Having spent way too much time watching Youtube videos of the Mets moments in history during the year end holiday it got me to thinking about the team that came within two games of the World Series in 2024 and how it compares to the one thus far constructed to compete in 2025. Let’s have a look.
Catchers
- Francisco Alvarez
- Luis Torrens
Infielders
- Pete Alonso
- Jeff McNeil
- Jose Iglesias
- Francisco Lindor
- Luisangel Acuna
- Mark Vientos
Outfielders
- Brandon Nimmo
- Harrison Bader
- Starling Marte
- Tyrone Taylor
- Jesse Winker
Designated Hitter
- J.D. Martinez
Starting Pitchers
- Kodai Senga (injured for virtually the entire season)
- Sean Manaea
- Luis Severino
- Jose Quintana
- David Peterson
Relief Pitchers
- Edwin Diaz
- Ryne Stanek
- Phil Maton
- Jose Butto
- Reed Garrett
- Tylor Megill
- Danny Young
- Adam Ottavino (left off playoff roster)
Now let’s take a look at the 2025 squad everyone is thus far banking on to make up those two games they fell short in 2024:
Catchers
- Francisco Alvarez
- Luis Torrens
Infielders
- Francisco Lindor
- Mark Vientos
- Jeff McNeil
- Luisangel Acuna
Outfielders
- Juan Soto
- Brandon Nimmo
- Tyrone Taylor
- Jose Siri (injured)
Designated Hitter
- Starling Marte
Starting Pitchers
- Kodai Senga
- Sean Manaea
- David Peterson
- Frankie Montas
- Clay Holmes
- Edwin Diaz
- Jose Butto
- Tylor Megill
- Dedniel Nunez
- Reed Garrett
- Sean Reid-Foley (injured)
- Dylan Covey
- Griffin Canning
Ummm...other than the addition of Juan Soto which is, of course, a huge one, there seems to be an awful lot missing with Spring Training starting next month. The glaring vacancies are in the infield, the outfield, DH and the bullpen. We’ll address comments about each of them in a bit, but first let’s look at the starting rotation.
Now, going into 2024 no one knew what to make of David Stearns’ reclamation project heavy rotation with Manaea not showing brilliance and Luis Severino not showing health nor competence. Holdover Jose Quintana was a known commodity to give you better numbers than Severino, Kodai Senga was injured and out of all by a handful of innings for the entire year and David Peterson was an unknown coming back from surgery on his hip.
Much to everyone’s surprise, these less-than-spectacular moves worked. Yes, there were innings given to the likes of Adrian Houser and others no longer in the picture, but somehow Carlos Mendoza and Jeremy Hefner got more out of this ragtag bunch than could have been expected.
The problem is that in this offseason Stearns has pretty much gone the same route, first by offering up Frankie Montas as the new Luis Severino. Well, on a career basis, he has had injuries and never posted the eye popping numbers the team needs. Even more surprising is how much he is being paid in the hopes that the on-the-field staff and the pitching lab can help push hm into a more competitive direction.
David Peterson was clearly the best pitcher in the rotation in 2024, finishing with an ERA of just 2.90. The problem is people think this level of performance was not a fluke but instead a new standard to expect in the coming 2025 season. Everyone hopes it could be yet at the same time it may not be realistic to write it in stone.
Rumblings exist that the Mets might try to sell high on Peterson and transfer the risk to another team as a part of a trade to help them in other places. Surely you would get a whole lot more for Peterson than you would for Megill.
The wildcard in the mix for 2025 is not as much Kodai Senga’s return to dominance which is more probable if he is indeed fully healthy and playing regularly, nor is it Sean Manaea’s rebirth in the second half of the year. He got his money and now must show it was not merely an extended hot streak.
No, the one area that no one can rightly predict is the conversion of star reliever Clay Holmes from the bullpen where he was rock solid for the Yankees to the starting rotation now that he’s hit his mid career stride.
The Mets failed to make this effort on Seth Lugo so they are hoping that Holmes’ more dominant stuff can push him into an even higher performance level than the man who got away.
Going into the bullpen is a bit unsettling as the names there are, well, unsettled. Both Nunez and Reid-Foley are recovering from injuries. We know what Diaz, Butto and Garrett can do. We’re not quite so sure about Covey, Canning and Megill if they are all slated to spend time supporting the starters.
Now the outfield is frankly a mess. Soto is a star, no question about that, but Nimmo is coming off his worst MLB season in terms of batting average. Tyrone Taylor and Jose Siri are 4th outfielders at best.
It would seem that the possibility exists for Jeff McNeil or Starling Marte to take the field in left with Nimmo going back to center. That’s not exactly an awe inspiring group of guys behind the infield.
On that note, let me remind you that the 2025 squad is missing a guy named Pete Alonso and another guy named Jose Iglesias. Granted, the Mets have some infielders in the system. I’ve already penciled in Acuna for a spot to replace Iglesias. Then there are the futures of slumping Brett Baty and lost-in-2024 Ronny Mauricio.
Finally we come to DH. Everyone was happy to see Steve Cohen spend for professional hitter J.D. Martinez who delivered a “meh” kind of season, often relegated to platoon with Jesse Winker taking the other half. Neither of those guys are here anymore and somehow few would expect Starling Marte in his final contract year to post numbers even equal to the ho-hum total the team got from the DH slot in 2024.
Any way you slice it, the club has a lot of holes to fill and while there is still about 6 weeks before pitchers and catchers report, the fact is that there are 29 other teams also looking to shore up their rosters as well. That means the available free agent pool is getting rather empty in many places and trades may need to be engaged to improve the team from where it was with its roster as last season ended. Right now even with Soto it appears weaker.