers a less than creative option for the former Milwaukee executive.  

For those folks who were not on the Johnny come lately Bauers bandwagon the implication as to what this $58 million investment will do to the rest of the available free agent market is a concern that bears scrutiny.  The other one-time flavor of the week — Ty France — is likely salivating over what he can now expect to earn when you consider he posted similar numbers with a .295 batting average, 21 HRs and 72 RBIs over the course of the 2026 season while also providing his usual Gold Glove level of defense at first.  

As far as fit goes, France batting right handed is a better match for the Mets current roster with lefty swinging AAAA player Jared Young having worked his way into a regular’s spot in the lineup last year while also posting uncharacteristic numbers.  While many felt France could be a reasonable option for the upcoming year, his 2026 salary of just $1.35 million after signing with the Padres during the previous off season on a minor league deal.

Now the guy who makes the New York Mets personnel decisions must face the reality that if Bauers set he bar unreasonably high with his AAV of $14.5 million, you can only wonder how high the previously affordable France will now get is anyone’s guess.  His defense and batting average are superior to Bauers and his run production is similar.  The Stearns strategy of doing nothing is once again looking as if it will bite him in the rear pocket holding his wallet as a result watching others make the market instead of him doing so.

We’ve already seen the public proclamation that Stearns is happy to allow the 2026 barely over Mendoza line Marcus Semien return as the starting second baseman, you’re kind of left wondering if a similar and questionable endorsement land on Jared Young’s back.  Bear in mind once again that the Mets are not looking to replace the production of the rag tag patchwork ensemble who spent time at first base last year for the cellar dwellers. He’s actually needing to address what was lost when he didn’t even bid on league leading slugger and current Baltimore Oriole Pete Alonso. 

Well, the clock on the wall continues to click and while other teams are making efforts to improve, thus far the Mets are reiterating the very same approach that failed them so spectacularly last year.


7 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

Having France on the Mets would be a real riot.

If they sign France multi-year, Amick would have a door slammed in his face.

Man, I hope there is a flurry of deals before the lockout.

Semien should surge to a .280 OBP. We’d all however prefer a .280 average, and so would he.

Mack Ade said...

By.now I should be writing summaries of career highlights of players coming aboard.

Instead, I keep having lengthy discussions with my publisher, watching Clemson and the Jints suck at football, and helping Mrs. Mack prepare for Thanksgiving.

Progress? I think not.

First base?

Do not sign any long term contracts with the little out there at this position.

Jared Young or a one year contract with some aging star until Billy Amick earns a shot.. but please begin discussions with Juan Soto on the benefits physically to someday bake the conversion here

Mack Ade said...

"bake" ----- beginning

TexasGusCC said...

If they would have signed France last year, Stearns would have been ripped throughout. Could Semien be last year’s France? Maybe if he was 31 again, but Stearns at least said his opportunity will be small. Wow… no one can call Stearns Captain Obvious. He seems to miss the obvious.

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

In an upcoming post, I argue that the Bauers signing (contrary to what Boston reports) is the ultimate blessing in disguise for the Mets as it now makes the best get for the Mets -- Contrares -- available. He has a one year plus an option on his contract at a very reasonable 20m/yr. And he bats RH and can be plugged into the Mets lineup as the full time regular 1B who occasionally DHs and hits either 3 or 5th, i.e. backing Soto or Benge (in my projected line-up. And 2 years blocks no one. Also if one of the prospects is ready in a year to replace him -- unlikely in my view -- there is no need to pick up the option.
The Sox need too many players and have too many at the wrong positions not to be open to a trade for a player they have so little control over.

Mack Ade said...

I too like Contreres as an option

trade someone like Wennington

Tom Brennan said...

I won’t be a contrarian on Contreras…get him!