11/16/26

Paul Articulates - First things first


As the off-season ticks away heading towards the expiration of the CBA and the inevitable lockout, very little has been happening in the trade and free agent markets.  

Sure, there are a bunch of players being signed to minor league deals and small trades of low impact players, but the only signing of significance so far was the Red Sox addition of Jack Bauer at an above market value $14.5M per season.  And the Sox already had Willson Contreras.

Jack is one of the few first basemen out there that have been written about as potential free agent targets, with the other being the as-yet-unsigned Ty France.  France is a better defender and has had a statistically better career than Bauer, so one could only imagine that he will command better numbers when signed.  That is a lot of money for a first baseman that doesn’t deliver huge power numbers.

First base, as we all know, is a weak point for the Mets.  We currently have Jared Young as the default incumbent, and his career numbers are not much worse than Bauer, but it is still a weak position.  So one may ask, “What else is out there”?

Let’s start with durable players at the position.  Over the past three seasons, only eleven players have played at least 100 games at first in each season. 


A quick look at this table confirms that most of the notable first basemen are pretty unavailable – Olsen, Alonso, and Freeman cannot be pried away from their current teams for a reasonable amount of collateral.  

The same goes for Bryce Harper and Munetaka Murakami who is not on the list because he played in NPB in 2024 and 2025.  No one else on that list had an OPS over .800 last year, so all of us armchair GMs are immediately into the value trade of durability versus power production versus defense.  There is also the question of age.  Walker is 35, Harper is 34, and France is 32.

There are a few new names out there that are worthy of a look. This includes rookie of the year (it hurts to say that) Sal Stewart, 24-year-old Nick Kurtz from the A's, 25-year-old Nolan Schanuel from the Angels, and a trio of 29-year-olds Busch, Naylor, and Pasquantino.  Let’s take a close look:



Clearly Stewart is not a trade candidate – you would have to give up someone like Benge for Stewart and I would much rather have Benge.  The same probably goes for Kurtz, although the A’s have been a trade partner before.  But with only two more controllable years, Busch and Schanuel could be had, and Pasquantino is even more likely.

Do the options of trading for either Busch, Schanuel, or Pasquantino look more attractive than paying big bucks for Josh Naylor with his -9 DRS?  Yes, in a word.  

Is it more attractive than Jared Young, Brett Baty, or Mark Vientos?  Probably – although the grass always looks greener on the other side.  LAA and CHC are big market teams, so those players are used to life under the media microscope.  Pasquantino would have a big step up if he were the next guy to try to fill Pete Alonso’s shoes.

The reason I have brought some of these names to your attention is because I struggle when I hear that the Mets are talking to Alec Bohm or that anyone would consider bringing Rafael Devers’ attitude into the Mets clubhouse.  Since we are not likely going to be able to acquire any of the big name first basemen out there, the Mets are better off getting a young, coachable player with MLB experience at first base than any of the other options, including playing some of our young prospects at an unfamiliar position as they break into the majors. 

15 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

Nick Kurtz? Trade the farm to get him.

Jack Bauer will have 24 HRs and 24 RBIs. But he will save the world. Even Boston.

Mack Ade said...

Will Bauer be known as the Designated First Baseman?

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

I think everyone is missing the obvious: Contreras. He has one year and an option. Perfect time-wise and a better hitter and fielder than most anyone on the list (all star adjacent talent as well). The Sox have limited control over him via contract and they have needs at positions and can't afford to have both a !B and a left fielder (who I don't want) who they can't play. They need to regain some flexibility. They need first line and secondary pitching as well. I am sure we can put together a package that does little if any harm to us and gets us Contreras while we figure out who if anyone rises from within the organization

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

I also think folks here are a little harsh on Bohm. He had a terrible family situation last year (suing his parents for frauding him out of his money) and after the deadline he moved to 1B and hit over 300 driving in runs and playing sound defense. He needs an opportunity to reestablish his value, so a very short term contract with a slight overpay is not a terrible idea. He's my third choice behind Contreras and Burger, but all make short term sense -- especially Contreras who the Mets should have gone after instead of Polanco

Dan said...

Houston needs to clear up the logjam in their infield and like everyone else, they are looking for pitching. Trade them Senga, Wenninger and Josh Franklin for Christian Walker. Mets get a right-handed bat, with a good glove, who hits for power. Houston gets a $5M savings in addition to a trio of bullpen arms.

Mack Ade said...

there are trades out there that easily can be made but it just doesn't seem like anyone wants to deal with Stearns anymore

Mack Ade said...

there is absolutely nothing wrong with Contreras in 2027. Past that... ???

Mack Ade said...

Jules, I don't want Bohm. I'd rather use Baty here than him

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

The Mets are looking to trade Senga as a starter and the interest in him has largely been in that role. They get more value if another team sees him that way. Wenninger's role is as yet undefined and he has a lot of team control. He is not a throw in piece in my book. I much prefer seeing what is necessary to ply Contreras from the Red Sox. I have been pushing exploring this option for quite a while now, starting with the departure of Alonso.
France will get too much for too long to suit me, though once the Sox traded for Contreras and Gray, I urged the Mets pursue France. At this point, we have to see whether anyone from the farm can take over at first by 2029. That is the coverage we need.

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

Mack, you may be surprised to learn that on my opening day roster for 2027, I have Baty on the squad and Young not. Versatility counts for me. I don't think Bohm is a 'never on my team' kind of personality. I've pushed for Contreras from the outset, but I don't know why Bohm is a no-no. I prefer Burger for power potential and low key player, but we could do a lot worse than getting someone who hits lefties at over .300 and can play sound defense, runs well and has 15-20 HR power and drives in runs. 1yr with team option for second with a buyout payment, he surely improves the team significantly.
9M for one year with team option and 1M buyout of the option is a fair offer for a big performance upgrade. And you don't have to trade anyone to get him. No injury history and not old either.

Paul Articulates said...

Contreras would be a very good add if we can get him. I was surprised that Boston signed Bauer if their only intent was to get a decent DH. Otherwise, if there is any play with Oakland/Sacramento/Vegas, I would go after Kurtz with gusto.

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

kurtz would be an actual answer, and if we can get him, we should be willing to give up either Amick or Mathis and a pitching prospect near major league ready like Wenninger and an outfield prospect or one of the many second tier of our middle infield prospects,

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

I realize Kurtz was overall #4 pick so we would very likely have to give up Wenninger and either Voit or Petri. Frankly, I would prefer to give up Morabito, Weninger and Petri. and get something in addition to Kurtz from the lower minors with a high ceiling. Or in a minute I would give up Wenninger and Alvarez

Tom Brennan said...

Kurtz would cost an arm and BOTH legs. He is off to an extraordinary start to his career.

Tom Brennan said...

A truism in life in general, as well as in baseball, is that some guys can’t get to first base.