Apparently I’m not the only one questioning the approach being take by the Mets during this accelerated off season that requires roster decisions to be made by the end of the month prior to the owners’ lockout taking place. Yes, the club has held a meeting with top-of-the-line starting pitcher Tarik Skubal but it’s the myriad of other needs that don’t seem to be getting any significant attention to making improvements.
Let’s take the first base situation once again. Yes, Jared Young had a nice but hardly exceptional year after making his way into the starting position for most of the season when he was merely an afterthought back in Port St. Lucie during Spring Training. Even if you doubled his output to project his output on a full time roll for the entire 2027 season he’d be slated near the bottom of the league’s comparative stats for the position.
Granted, there are no Skubal level free agents out there for that role. Yes, both Japanese import Teruaki Sato and Korea import Roh Si-hwan both have 30 HR potential and likely wouldn’t cost nearly as much as former first baseman got from the Orioles, but there is no assrance that they will adjust to American baseball hitting with the aplomb of the Dodgers’ Shohei Ohtani. With the prospect of a great deal of money needing to be spent in the attempt to lock up Skubal the Mets are instead making the rounds of the scratch and dent section of the personnel supermarket. Is that assessment overly harsh? Well, let’s take a look...
There are the slew of platoon partner options that would provide the right handed half of a first base platoon with returning concussion victim Jared Young. Here you would find guys like turning 40 Paul Goldschmidt, on-again/off-again stellar fielding Ty France, now ex-Phillie Alec Bohm and others who have not yet seen the light of the auction block from the Mets. There have bee no rumors regarding Ryan Mountcastle, Rhys Hoskins, Carlos Santana nor switch hitter Josh Bell.
Now it is possible to obtain a viable player using the trade market but then you are sacrificing not only the money to pay the man but also current baseball roster assets to make it happen. If you can do it while trading away someone not in your current long term plans then it may be a reasonable way to go. Many stories have been written about the Mets showing interest in the Rangers’ Christian Walker who is going into the final year of his contract while they would in turn send over one of Kodai Senga or Sean Manaea to balance out the payrolls on both sides. In this type of scenario your payroll commitment doesn’t much change but you do address a fundamental need.
Looking to the minors for help still seems unreasonable as Ryan Clifford has virtually played himself off the team and Billy Amick still needs to cut down on his strikeout issues to prove he’s ready to ascend up the development ladder. If, however, you buy into the prospective arrival of Amick for the 2028 season then a one-year tide-us-over move on someone like Walker, Goldschmidt or others of that ilk could make sense.
Where it is much less clear is the pursuit of someone like Ty France who witnessed the recent price and duration played for Jake Bauers and who will likely want a similar offer. As a result the move for a decent but not great option like France could also block Amick’s future.
Now it could go another way in which the Mets land one of the Asian imports for the position as they recently padded their International pool money budget by making a small trade with the Rangers on a prospect for that compensation. In this case you’d be insulating yourself against a Clifford like fall from the cliff if it happened to Amick or it could turn Amick into a trade chip.
If none of the more conspicuous actions take place be prepared for the next Jorge Polanco level of solution who was Stearns’ last strike at finding the next Polar Bear.


7 comments:
Frankly, I would push this position in 2027 and either go with Young until Billy Boy is ready or sign a one year contract with someone like Goldschmidt
Agree. Get the SP roles filled first.
Jared Young hit .281 in the second half, in part because he didn’t fan a lot. I’d like to see him get a real shot for 2027, Somebody ought to able to platoon with him, as he hit a very solid .275 vs. righties. Goldschmidt hit .300 vs. lefties in 2026. Seems like a good one year fix.
SP is first and second and maybe third top priorities. Not a fan of trading bad contracts for one another in general, but Walker/Senga not the worst idea, but I really don't believe that any of the prospects will be ready to take over 1B in 2028. Gun to my head I would keep Baty over Young because of the former's overall versatility. There isn't a perfect solution at 1B. IMHO, the closest is making a trade for Contreras, if possible at reasonable cost. He provides 2 years for one of the prospects to rise, if any is going to.
I think getting a top of the rotation pitcher and a sound, experienced middle rotation pitcher should be immediate focus. Pitching has got to be our foundation going forward. Bullpen needs reinforcements in high leverage situations: not question marks: Those are the priorities: We will know about Skubal by the end of next week, and figure out then whether we have to switch to a different strategy or look for the complementary mid rotation starter.
I would have my eyes on Loisaga and Morejon for the pen as well, but would not be bidding against myself on either, and it takes time for markets to develop so likely nothing happens on that front until the expected lockout is resolved.
Trades will likely wait until the new CBA is in place.
No rush on 1B therefore. Other than Contreras, every other option is a compromise anyway.
You must have been watching reruns of "Walker Texas Ranger" when you wrote this! He's an Astro. But otherwise, the idea of importing him here is a solid one. Senga or Manaea, cash if they take Manaea, plus an arm from the minor leagues like Davis or Watson could get it done. He has the glove and his bat lengthens the line up.
Ha
I don't think you give up an additional arm and pay down on Manaea to get Walker for one year. I also think there is interest in Senga as a starter; and with a paydown Manaea as well, but who knows.
Post a Comment