10/29/26

MACK - Bo Bichette Remains A Met

 

Remember earlier today I mentioned in a column that the talent in the free agent class being released was weak and the Mets were going to have to look to trade for their next slab of prime red meat?

Well, I was wrong.

The meat arrived around an hour ago when third baseman Bo Bichette decided to opt IN for $42 big ones in 2027 and remain the New York Mets third baseman.

I'm being told he also intends on opting in for 2028.

This changes everything for prospects and gives the Mets the option needed to package together a couple of them to grade up on another position.

Great night to be a Mets fan.



29 comments:

aptoklas said...

Not crazy about decision. I’d rather free up the 42 million. They should convert him to 1st base.

Mets have good prospects at 2nd and 3rd , no one reliable to play 1st and Bichette has no future with the team.

He could be a placeholder at first and maybe give something close Keith Hernandez offense if he has a good year

Mets should tell him to get a first base glove now

Paul Articulates said...

You can't just give a spoon to a player and turn him into a first baseman. That was the fallacy that got us in this place last year, and Polanco still remains on the team. Better to leave Bichette at third and start packaging things up to go get a real first baseman. And don't say Jake Bauers. He is not much different than Jared Young, but he played on a team that was in sync.

royhobbs7 said...

Thank you Paul. You're absolutely correct on both accounts! But Sato isn't coming here as long as Stearns refuses to be open to extended contracts. However, he'd be able to justify a 3 Yr deal to sign Ty France to play 1B. I.e., France is good at RP (Run-Prevention)!

royhobbs7 said...

Bichette is our 3B next year (even if we play only 80 games due to the lockout)!

Mack Ade said...

I can't believe Paul has to defend retaining Bichette.

And now you would have us shifting players off their best position

Bichette started slowly as a Met but adjusted both his physical and mental game and hit over .280 the second half of the season.

And once again... it is not our money

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

Bichette is too short to play 1B. I also think that there is value in having stability on one side of the infield for next year..

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

Paul is also correct about getting a real 1B.

Mack Ade said...

THe strange thing is fans want their team to have the best availabe players at every position, yet when you do, they balk at the cost of them personally not spending a dime in the transaction

aptoklas said...

Looks like my idea Bichette should transition to first is not popular. Let me develop it more.

Many folks want Mets to sign Sato to play first base but Sato is primarily a 3rd baseman who has played a little outfield so if he came over to play 1st base he’d need to learn a new position too.

An argument is made since the Polanco transition was a failed experiment the Mets should learn from their mistake. I’d respond that Bichette is younger, healthier and more athletic than Polanco. We also don’t know how Polanco would have done at 1st since he was injured the entire year and his injury had nothing to do with the proposed transition.

Bichette never played 3rd base before last year and requited himself well. 1st base is an easier position than third and many 3rd basemen have made the transition . Here are some:

Joe Torre
Miguel Cabrera
Eddie Mathews
Wade Boggs
Rafael Devers
Albert Pujols
Jim Thome
Harmon Killebrew
Ryan Zimmerman
Edwin Encarnación
Todd Zeile

If the Mets don’t have a real 1st baseman, need to develop the kids to have a decent future and the kids can play 3rd or 2nd it seems to me Bichette at 1st would be appropriate .

Obviously, no one shares my opinion, which is fine. I understand your arguments but I’d rather have a 3rd baseman who’s potentially a foundational piece than a mercenary placeholder who will be gone within a year or two at most and blocks a kid from development especially since we don’t have a real 1st baseman

Mack Ade said...

Sound arguement

I still would leave him on third, and trade two of the three unknown entities of Pitre, Rojas, Amick, and Voit for an established first baseman

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

All fair points. I'll make a couple of potential counter points, but first, I agree that we should want a longer term solution at 3B and at 1B. And I am of the view that we don't have an obvious solution at 1B on the farm, though perhaps one may emerge in due course. Two counterpoints. Bichette is comfortable at 3B now, I never like making position changes that potentially make a team worse at 2 positions defensively. I am not in love with the Sato talk. It's not top priority right now. And while I am not in love with Bichette long term, if only because he is likely to cost too much especially when compared to the number of potential replacements already on the farm, some of whom will be available earlier than others, and the cost savings that would allow, we can't just eliminate him as a possible candidate for the position relatively long term.
To be honest, the contract with Bichette was poorly structured and so the Mets are kind of saddled in the sense that he has all the leverage. Hard to do strategic planning under those conditions. So you need to control what you can control,, which right now is the Mets ability to approach 1B as they see fit and determine its priority overall and whether they will look for a 2 or 3 year solution or a long term one.

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

I completely agree about Bauers. He is roughly 'Young' on a much better team.
Note the great thing about the Brewers other than the points RVH has made so well in his series, is that they don't have stars everywhere on the field, but they do have lots of speed, high baseline bat to ball skills, and defensive skills, and real leadership. They also have something I have mentioned in some of my earliest posts: they focus on amassing competitive advantages that they are great at turning into strategic advantages.

TexasGusCC said...

The Mets signed their first free agent today and it filled a hole in both the lineup and the defense. Bichette graded fine defensively as he got better with more reps. Plus, he is a solid reliable run producer. Forget Sato. As for first base, the Mets either need a Devers there or quite possibly let Baty, Alvarez and Young rotate there. I don’t want one year wonders like Ty France, nor do I want has beens like Goldschmidt or Christian Walker. Colby Mayo would get my attention.

Tom Brennan said...

Bichette hit great over the last 4 months.

The first two awful months were him dealing with being in the spotlight hugely, out of sync in the period of time balls don’t Citi-carry, and also dealing with Soto and Lindor injuries, stripping the line up of surrounding offense. Not to mention the bad April of Benge.

Focus on his last 4 months. He should hit .300 in 2027. If the main hitters stay healthy, this is an above-average offensive team in 2027.

RVH said...

I think this is a good thing for the Mets. Bichette made a fast decision (even read somewhere last night he may ultimately commit to year three.

The money is the money - literally the equivalent of approx $2,000 spend for someone who has $500k net worth to SC.

He is Bo Bichette. He will very likely be a very solid player filling a gaping hole in the lineup & field. He connected with Ewing & Benge. Fans should be happy…

If Rojas is really ready, play him at 2B for now. Move him later if 3B opens up.

Agree that the Mets need a legit 1B at least to compliment Young.

The Mets need another strong RH bat. Ideally it’s an athletic OF that can play all three positions with athleticism & some pop. There are multiple options (Cincy has a couple), someone who can play OF, provide insurance if Ewing takes some time to truly lock in, spell Soto & maybe even play some 1B.

They can live with a patch at 1B but the big question is do they decide to bank on Polanco returning to DH or do they get an external power RH DH bat.

Current holes: 1B, 2B, DH, SP1, SP 3, Closer, leverage RP, RH OF with some pop.

Some will come from farm, some from trade, some from FA.

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

Tom-- I don't think this is an above average offensive team because it is unbalanced and has too many black holes. There is no credible DH; no power right hand bat, 2b is a black hole; bench players can't hit or play defense as of now. Too many easy innings for opposing pitchers. I'll feel better about the offense when they can be a team that consistently puts pressure on the opposition; that's the stuff that leads to heavy use of opposing pitching staff and errors and mental mistakes.
I think Ewing has to emerge as the leadoff hitter. Soto likes hitting second and because he takes pitches and is selective, it gives Ewing a chance to steal.
Lindor is my choice at 3 because he is a switch hitter and can run. Bichette is 4; Benge is 5.. DH should be 6 or if the Mets follow my suggestion about splitting DH among Soto Bichette and Lindor, 6,7,8 should be shifting order of either Young or RH platooner, (worse case scenario Polanco if DH) , replacement LF if Soto is DH) or infield replacement if Lindor or Bichette is DHing), replacement for Semien (either Voit or Rojas) and 9 is catcher.
The one issue that would remain in this starting lineup is where does the power come from. It is the reason I would like to see the platooning 1B with Young be a RH power bat if possible.
There won't be speed at catching back up, but the rest of the bench should be speed and defensive versatility with some attention given to bat to ball skills.

Mack Ade said...

it's heading in the right direction

solid outfield

three great to good controlled rotation pieces

red meat left side of the infield

handful of interesting high level prospects

progress

Zozo said...

I would consider moving Bichette to second base if Rojas is better there defensively than him, but if not put Rojas at second base on opening day.
Then I would have Voit get some reps in leftfield until Bichette decides to leave.

Zozo said...

Also would call the Yankees and Offer Polanco for Stanton. I believe it’s the same amount of money and would rather have him at DH for 80-90 games

Rds 900. said...

Am I the only one who believes Baty is our future first baseman?

Mack Ade said...

Yes

Yes you are

Baty is the future nothing

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

I don't think that Baty will amount to nothing, but I don't believe he is our future first baseman either. I certainly hope not

Paul Articulates said...

Pleased to hear your argument aptoklas. Your opinion is very welcome here. We love a great baseball debate.

Paul Articulates said...

Rojas can play all three non-1B infield positions. I would not move Bichette after the Mets made the investment in time to get him trained and comfortable there.

Paul Articulates said...

Baty has played 1B capably a few times for the Mets. He is a corner infielder by nature, so he can handle the hot shots off the bat. He is a power left-handed hitter. All good qualifications. But what we are looking for is an outstanding first baseman - a differentiator. Baty needs to take a giant step up on both sides of the ball to become that. He is still on the roster, so he still has an opportunity to compete.

Jules C-- The Cautious Optimist said...

I do believe that of the four semi baby Mets -- Baty, Mauricio, Vientos and Alvarez -- I believe that Baty has the chance to have the longest major league career. He'll be on the roster come Spring Training (or its equivalent) due to his versatility. But he would serve his interests best if he could step up more defensively at one position and display more power.

Mark said...

France: another 3 year deal? Just found out today that we have 1 more underway than we might have had. Clearly to me there is a let-down when a player moves to a new team with a multi-year king's ransom to count on as retirement.

Mark said...

I think Baty has been around now 5 years. I think his average is around .235 over that time. I say a prayer every time he circles under a fly ball.

Mark said...

Paul - Baty MLaverage s +/- 1 HR per 30 ABs.. Jared Young +/- 1 HR per 27. Not so say Young a power LH hitter - simply that Baty is not.