11/22/26

Tom Brennan: Painful 2022’s Top 30 Mets Prospects; Skubal and Tong; Extension Dimension

Stock Photo by Herm Card - Herm444@gmail.com

REALLY?  KHALIL LEE WAS RANKED # 7??  
That IS troubling.

FIRST, THOUGH, I WILL START WITH SKUBAL AND TONG…

Jonah Tong recently said essentially that he would be thrilled if Tariq Skubal became a Met.

Which got me thinking about Tong. 

He has scuffled a bit after a brilliant 2025 minor campaign. 

But he is not turning 24 until the middle of June in 2027.

What did the great and mighty Skubal do in the majors at age 23 and 24?

9-16, 4.60 ERA in his age 23 and 2024 seasons. And an improved, but not stunning, 7-8, 3.52 ERA at age 25.

So…have great patience with young Jonah. 

He may never be the next Skubal…but Tong’s best is yet to come.


SECOND, I WILL CONSIDER AJ EWING’S NEW TAX BRACKET

Saw this: “The Mets made a massive, long-term commitment with one of their brightest young players, agreeing to an eight-year, $95 million extension with outfielder , per a source. The deal includes a 9th-year team option for 2035 worth $25 million. The club has not confirmed the report.”


Benge presumably will be next. 


Talent worth extending. Congratulations.


Mamdani asked his Controller to calculate Ewing’s NYC tax liabilities for those nine years.  He will extract his pound of flesh.


Just remember, AJ, health-wise, running into fences is not good for durability.


Ewing was a high school 4th rounder in 2023, induced to sign with nearly $200,000 in overslot $$. Money reallocated VERY well on him in that draft.

Kudos.


A.J. Ewing, SS, Springboro HS (OH)
Slot Value: $483,000
Signing status: SIGNED ($675,000)


NOW…BACK TO MY REGULARLY SCHEDULED ARTICLE…

When it comes to balls and bats, I am a results-oriented person.

I thought I’d take a look back at a recent year’s TOP 30 prospect list, in this case the Mets’ site’s top 30 for 2022, from a “subsequent results” focus.

Results Conclusion: NOT GOOD

The top 4 guys (familiar names - see below) have turned out only to be semi-regular Mets and quite mediocre, so far, quite frankly.  Of that, I’m quite clear.

Just below that, the #5 thru #11 dudes have been awful, quite disappointing. 

Many below # 11 have been brutal, as well….

#’s 13, 14, 16, 18, 19? Messrs. Juan, Palmer, Santos, Dominguez, Schwartz? 

Brutal.

No, those ranked players have not been good at all.

The only ones below that top 10 who turned out to do well were Christian Scott and the jettisoned Jake Mangum. Both solid, but neither so far with a big impact. 

Carlos Cortes has done fairly (and surprisingly) well with the bat, too, but his fielding must be atrocious, as he is -0.7 WAR in 480 career PAs.

The few others who’ve made it to the big leagues have been of limited impact and quite mediocre.

NO, NOT GOOD AT ALL. 

HERE IS THE TOP 30 LIST FOR 2022 - GOOD OR BAD?

DO NOT BE BASHFUL - SPEAK UP- YOU DECIDE:


PLAYERPOS
1
Photo headshot of Francisco Alvarez
Francisco Alvarez
C
2
Photo headshot of Brett Baty
Brett Baty
3B/OF
3
Photo headshot of Ronny Mauricio
Ronny Mauricio
2B/SS/OF
4
Photo headshot of Mark Vientos
Mark Vientos
3B/1B
5
Photo headshot of Matt Allan
Matt Allan
RHP
6
Photo headshot of Alex Ramírez
Alex Ramírez
OF
7
Photo headshot of Khalil Lee
Khalil Lee
OF
8
Photo headshot of Nick Plummer
Nick Plummer
OF
9
Photo headshot of Dom Hamel
Dom Hamel
RHP
10
Photo headshot of Joel Díaz
Joel Díaz
RHP
11
Photo headshot of Calvin Ziegler
Calvin Ziegler
RHP
12
Photo headshot of José Buttó
José Buttó
RHP
13
Photo headshot of Simon Juan
Simon Juan
OF
14
Photo headshot of Jaylen Palmer
Jaylen Palmer
3B/OF
15
Photo headshot of Carlos Cortes
Carlos Cortes
2B/OF
16
Photo headshot of Junior Santos
Junior Santos
RHP
17
Photo headshot of Eric Orze
Eric Orze
RHP
18
Photo headshot of Robert Dominguez
Robert Dominguez
RHP
19
Photo headshot of JT Schwartz
JT Schwartz
1B
20
Photo headshot of Hayden Senger
Hayden Senger
C
21
Photo headshot of Mike Vasil
Mike Vasil
RHP
22
Photo headshot of Jake Mangum
Jake Mangum
OF
23
Photo headshot of Jordany Ventura
Jordany Ventura
RHP
24
Photo headshot of Josh Walker
Josh Walker
LHP
25
Photo headshot of Christian Scott
Christian Scott
RHP
26
Photo headshot of Joander Suarez
Joander Suarez
RHP
27
Photo headshot of Nick Meyer
Nick Meyer
C
28
Photo headshot of Carlos Rincon
Carlos Rincon
OF
29
Photo headshot of Jose Peroza
Jose Peroza
3B/2B/1B
30
Photo headshot of Brian Metoyer
Brian Metoyer
RHP
30
Brian
Metoyer
RHP, Syracuse Mets, AAA
  • AGE
    29
  • BATS
    R
  • DOB
    11/13/1996
  • THROWS
    R
  • HT
    6' 3"
  • DRAFTED
    2018, 40th (1190) - NYM
  • WT
    173
  • ETA
    2023

Scouting grades: Fastball: 55 | Curveball: 70 | Changeup: 40 | Control: 45 | Overall: 40

The last 40-round Draft could very well be the 2019 edition. One year before that, the Mets used their 40th-round selection on Metoyer out of NAIA program Louisiana State University of Alexandria. He was dominant in relief for High-A Brooklyn in 2021 with a 2.18 ERA, 0.91 WHIP and 46 strikeouts in 33 innings with the Cyclones and made a late two-game appearance at Double-A Binghamton. The right-hander closed out his age-24 season in the Arizona Fall League, where he fanned 17 but walked 10 while allowing 12 earned runs in 10 1/3 innings.

Lanky at a listed 6-foot-3 and 173 pounds, Metoyer earns the biggest praise for his curveball, a plus-plus offering that could play in the Majors right away. The 79- to 81-mph deuce regularly pops 3,000-plus rpm, and he posted the 35 highest spin rates as measured by Statcast in last year’s Fall League. The vertical break toward the bottom of the zone helps generate a high ground-ball rate, and his 69.2 GB percentage was tops among Mets pitchers with at least 30 innings in 2021. The right-hander is typically around 94-96 mph with a cutting fastball, helping keep balls on the dirt. Metoyer went to the AFL to work on a changeup, but that remains a distant third pitch.

Because of all the movement, Metoyer can struggle to stay in the zone. That lack of control (along with the lackluster third pitch) keeps him in relief, and it played into the Mets’ decision to leave him off the 40-man roster last November when he became Rule 5-eligible. The velocity and spin of the curveball give him enough of an arsenal to feature in a Major League bullpen, and a back-end role is possible if he can land more strikes in 2022.





8 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

This list of 30, looked at currently, I would rank as follows:

1. Christian Scott

2. Francisco Alvarez

3. Jake Mangum

Then, the mediocre:

4. Brett Baty

5. Mark Vientos

6. Carlos Cortes

7. Jose Butto

8. Mike Vasil

9. Eric Orze

10. Josh Walker

Then, the Below Mediocre:

11.Hayden Senger

12. Brian Metoyer - still TBD

AND EIGHTEEN BUSTS

Mack Ade said...

Re: Ewing

A.J. will not lose a single shekel if he gets injured running into anything

Contracts like this sort of invite reckless actions

Mack Ade said...

I'm currently working on my top Mets prospect list, which will begin mid-week at 10am

Tom Brennan said...

Put shoulder pads and a helmet on him.

He did accrue 3.1 WAR in approximately 70% of a full season. That was a 4.5 WAR pace over a full season. Hence, the L/T signing.

Tom Brennan said...

Good deal

Tom Brennan said...

The traded away Pete Crow Armstrong accrued more WAR in 2026 than this entire list did, hands-down. Had he stayed this would have been a solid list to look back on.

Tom Brennan said...

I googled how much WAR those 11 accrued in 2026. Answer: not much: In 2026, these top 11 players combined for 2.6 total bWAR (Baseball-Reference) and 4.6 total fWAR (FanGraphs)

Tom Brennan said...

Crow had 9.8 bWAR, and 10.6 fWAR in 2026, all by himself.

Triple what the Mets top 11 other prospects from 2026 accrued, in total.