11/14/19

Mack – FWIW - Astros, Alonso, Luxury Tax, Chili, Open Thread




    1.    Baseball needs to act swiftly with this Houston Astro stealing signs mess. Even one of their ex-pitchers, Mike Fiers confirms this. Sports need some strict guidelines on infractions like this. Spousal abuse would lead this list. In this case, make the baseball world know that everyone needs to play under the same rules. Hurt their future because they cheated in the past. Take away ‘X’ amount of their 2020 draft picks and shut them out of the 2020 International bonus pool.


    2.    Everybody seems to be jumping on the “build around Alonso” band wagon. What do you think we did last year with the addition of Justin Wilson and J.D. Davis, and the improvement of Jeff McNeil, Amed Rosario and  Dom Smith? Sure, more is needed… a viable backup catcher, a defensive CFer, an SP5, and multiple relief pitchers… but we would be looking to improve here even if Wilmer Flores was still playing first.


    3.    Whether we like it or not, this team has a cheap owner that refuses to operate above a $208mil salary level and thus, generate a 20% tax on the overage. This, even though the monies owed David Wright and Yoenes Cespedes are a year away from disappearing and the team would naturally return to a level below the $208mil. Bad contracts, piss poor drafting, and disrespecting the International market put us in this position and, though we have improved in the last two areas, we have to live with this until, at least 2021. Maybe 2022. Our best prospects are kiddies and need time to grow up.


    4.    The Mets and Chili Davis have agreed to a 2-year deal to return as the Mets hitting coach. You need to embrace this. Those in the know credit Davis with the growth of players like Pete Alonso, Dom Smith, and, especially, Amed Rosario, We wouldn’t have come as close as we did in playing 2019 playoff without the work of this guy with our batters. The best part of this is we don’t have to break in a new hitting coach at the same time as we break in our new manager. Love the move.


    5.    And lastly… it is tough to keep coming up with what direction to go in the off season. So, I need your help. We have had a very successful post feature called OPEN THREAD where I ask a question and readers like you chime in with comments. My question is this… do you have anything you want me to ask on this series? I would love you to write back as a comment here, what you want me to ask in the future.  


 (but, what do I know…)

8 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

Houston was a stunning 60-21 at home, a far worse 47-34 on the road.

Minnesota, likely not sealing signs, was 46-35 at home, but a far better 55-26 on the road.

Yes, indeed, Houston should be severely punished.


Building around Alonso and Jake - these dudes deserve World Series appearances, so while you always want to build around your good players, the stakes are higher if you want to get to the World Series (or even the playoffs). So, as I wrote in response to John's article this AM, spend over the cap for one year. $10 million over is just a $2 million luxury tax. A better team will make that up at the turnstiles and in concessions sales.

Chili D helped the Mets to have their 7th highest scoring team ever, against a very tough schedule. Great to keep him.

Mack Ade said...

tOM -

I 1000% agree with you about spending $10mil more in 2020 than projected.

The one year penalty is pocket change in this game and it could be the difference of getting one more award winning player on this team.

Reese Kaplan said...

You have to give to get. So for an open thread question, who of McNeil, Conforto, Rosario, Syndergaard, Ramos, Lugo and Gimenez would you be willing to trade and for what type of return?

Tom Brennan said...

Reese Kaplan might not win a Cy Young, but he ought to win a Dick Young award after his reliever article series.

Mike Freire said...

Houston should be punished, I agree. You just wonder if the punishment will be enough of a deterrent to keep them honest? Reminds me of the cheating Atlanta did in the past (Latin prospects).....yeah, they were punished a bit, but it didn't slow them down at all.

I am pleased with the retention of Chili Davis.......the team was better offensively last year and he had a lot to do with it.

Tom Brennan said...

Mack, absolutely. A $2 million luxury tax penalty is peanuts.

Reese Kaplan said...

In Dick Young fashion does that mean I'll campaign to get Jake out of town? 🤔

Tony said...

Houston should be penalized & perhaps the Wilpons will spend some money.