ANGRY MIKE
12/4/25
ANGRY MIKE: 2025 METS PROSPECT REPORT: A.J. EWING
MACK - POSITION ANALYSIS - OF (Holy, moly)
Position Analysis –OF
Sit back… this is going to be a long one…
Nick Morabito, Carson Benge, AJ Ewing – the first three names here are all RED prospects,
all starting off in AAA, and all don’t need me to repeat here what has been said
about them a septillion times before. They are all destined to hit Queens this
season (unless one is packaged for a starter) and MetsWorld will start to spin
correctly again.
Ji-Hwan
Bae – recent sign-on after the Pirates waived him. Looks like the perfect
candidate for late D (ultra-speed here) and pinch running. Excellent AAA stat
line last season, so he looks to be a much better alternative with a bat in his
hands than that Siri experiment. I’m starting him out in AAA, letting my Queens
five-dom be Soto/TBD/Taylor/Young/McNeil.
Matt
Rudick – turns 28 in July. LHH. Plays all three OF positions. Spent all of 2024
at AA(8-HR, 41-RBI, .231) , then hurt all of last season (TJS), except for late
rehabbing in A+. I have him backing up Tne Three Amigos at AAA and then
starting there when the first is either promoted or traded.
Eli
Serrano – turns 23 in May. LHH. Plays center, right, and 1B. Had 383-PA for A+
last season (.222) and will graduate in the spring to AA, if for no other
reason than they have slots to fill there.
John Bay – “lightning In A Bottle” here will turn 25 in May. RHH. Plays center and right. Undrafted out of
Bumfuk, Egypt. Proved the baseball world wrong at A/A+ going 108-PA, 33-K,
16-BB, 4-HR, 23-RBI, .253/.417/,458/.874. Even got hit eight times. I have starting
off again at the A+ level, but he should quickly more to AA if early spring
proves that last season wasn’t a fluke.
Yohairo Cuevas – 23/years old. Plays RF, LF, 1B. Played for St.
Lucie and Brooklyn last season: 378-PA, 81-K, 60-SB,
2-HR, 23-RB1, .252/.392/.726-OPS. Only 121-PA at the A+ level, so he will
return there this spring. 6-3 with projectable power. Strong arm. Hustles on
every play. I like this guy. Especially his blazing speed on the basepaths. Could
be breakout star in 2026. Remember this name.
Diego
Mosquera – turns 22 in March. Plays LF, SS, 2B. RHH.
Was a Clone for the entire 2025 season: 223-PA, 47-K,
24-BB, 0-HR, 16-RBI, .217/.253-SLG. Two things here… the good news is you have
to go to a lot of games to see him strikeout… the bad news is you have to a go
to a whole lot more to see him get an XBH. He probably will move on to AA as a
utility player.
Yostan
Henriquez – 21/years old. Plays CF, RF, 3B. SH.
Hit for (mostly) St. Lucie and Brooklyn in 2025: 437-PA, 80-K, 55-BB, 8-HR, 52-BB, .263/.353/.393/.746. A versatile defender. Sneaky
pop from both sides. Another kid you are going to hear more about, especially
in the age that hitting above .250 makes you a potential superstar. I have him
starting off back at the A+ level. Remember this name too.
Randy Guzman – okay… here’s a live one. Turns 21 in April. Plays
RF, LF, 1B (!). RHH. Arrived from the DR at
the end of 2024 and played last season for the FCL Mets and St. Lucie. Did well
at FCL (178-PA, 7-HR, .282), but really hit the peddle at Lucy (105-PA, 21-K, 6-BB,
.3-HR, 24-RBI, .333/.381/.604/.985-OPS. That
added up to 10-HR, 57-RBI, .302, .898-OPS. Breakout 2025 season. Elite raw
power. 90th percentile exit velo (108.1).Plays solid corner and
first. Most improved hitter in the chain. 20-25 HR potential. I’m sending him
to Brooklyn, where I would play him a little more on first.
Simon
Juan – $1.9mil signing bonus on 1-15-2022. Downhill from there. Turns 21 in July.
Plays all three outfield positions. RHH. Made
half a splash for the FCL Mets in 2024: 202-PA, 7-HR, 29-RBI, .273… then fell
back into the pact last season for St. Lucie: 376-PA, 7-HR, 50-RBI, .222. My
thoughts are the potential felt when they shelled out the bonus keeps Juan
around. So, off he goes to Brooklyn in 2026 for, probably, his last shot.
Sam Biller – turns 24 in July. Plays all three OF positions
5-10 180 LHH
2025 free agent out of Univ. Connecticut (13-HR, 60-RB1, .978-OPS)
2025: A-St. Lucie – 21-PA, 9-K, 3-BB, 0-HR,
1-RB1, .235
Biller
was a standout outfielder for the UConn Huskies and had an absolute monster
2025 college season! The graduate transfer crushed .296 with 14 doubles, 13
homers, 60 RBI, 23 stolen bases, and led his team with 19 hit-by-pitches across
58 games. He earned Perfect Game National Player of the Week honors after a
ridiculous stretch: going 12-for-19 with 4 doubles, 5 homers, and 17 RBI in
just a few games. Biller also snagged the NCBWA Dick Howser Trophy National
Hitter of the Week after a 4-for-5 game with three dingers and six RBI against
Villanova, part of an 11-game hit streak where he racked up 29 RBI and eight
homers. On top of the stats, he's a class act—earlier this year, he spearheaded
a fundraiser with college baseball players nationwide to rebuild a Little
League field in California destroyed by wildfires, raising money for equipment
and relief through partnerships with Rawlings and Easton. And get this: in his
pro debut season, he already set a career-high with four stolen bases in one
game! Kid's got power, speed, heart, and
he's just getting started. I have him opening up again at the A level.
Yunior Amparo – (may have a live one here…).
19/years
old. RHH.
Plays CF, 1B, 3B
6-0 170
Santo Domingo, DR
2025: 2-DSL teams – 173-PA, 24-K, 26-BB, 4-HR, .312/.426/.903-OPS
Showing
excellent plate discipline, speed (above-average runner), and a quick,
adaptable bat with fast hands that projects for double-digit homers down the
line. One of the standout performers at the DSL All-Star Game, noting his
malleable swing, line-drive approach with loft, and strong arm, though he may
shift off shortstop eventually. Has scouts buzzing about his offensive gifts
profiling anywhere on the diamond. Poised for a stateside jump to the Florida
Complex League in 2026.
6-1 175
RHH 18/years
old
IFA
signed 1-15-2024: $950K signing bonus. Drew comparisons to stars like Julio
RodrÃguez for his athleticism, size (now listed at 6'4", 195 lbs), speed,
and projectable power.
2025
– FCL Mets: 194-PA, 29-K, 33-BB, 3-HR, 27-RBI, .288/.433
Professionally
last season for DSL Mets/Mets, he absolutely raked. Named DSL Player of the
Year. Strong plate discipline An FCL
All-Star. Scouts love his above-average
arm, speed that should stick in center field (or right if needed), and high
ceiling as he adds muscle—Baseball America gives him 50+ grades across hit,
power, run, field, and arm. Even though St. Lucie is crowded, I still can’t see
holding back this potential RED prospect.
Jeffry
Rosa – 21/years old RF/LF/CF RHH 6-1
190
IFA
signed 1-15-2022 $100,000 signing bonus
2025: FCL Mets
- 147-PA, 43-K, 10-BB, 4-HR,
10-RB1, .180
Turned
heads in 2023 when he hit 15 home runs for the Mets DSL orange team. Turned
heads away ever since. Has hit 8 homers combined for two seasons since. 1.069-OPS
to .607. Frankly, he’s St, Lucie filler at best.
Haniel
German – 19/yrs 6-2 185 RHH RF/LF/CF
IFA
– signed for under $10.1K
2025: FCL Mets – 145-PA, 51-K 16-BB, 0-HR, 11-RBI, .192
Another
Rosa. Me? I repeat him.
Heriberto Rincon – turns 20 in February
6-1 160
RHH
CF/RF/LF IFA signing bonus $150K
2025
– Mets DSL-O: 206-PA, 30-K, 19-BB, 34-SB,
.314/.363/.438/.821
Frankly, you couldn’t ask for a more
well-rounded season from Herby. The only downside I see here is he’s too old to
be playing down there. Elite speed. 70-grade run tool. Tied DSL lead in steals
in 2025. 30+ SB and 15+ XBH. FanGraphs
calls him one of the toolsiest position players in the Mets' DSL groups. Scouts note gap
power, hard contact (e.g., 101-110 mph exit velos on highlights), and clutch
hits like game-winning doubles or triples. Primarily a centerfielder with range
and arm strength; projects as a plus defender. Coming stateside to an FCL team
near you.
Adolfo Miranda – 19 years old
RHH 6-2
190 RF/LF/CF IFA signed – bonus in $10-300K range).
2025: DSL-Mets-O – 187-PA, 32-K,
10-BB, 5-HR, .290/.353/.473/.826
Toosly with room to add strength. Scouts
highlight his plus raw power potential (especially to the pull side) and
above-average speed, making him a classic "high-ceiling" corner or
center field prospect who could develop into a 20+ homer guy with good defense.
Another James Kang/IFA Director find. He will definitely come stateside (if he’s
not already here in the lab) and will open for the FCL Mets net season.
Overall – Boy, the outfield looks good right now. You have solid upper-level talent, mixed in with six mid-lower BLUE prospects. Easily can survive a trade or two.Now all they to do is find someone to play left until June.
Rating:
A+
Paul Articulates – Marcus Semien, the newest Met
The trade last week of Brandon Nimmo plus $5M for Marcus Semien surprised many of us throughout the Mets’ nation. It has taken a while to absorb what it all means as the Mets sent one of their long-standing fan favorites and a major contributor to the American league for a gold glove second baseman.
As soon as it happened, I put a piece together “Bran-done?!” to recognize Brandon Nimmo and his accomplishments as a Met. I think a lot of people felt that way – sentimental about a guy that did so much for the team over the years. But in the business of baseball, sentiment takes a back seat. Let’s look objectively at who Marcus Semien is and what it does for the New York Mets.
Marcus Semien has had a very successful career, coming up with the Chicago White Sox in 2013 just two years after being selected in the sixth round of the 2011 draft (what a steal!). He is a defense first player, having played all infield positions except 1B and winning two gold gloves (one in 2021 with Toronto and one last year with Texas). Both his Outs Above Average and Defensive Runs Saved metrics for a typical year would place him among the top Mets. He has been on three all-star teams (2021, 2023, and 2024) and has also won two Silver Slugger awards (2021, 2023).
Besides the professional accolades, Marcus Semien has also excelled as a person – three times representing the Rangers for the MLB Heart and Hustle Award, with one of those years (2023) being the MLB Players Association winner. He was also MLB players choice man of the year in 2021 and 2023.
Semien adds a right-handed bat to a Mets lineup that has been dominated by lefties the last few years. This adds balance and his infield versatility gives Carlos Mendoza options on how to arrange the lineup against a particular pitching challenge. Statistically, he has a solid but not spectacular career OPS of .756 and a 49.2 career WAR. His career slash line is .253/.321/.435 but he was down from those numbers in the last two seasons with Texas. Last year he only played 127 games due to a left foot fracture. He has not had much of an injury history, so hopefully he will remain healthy for the Mets.
Semien will be a great add to the Mets clubhouse. Besides the humanitarian awards mentioned above, former teammates describe him as having an elite work ethic and someone who demonstrates field leadership through example. This fits very well with Francisco Lindor’s style so there is an opportunity for them to become a very dynamic combination in the middle infield.
The data shows that this trade should be a positive for the Mets. They gain defensive capability that is consistent with their run prevention goal, they get more lineup balance with a solid right-handed bat, and they get clubhouse/field leadership by example from a player who wants to win.
The risk in this acquisition is that Semien has already peaked for his career and is on the downslope. Last year he batted only .230, and while that may be dismissed due to the foot injury, his 2024 season was not much better with a .237/.308/.478 line. He will be 35 years old this season, so his physical durability is something to watch.
I am looking forward to seeing an improved infield in 2026, with the dynamic combination up the middle and an improved Brett Baty focused on his third base play. The first base position will be unresolved for at least a month but if the floor is Pete’s defense, I’ll take it.
12/3/25
RVH — The Organizational Superstar Blueprint:
How Generational Players Transform Entire Baseball Franchises**
Baseball organizations don’t just build rosters — they build identities. Front offices talk constantly about culture, development, and sustainability, but they rarely articulate the deeper truth:
Successful modern front offices are beginning to leverage prototype players as core inputs into their player-development systems.
When you think of players as organizational assets, this emerging philosophy aligns perfectly with the Steve Cohen / David Stearns blueprint — a model inspired by hedge-fund logic, where capital is deployed efficiently to generate compounding long-term returns.
These players are not just stars.
Not just producers.
They are Prototypes — singular offensive or defensive engines that define what an organization values, teaches, invests in, and replicates across every layer of the system.
A prototype becomes the reference model for how you:
-
scout
-
draft
-
coach
-
structure analytics
-
design your farm system
-
build offensive and defensive approaches
-
develop decision-making
-
define your competitive identity
Every elite organization has one.
And they shape everything downstream.
The Dodgers built theirs around Ohtani (and Betts/Freeman before him).
The Yankees built theirs around Judge.
The Royals around Bobby Witt Jr.
The Braves around Acuña.
The Padres around Tatis Jr.
The Jays around Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
And the Mets — finally — have theirs: Juan Soto.
Soto has been a Met for a full season. The team failed to win — but that failure actually highlights a critical truth modern baseball is only now beginning to understand:
Superstars are not paid astronomical contracts solely for performance or marketing value.
They are paid because one generational player can materially accelerate the quality and quantity of an entire organization’s player-development output.
A prototype produces WAR.
But the hidden ROI is that they create organizational leverage.
This is the core of the Cohen/Stearns philosophy:
Spend big on the right established talent, build the internal systems to multiply that investment, and compound value across the entire roster over time.
Prototype Players Are Not Just Great — They Are Inputs into Advanced Development Systems
A prototype hitter is more than their stat line.
They are a complete offensive development philosophy wrapped inside one athlete — a live blueprint of:
-
biomechanics
-
sequencing
-
pitch recognition
-
timing models
-
plate-discipline architecture
-
contact-quality patterns
-
risk tolerance
-
zone control
-
and the stabilizing halo they create around everyone else
Once you understand the prototype, you understand the organizational identity that should form around them.
This is why the Mets’ new alignment matters so much.
For the first time in decades, ownership, baseball operations, analytics, scouting, and development are unified around a single objective:
Build a sustainable winning machine by increasing the quality of player assets through a modern, data-driven, capital-efficient development ecosystem.
Cohen provides the capital.
Stearns provides the architecture.
Soto provides the prototype.
Together, they form the foundation of a system capable of compounding value over time.
The Hidden Value: How Prototypes Transfer Their Operating System to an Entire Organization
A franchise investing in a generational prototype isn’t just paying for WAR or marketability.
That’s the surface-level ROI.
The real value — the one that actually justifies these contracts — is that the organization gains access to the player’s operating system.
A prototype doesn’t just hit.
They reveal:
-
how they see pitches
-
how they sequence
-
how they train
-
how they build timing
-
how they self-correct mid-season
-
how they prepare mentally
-
how they manage count leverage
-
how they simplify the game under pressure
When player development, coaches, analysts, and young hitters learn these internal processes, the superstar becomes an organizational input, not just an output.
This is where exponential leverage appears.
If even 15–20% of a superstar’s operating system can be embedded into the farm, everything accelerates:
-
Prospects refine faster
-
Swing decisions improve
-
Mechanics become more efficient
-
Depth improves
-
Variance decreases
-
Analytics integrates cleanly with coaching
-
More players reach their ceiling
-
Salary capital gains efficiency across the roster
This is classic hedge-fund logic applied to baseball:
turn one high-value asset into a multiplier across the entire portfolio.
That’s how you sustain winning without needing to spend $300M in free agency every winter.
This is the Cohen/Stearns model — and Soto is the perfect player to anchor it.
The Mets’ Prototype: Juan Soto
Juan Soto isn’t just the Mets’ best hitter.
He is their organizational blueprint.
What Soto represents:
-
the cleanest decision engine in MLB
-
elite OBP and contact-quality stability
-
minimal unnecessary movement
-
maximum repeatability
-
a low-variance offensive floor
-
a swing and approach that age exceptionally well
Even in a season when the Mets failed to win, his value extends far beyond the standings.
Soto is a living model for how to build hitters.
Teams aligned around Soto tend to adopt:
-
selective aggression
-
shadow-zone mastery
-
OBP supremacy
-
controlled, repeatable mechanics
-
long-AB pressure
-
complementary hitters who punish the mistakes Soto refuses to chase
-
development systems centered on clarity, timing, and decision quality
Soto doesn’t just hit.
He teaches you how to create hitters, how to develop assets, and how to build a system that compounds value over time.
This is the opportunity in front of the Mets — and why, for the first time in decades, the franchise is aligned to build a sustainable winning machine.
MACK - MY WEDNESDAY OBSERVATIONS - MACK'S PROSPECT #5 - RHSP WILL WATSON - Dove Camp Notes, Robert Suarez, Joe Ryan, Juan Soto, A.J. Ewing, Jose Castillo, Sean Manaea
I promised
all of you that, as soon as the season ended, I would breakout and post my
current Top 30 prospects.
This is
performance based, not players that came to the Mets full of promise but have
only produced butterscotch pudding. A perfect example of a player that didn’t
make this list is catcher Ronald Hernandez.
I still like the guy, but based on what he did in 2025, I don’t like him “top
30 guy”.
Nolan
McLean, Brandon Sproat, and Jonah
Tong (maybe) are not on this list. They have
graduated.
I will post them in each of my weekly Observations and In Focus posts… one player at a time… beginning with #30.
Today, we
move to #5:
5. RHSP Will Watson
23/years
old 6-1 180
7th rd. 2024 – USC
2025 – A/A+/AA: 28-G, 23-ST, 3-9, 2.60,
1.20, 121.1-IP, 142-K, 58-BB
Will Watson
is widely regarded as one of their breakout prospects in 2025.
He signed for
$281,300, just under slot value.
Prior to USC,
Watson attended California Lutheran University and San Joaquin Delta College,
where he was drafted in the 20th round by the Seattle Mariners in 2023 but
opted to return to school.
Watson's
journey to pro ball included a solid college season at USC in 2024, where he
appeared in 16 games (9 starts), posting a 3.93 ERA over 50.1 innings with 46
strikeouts, 27 walks, and a 1.411 WHIP.
Watson
profiles primarily as a pitcher with starter potential but could transition to
relief if command issues persist. He's praised for his competitiveness,
athleticism, and ability to miss bats,
2025
Performance and Rise
Watson's
first full professional season in 2025 has been a revelation, earning him spots
on Mets top-prospect lists. He began at Single-A St. Lucie, where he dominated
with a sub-3.00 ERA and high strikeout totals, including a career-high 7 Ks in
4.1 hitless innings in his debut on April 9.
Promoted to
High-A Brooklyn in June, he continued excelling (e.g., 8 Ks in 4.2 scoreless
innings on June 13), then reached Double-A Binghamton by late summer.
Scouts call
him a "wildcard" arm with quick-rising potential, though his fringe-average control (walks
remain a hurdle) could cap him as a mid-rotation starter or high-leverage
reliever.
ETA to MLB:
2027, but aggressive promotions suggest 2026 is possible.
Pitch
Repertoire
Watson's
arsenal is deep and versatile, featuring a five-pitch mix that plays well against both lefties and righties. He's
experienced a velocity spike in pro ball (up 2-3 mph across the board),
crediting Mets development for better extension and spin. He throws from a
low-three-quarters slot with a leg kick and long arm action, adding deception.
His fastball-centric approach keeps hitters off-balance, and he's noted that
opponents "haven't been comfortable" facing it.
Four-Seam Fastball
94-97 mph
(avg. 95)
Rise/run
profile with elite spin (up to 2,300 RPM);
explosive life up in the zone for whiffs. Primary pitch (50-60% usage).
Plus
grade; generates
swing-and-miss (often his best offering). Peaks at 97 mph.
Slider
84-87 mph
(mid-80s avg.)
Sharp, late
break with two-plane movement; pairs well with fastball for righties.
Above-average; key for stealing strikes and Ks
(recently "working really well"). 20-25% usage.
Cutter
88-91 mph
(upper-80s avg.)
New addition
in 2025; hard, late cut to tunnel with fastball/slider.
Fringe-average
but improving; used as bridge pitch (10-15% usage). "Still finding the
right spots," per Watson.
Changeup
87-90 mph
(upper-80s avg.)
Tailing
action with arm-side fade; firm but flashes plus potential vs. lefties.
Above-average; complements fastball for reverse
splits. 10-15% usage.
Curveball
78-82 mph
Deeper, 12-6
break as change-of-pace; less used but adds depth.
Average;
situational for early counts or stealing strikes. <10% usage.
Strengths: High-spin fastball and slider combo
drives his 25-30% K-rate; athletic delivery aids repeatability. Areas for
growth: Command (4+ BB/9) to unlock full potential—refining this could elevate
all pitches to plus. Watson's meteoric 2025 rise—from seventh-rounder to
Double-A playoff starter—marks him as a Mets system bonus. With the
organization's pitching lab, he could emerge as a dark-horse rotation piece by
2027.
Mack Ade macksmets@gmail.com
Highlights from last Ernest Dove podcast:
1. 100% healthy Zach Thornton
2. Also in pitching camp, R.J. Gordon, Jack Wenninger, Ryan Lambert, and
Brandon
Girton
3. Small, under 20 pitchers select camp.
4. Position players concentrated on
strengthening. Positive updates on Boston Baro, Eli Serrano III, Carson Benge, Jacob Reimer, AJ Ewing, and Collin Houck.
5. Camp now in the "dead period ".
6. Re: players that left the AFL early... Brett Banks is
100%, and DeAndre
Smith, is also 100% healthy
7. Austin Treosser may be injured. No details.
High-leverage
relievers still on the board after Ryan Helsley signing
Robert Suarez, who quietly put together is one
of the most efficient seasons in the league for the Padres. The 34-year-old
right-hander logged 40 saves with a 2.97 ERA and a 0.90 WHIP, giving him the
kind of recent track record teams crave in the ninth inning.
Joe Ryan
https://fansided.com/mlb/mlb/ranking-joe-ryan-trade-destinations-from-favorites-to-dark-horses
New York Mets
The New York Mets unearthed an ace in Nolan McLean,
but the rest of the rotation is in shambles. Jonah Tong and Brandon Sproat aren't
ready. Kodai
Senga is too unreliable. Sean Manaea took a huge step back in 2025. Ryan provides
instant stability and production at New York's weakest position. The Mets'
offense can mash as well as any group in MLB, but unless New York can keep
opposing lineups in check, the wins won't come frequently enough in 2026.
Eric Cross @EricCrossMLB
Only two players in MLB history met all of
the below thresholds through their Age 26 season...
200+ Home Runs
650+ RBI
750+ Runs Scored
75+ Stolen Bases
.400+ OBP
Juan Soto and Mickey Mantle.
Ben Yoel @Ben_Yoel
A.J. Ewing
Mets biggest prospect rise in 2025. He could
be the CF of the future.
He stole 70 bases this year.
Mack – MM
LHRP Jose Castillo, who was non-tendered by the Mets in November,
has signed with Japan's NPB with the Chiba Lotte Marines. Castillo pitched for
four teams in 2025… the Mets, Mariners, Diamondbacks, and Orioles.
32-IP
3.94-ERA
Ugly Baseball Contracts
Sean Manaea, New York Mets: Manaea took a huge step
backward with his 5.64 ERA last season after dealing with a stubborn oblique
injury. He’s due $50 million over the final two years of his contract, though
more than $14 million of that is deferred. It’s still a high AAV for a pitcher
who is soon to be 34 and has only once posted a 3-fWAR season.
Reese Kaplan -- Who's Really the 2026 Closer for the Mets?
With the Winter Meetings slated to begin next week there has already been a bit of personnel activity around the league. The latest one found the Baltimore Orioles inking Mets disaster Ryan Helsley to a two-year $28 million deal. Apparently the folks hoping to continue contending are expecting that Helsley’s track record prior to the Mets and his late September strong finish after the horrific tenure with the Mets was a hiccup in an otherwise commendable and dominant career.
With the big righthander off the board it now makes the price tags on the next tier of relievers escalate as fewer All Star level closers are now available to the highest bidder. Heading the list, of course, is Edwin Diaz who is looking for a five year deal in the neighborhood of $22 million per season which would amount to a $110 million contract for a guy during his age 32 through 37 career years. Obviously the Mets would like to have him return but at that rate it might be necessary to embrace an alternative as a complementary piece or Closer Plan B.
Some were caught by surprise when word came out on Monday that the club indeed executed a reunion between David Stearns and his former Brewers closer Devin Williams. After his rugged 2025 season in the Bronx most people have written him off already without considering what he did prior to his departure to Yankee Stadium. As a refresher, during his career which started in 2019 he was absolutely unhittable. For the period of 2019 through 2024 he went 27-10 with 68 saves that included 375 strikeouts in 235 innings pitched. His ERA was a sparkling 1.83. You’re talking Diaz level dominance. Last year he escalated to 4-6 with a 4.79 ERA. The only positive was his 90 Ks in 62 IP.
How this new contract impacts the Mets is still the great unknown. On the one hand you have a lethal level closer from Milwaukee who regularly made All Star teams while playing there. His first foray into New York media coverage and pressure went about as well as Ryan Helsley's tenure across town. However, the price paid ($15 million per season for three years) is in this day and age fairly modest for someone with a career ERA of 2.45 AFTER his horrific Yankees turn in 2025.
The politically correct aspect of this conjecture is that Williams has stated he is content to be the 8th inning guy and turn the ball over to Edwin Diaz for the 9th if by some increasingly unlikely happenstance that Sugar will make his way into the home team lockers at Citifield once again. If that indeed happened then you can certainly tip your cap to David Stearns about run prevention if you're willing to write off the past year as a blip rather than a trend. The trend was awesome before that.
However, in what baseball business ledger does it suggest you pay approximately $22 million for Diaz, $15 million for Williams, $11 million for A.J. Minter, approximately $8 million for Brooks Raley and more money for the balance of the pen? That means you're allocating about $60 million for relief pitching without considering how you're going to address the other obvious needs in the starting rotation, outfield, first base and the bench (if indeed you cast Baty as a starting caliber third baseman).
Only Yankees fans would deride the decision to secure Williams for the pen. If he's slated to become the primary closer with the Diaz $22 million annual salary used elsewhere, that's livable although some would say a step down. Truth be told during the Diaz Mets reign he's managed a highly respectable 2.93 ERA but it reminds you that there were some years he was not quite the automatic save he was in other years (and is nearly a half a run worse than Williams). Personally, I could live with Williams as the closer if the gap to reacquire Diaz become insurmountable.

















