10/19/18

Reese Kaplan -- A Strong Bench in 2019?


"Benchwarmer" is often used as a derogatory term for the players deemed not quite good enough to earn a starting role on their team due to perceived performance insufficiencies, managerial preferences or simply they don't earn as much money as the guys paid to start.  In the past the Mets have had some rather putrid players occupying these roles but going into the 2019 season it appears for once that the former position of weakness may actually become something of a strength.


Infielders

Hopefully the somewhat off-key swan song following David Wright's departure really did spell the end of Jose Reyes in a Mets uniform.  Why they kept him around for as long as they did either spoke to loyalty, the Wright Day festivities or simply the fact it's easier to do nothing that it is to do something.  We can also hope the Ty Kelly types are no longer in the running.

This year there are many contenders on the infield for backup roles, including the long forgotten Gavin Cecchini.  The former first round pick was off to a solid start with the bat before a major foot enjury ended his season.  He's versatile enough to fill in at 2nd, SS or 3rd while not embarrassing himself with the bat.  

The man with the reputation for slick fielding has been anythiing but in his brief trials at the major league level.  Also, the last thing the Mets need are more left handed batters, but the diminutive Luis Guillorme rallied to finish with a season's batting average north of .300 and has hit .287 for his minoor league career.  If only he could remember how to field...

The Tommy John Surgery-afflicted T.J. Rivera was Jeff McNeil before there was a Jeff McNeil.  He hit at every level and put together terrific ABs, albeit without much power.  Assuming his arm is good to go once again he is someone in the mix for 2B/3B.  

Fan favorite Wilmer Flores is likely on his way out the door with Pete Alonso threatening to knock it down.  The need for a right handed power bat may be met by the far less expensive Alonso, thus rendering the man without a position also looking for a job elsewhere.  If he does return, he's a potent bat with many late inning heroics on his resume.

With semi-regular playing time towards the end of the year Dom Smith started showing offensively and defensively (at 1B) why he was so well regarded in the minors.  One would assume he's the starting 1st baseman on opening day at least until they deem Alonso worthy of a promotion.  


Outfielders

Also pretty much forgotten is the now very expensive Juan Lagares who will earn as much money as will Todd Frazier.  If he can manage to stay off the DL, he's a very valuable fielder and the early indications last year was that his revamped swing was working.  Right now you'd have to figure the all lefty outfield is slated to start -- Brandon Nimmo, Michael Conforto and Jay Bruce -- making Lagares a quality reserve.  

Unfortunately after Lagares the Mets don't have much.  No one in the upper minors who is a true outfielder is on the 40-man roster, so unless you think Dom Smith or the injured Phil Evans can man a 5th outfielder role, they're likely looking to the outside to bring someone in who can fulfill that need.


Catchers

Once again this year we saw flashes from Kevin Plawecki showing what he could do.  At this point I'm perfectly fine with him as a backup and I'd like to see Tomas Nido get challenged to hit some more at the new home in AAA in Syracuse.  I really think that if the Mets can't swing a reasonable deal for one of the many catchers who are rumored to be on the market (or available as free agents) they may simply go back to the well one more time and offer the job to Travis d'Arnaud (assuming his already lackluster throwing has not diminished even further).  


Conclusion

As I see it, the only bench job up for grabs is the role of 5th outfielder (asssuming no surprising trades of starting players take place).  Then again, consdering there is no GM hired and the GM Meetings are taking place in about two weeks, I can't foresee that happening either.  

10 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

TJ Rivera should be a big "addition", and otherwise, maybe Gavin Cecchini in-house? I don't expect much from him.

I still think Gimenez could be a mid 2019 call up. They may try to patch together back up guys until then.

bill metsiac said...

Wilmer should be non-tendered, but hopefully he has enough trade value to bring back a RH 5th OFer. If we don't get one that way, or as a FA, I don't have a problem if Jackson returns in that role. His days as a starter are done, but he can fill the bench role.

And let's not forget that we hopefully get ourown RH bat back in mid-season.

Mack Ade said...

We are basically in good shape for bench plaers less as u say an additional outfielder

TexasGusCC said...

Rivera will be coming back as a 30 year old that hasn’t played in close to two years, and has no power or speed? Sorry TJ, I’d remove him from the 40.

TDA is supposed to come back after the all-star break according to SNY, so that’s an easy no thank you.

Wilmer Flores is an easy yes due to his power off the bench and ability to play second base should Jeff McNeil get hurt once again.

Dom Smith is Jay Bruce Jr., so he’s on the roster.

That pretty much is your bench nowadays: The backup catcher, Smith, Flores and Lagares, because teams want to carry 8 relievers so...

Zozo said...

I feel Bryce Bentz would be a more than capable 5th Outfielder that is cheap and can handle all 3 spots?

Tom Brennan said...

Gimenez has not played a lot in the AFL so far, annoyingly, but last night walked as a pinch hitter and doubled his next AB.

Lindsay singled, doubled and fanned twice - now 4 for 8 with a single, double, and 2 homers.

Nogosek was good in 1.2 innings of relief too. The Pounder had the night off.

TexasGusCC said...

The only adjustment here would be to switch out Alonso with Smith in late April and to go 7 relievers and carry another middle infielder.

Rustyjr said...

Well if utilize the platoon like they seem to have over the past few seasons it looks like the bench could be a strong asset

Anonymous said...

I kind of disagree with every single poster above. Let me explain why.

I think one of the several key problems here with the 2018 NY Mets team (like a handful of seasons before this one as well) is their reluctance to severe ties with players who have not really done much of anything as a NY Met and are only really good at getting hurt and being out for the whole season. Four words, get rid of them all. My bad, that was five.

These players must have read the Karl Pavano biography or something.

The second key problem with the 2018 NY Mets, is that they keep endlessly bringing back the same bench players, year after year also, but somehow expecting them to be garnish much better results from each one, which does not ever seem to happen in the real world. They are what they are. A bird is a bird, not a jackrabbit.

Players like Ty Kelly, Luis Guillorme, Tomas Nido, Paul Seawall...How many times do we need to see these guys play up with the NY Mets? Hasn't their fate already been cast in granite by their own respective performances? Be honest.

2019 to me, should be all about a fresh new start, a start this time in the right direction. Lose the all the bad player ideas, and start again may make for very good advice.

Anonymous said...

Wilmer Flores is the perennial bench/hurt guy. Wilmer I could see having back in 2019, but he has not one but two bad knees now. Practically crawl off the field in 2018 to end his season. Come on. Bad knees usually involves osteoarthritis, or a knee operation. This stuff just doesn't go away. It is a degenerative ailment.

Just how much time Wilmer Flores has left on his knees no one even knows, but the clock is probably ticking now.

Move on people. Severe the ties to the wrong guys. If the team does not do it now, they never will.

If you put say a Christian Colon, a TJ Riveria, or a Gavin Cecchini in Wilmer's place, how much is lost really? Wilmer's made some money, let him go elsewhere now to be someone else's bench player.