You read some opinions about the Rule 5 draft protections (or the lack thereof) yesterday in a couple of the posts, but I have a different viewpoint, so I will weigh in with my thoughts.
The deadline has passed for teams to protect players from being chosen in the Rule 5 draft by placing them on the Mets' 40-man roster. Only one player was protected in that way - #1 prospect Jefferson Rojas. It was a nail biter for me, because Rojas was not added until very late. The fact that he was the only one protected amongst a sizable number of prospects who had met the service requirement means that David Stearns was willing to take a calculated risk with his roster.
Risk number one was that the Rule 5 draft will actually happen. If the owners issue a lockout order on December first with the expiration of the current Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA), then the Rule 5 draft would not occur on December 5th as planned - it would be either postponed or cancelled. Cancellation, of course, would eliminate any risk that the Mets would lose a player. Postponement until a new CBA is in pace kicks the can down the road quite a bit, but it also brings with it the opportunity to set new rules and deadlines on protection, giving teams a second chance at protection. The probability of a lockout is extremely high, and therefore the probability of losing a player (or players) on December 5th is very low. Good calculation David.
Risk number two was that another team would choose an eligible player in the Rule 5 draft. Given the quantity and quality of players unprotected in the Mets system (here is the list), the risk seems substantial.
However, one has to look deeper into the specifics of the Rule 5 deal. If a player is chosen, that player must be put on the choosing team's active roster (26-man, not the 40) and remain there for the entire season. If not, that player is returned to the original team.
So for the Mets to truly lose a prospect, that player would have to be ready to contribute enough at a MLB level to hold a roster spot for a year. They can't be optioned back to the minors to work on improvements. If it is a position player, they have to be among the top 13 players in the receiving organization to hold a spot. If it is a pitcher, given the number of arms teams go through during a season, that pitcher had better contribute regularly, because hiding him is like reducing the number of pitchers on the active roster to 12.
With that in mind, Risk number two becomes much lower. Sure, Jefferson Rojas showed signs last year that he could handle any minor league level. Much like Benge and Ewing and Thornton last year, it would be likely that Rojas would stick to a MLB roster. That is why he was protected. But the others that were left hanging out there are far less likely to stick for a full season and therefore would not be lost to the Mets forever - just one season. And during that season, they would become a valuable MLB test case with no impact to the Mets' roster. Let's look at the names:
Jack Wenninger - he looked like a solid pitcher when he sailed through the minor league organization, but then stalled somewhat in AAA Syracuse posting a 5-8 record with a 4.54 ERA with a 1.46 WHIP. Not exactly a lock to spend the year with an MLB roster.
Chris Suero - a favorite of mine because of his versatility. I have seen him catch one game and play center field the next. But last season he had a .201 batting average and a .742 OPS for a AA team. Would you give up one of your 13 position player roster slots on an MLB team for a season for that?
Gary Gill Hill - another favorite of mine since he came over from the Rays in the Peralta deal. But he has seen five innings in a single game on a AAA mound. For a team to select a player with that little experience and keep him among the 13 pitchers on their MLB roster for a full season is quite a gamble. Personally, he is the one other Met I would have liked to see protected, but it is only a medium risk that he is poached.
Jacob Reimer - a rising star in the Mets minors due to his powerful bat, but he was a defensive liability and had a high strikeout rate before he lost considerable time due to injury. Many writers put him among the top 10 prospects, but to me he is a questionable bat without a position. Low risk of losing him and high probability he is returned in 2028 if selected.
D'Andre Smith - a versatile player with both infield and outfield skills that has been around in the Mets' development system for years. He finally had somewhat of a breakout last year, hitting .294 in the last 32 games of the season in AAA Syracuse. He is a medium risk of being selected, but with the Mets loaded with middle infield prospects and all set with their MLB outfield, this is a risk worth taking.
I could go on, but I think you get my point. David Stearns was not cavalier with his decisions Tuesday. He took some very calculated risks, and it appears to me that it was a sound choice.

13 comments:
As I read articles around the Internet concerning this topic, it appears that only a few teams put all their eligible and stash worthy prospects on the 40 man roster. The two reasons most often cited are: (1) if these players are on the roster, they cannot participate in spring training and work on their game; (2) the cancellation of the draft during the previous lockout is expected to happen again. Further, if they will do it again after the resumption of league business, qualifications may change and the eligibles will be redone.
It is a very good point to remember that if there is a strike, you have to be off the 40 men roster to play in the minor leagues. Through that lens, Plus the points that Paul is making, David’s decisions make a lot of sense.
Further, I too am very surprised that they let a pitcher that can control four pitches be unprotected. Gill Hill also improved his velocity in the Mets, so how do you not block him?
Shhhh, if you start giving Stearns credit you will incite the Alonso cult.
I will Re-Pete….Never let anyone named Pete leave.
There will be no Rule 5 Draft
Details at 10am
Gill Hill may end up giving another team’s fans a Thrill. I still remember those 160 hits allowed in 140 innings in 2026, 135 of which innings came in AA or lower. In the majors, would that be 160 hits in 70 innings? My off-the-cuff estimate is that if you imported the average offensive portion of any AA team straight to the majors, they would hit .115. Yet those same hitters had no problem hitting the Gill on the Hill, Dr Suess reminded me.
As we move towards December, i hate the word DRAFT. WHY am i not in PUERTO RICO covering the PR Winter League? I must be crazy.
Wenninger had a shaky 5.82 ERA in 56 innings in AAA in the second half, with a bloated 1.54 WHIP.
Maybe he is no more than the next Dom Hamel? Hamel was the #9 Mets prospect in 2022 and 2023, and has been a total pinata above A BALL.
He and Wenninger have similar velocity,
Hopefully Jack is soon to be more like the next Mike Vasil.
Wenninger turned out to be a big disappointment last season. I kept waiting for a rebound that never came
I no longer consider him Queens bound as a starter
Gill Hill is the one I worried about when he remained unprotected. I understand the calculus, but at the same time there are probably four expendable players on the 40-man roster that I would risk the waiver wire before risking Gill HIll.
Don't give up on Jack yet, Mack. He always had such a commanding presence on the mound in AA. I think he just lost some confidence when he got hit hard in AAA. It is possible for him to build it back with some success.
Paul, do you have any thoughts on Wenninger vs. the failed Hamel? My guess is Wenninger is the better prospect, in that he pitched better in AA and also (while shaky) not as bad as Hamel has been in AAA.
Hamel is the type of guy that I cite when I talk about pitchers making the major leagues, while so many hitters don’t. Hamel did get his one inning in with the NY Mets. He didn’t alliw a run, but did allow three base runners. But he can tell the grandkids he made the major leagues. Hitters get screwed. So many never even get that single game.
Post a Comment