6/7/13

Day One Final Results of the MLB Rule 4 Player Draft.

Also at Mack's Mets:


Tonight is the Big Night Folks!!! Christopher Soto and Mack Ade here bringing you live coverage to tonight to start. 


First Round

  • 1. Houston Astros- RHP Mark Appel, Stanford
  • 2. Chicago Cubs- 3B Kris Bryant, San Diego
  • 3. Colorado Rockies- RHP Johnathan Gray, Oklahoma
  • 4. Minnesota Twins- RHP Kohl Stewart, Saint Pius X HS  (Texas)
  • 5. Cleveland Indians- OF Clint Frazier, Loganville HS (Georgia)
  • 6. Miami Marlins-  3B Colin Moran, North Carolina
  • 7. Boston Red Sox- LHP Trey Ball, New Castle HS (Indiana)
  • 8. Kansas City Royals- SS Hunter Dozier, Stephen F Austin
  • 9. Pittsburgh Pirates- OF Austin Meadows, Grayson HS (Georgia)
  • 10. Toronto Blue Jays- RHP Philip Bickford, Oaks Christian HS (California)
  • 11. New York Mets- 1B Dominic Smith, Serra HS (California)
  • 12. Seattle Mariners- 3B D.J. Peterson, New Mexico
  • 13. San Diego Padres- OF Hunter Renfroe, Mississippi State
  • 14. Pittsburgh Pirates- C Reese McGuire, Kentwood HS (Washington)
  • 15. Arizona Diamondbacks- RHP Braden Shipley, Nevada
  • 16. Philadelphia Phillies- SS J.P. Crawford, Lakewood HS (California)
  • 17. Chicago White Sox- SS, Tim Anderson, East Central CC (JUCO)
  • 18. Los Angeles Dodgers- RHP Chris Anderson, Jacksonville
  • 19. St. Louis Cardinals- LHP Marco Gonzales, Gonzaga
  • 20. Detroit Tigers- RHP Johnathan Crawford, Florida
  • 21. Tampa Bay Rays- C Nick Ciuffo, Lexington HS (South Carolina)
  • 22. Baltimore Orioles- RHP Hunter Harvey, Bandys HS (North Carolina)
  • 23. Texas Rangers- RHP Alex Gonzalez, Oral Roberts
  • 24. Oakland Athletics- OF Billy McKinney, Plano West HS (Texas)
  • 25. San Francisco Giants- SS Christian Arroyo, Hernando HS (Florida)
  • 26. New York Yankees- 3B Eric Jagielo, Notre Dame
  • 27. Cincinnati Reds- OF Phillip Ervin, Samford
  • 28. St. Louis Cardinals- LHP Rob Kaminsky, St. Joseph Regional HS (New Jersey)
  • 29. Tampa Bay Rays- RHP Ryne Stanek, Arkansas 
  • 30. Texas Rangers- SS Travis Demeritte, Winder Barrow HS (Georgia)
  • 31. Atlanta Braves- RHP Jason Hursh, Oklahoma State
  • 32. New York Yankees- OF Aaron Judge, Fresno State
  • 33. New York Yankees- LHP Ian Clarkin, James Madison HS (California)

Competitive Balance Round A

  • 34. Kansas City Royals- LHP Sean Manaea, Indiana State
  • 35. Miami Marlins- LHP Matt Krook, St. Ignatius HS (California)
  • 36. Arizona Diamondbacks- RHP Aaron Blair, Marshall
  • 37. Baltimore Orioles- OF Josh Hart, Park View HS (Georgia)
  • 38. Cincinnati Reds- RHP Michael Lorenzen, Cal State Fullerton
  • 39. Detroit Tigers- RHP Corey Knebel, Texas

Second Round

  • 40. Houston Astros- RHP Andrew Thurman, UC Irvine
  • 41. Chicago Cubs- LHP Rob Zastryzny, Missouri
  • 42. Colorado Rockies- 3B Brian McMahon, Mater Hei HS (California)
  • 43. Minnesota Twins- RHP Ryan Eades, LSU
  • 44. Miami Marlins- RHP Trevor Williams, Arizona State
  • 45. Boston Red Sox- RHP Teddy Stankiewicz, Seminole State (JUCO)
  • 46. Kansas City Royals- LHP Cody Reed, Northwest Mississippi CC (JUCO)
  • 47. Toronto Blue Jays- RHP Clinton Hollon, Woodford County HS (Kentucky)
  • 48. New York Mets- RHP Andrew Church, Basic HS (Nevada)
  • 49. Seattle Mariners- OF Austin Wilson, Stanford
  • 50. San Diego Padres- SS Dustin Peterson, Gilbert HS (Arizona)
  • 51. Pittsburgh Pirates- LHP Blake Taylor, Dana Hills HS (California)
  • 52. Arizona Diamondbacks- SS Justin Williams, Terrebonne HS (Louisana)
  • 53. Philadelphia Phillies- C Andrew Knapp, California
  • 54. Milwaukee Brewers- RHP Devin Williams, Hazelwood West HS (Missouri)
  • 55. Chicago White Sox- RHP Tyler Danish, Durant HS (Florida)
  • 56. Los Angeles Dodgers- LHP Tom Windle, Minnesota
  • 57. St. Louis Cardinals- SS Oscar Mercado, Gaither HS (Florida)
  • 58. Detroit Tigers- LHP Kevin Ziomek, Vanderbilt
  • 59. Los Angeles Angels- LHP Hunter Green, Wareen East HS (Kentucky)
  • 60. Tampa Bay Rays- SS Riley Unroe, Desert Ridge HS (Arizona)
  • 61. Baltimore Orioles- C Chance Sisco, Santiago HS (California)
  • 62. Texas Rangers- RHP Akeem Bostick, West Florence HS (South Carolina)
  • 63. Oakland Athletics- LHP Dillon Overton, Oklahoma
  • 64. San Francisco Giants- 3B Ryder Jones, Watauga HS (North Carolina)
  • 65. Atlanta Braves- C Victor Caratini, Miami Dade CC (JUCO)
  • 66. New York Yankees- 2B Gosuke Katoh, Rancho Bernando HS (California)
  • 67. Cincinnati Reds- 3B Kevin Franklin, Gahr HS (California)
  • 68. Washington Nationals- RHP Jacob Johansen, Dallas Baptist

Competitive Balance Round B

  • 69. San Diego Padres- OF Jordan Paroubeck, Serra HS (California)
  • 70. Colorado Rockies- RHP Alex Balog, San Francisco
  • 71. Oakland A's- 3B Chad Pinder, Virginia Tech
  • 72. Milwaukee Brewers- SS Tucker Neuhaus, Wharton HS (Florida)
  • 73. Miami Marlins- RHP Colby Suggs, Arkansas

227 comments:

1 – 200 of 227   Newer›   Newest»
Justin M. said...

Draft coverage has been great guys. Looking forward to some play by play leading up to the Mets' pick.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for joining us Justin.

Really hoping Austin Meadows falls to us at #11.

If not Aaron Judge is the guy i want

Justin M. said...

Meadows would be fantastic.

Also, that Wheeler countdown threw me for a loop. Looked official :)

Mack Ade said...

Hey guys... Mack is in the house.

Unknown said...

Hey fellas. Back from purgatory. Looking forward to the draft coverage tonight!

Mack Ade said...

Right now I'm hearing the the Astros are still talking to 4-5 players, but my 'educated' guess is they will go with Mark Appel at a slight discount

Mack Ade said...

da Rammy man....

Stephen Guilbert said...

I'm saying Jon Gray. At a discount.

Justin M. said...

I feel like this is Christmas morning for Mack's Mets. haha.

Unknown said...

Mack! Good to see you again. Man, it's been a rough time in life but glad to be back!

Mack Ade said...

also... Royals and Phil Bickford are a "done deal" per Gammons

Mack Ade said...

my wished are #11 - Meadows, #48 Wahl

Unknown said...

If Smith or Meadows are still at 11, who would you guys go with?

Stephen Guilbert said...

meadows

Stephen Guilbert said...

i dont want judge

Anonymous said...

Meadows hands down

Mack Ade said...

Rammy, Meadows... he's a legend in Georgia

Unknown said...

I am hoping Meadows, Smith, Judge, Peterson in that order.

Justin M. said...

Would Bickford be considered a bit of a reach for the Royals at 8?

Unknown said...

I am so pumped about the draft!!!

Mack Ade said...

would this be a good time to discuss the pros and cons of gays marrying?

Anonymous said...

The Astros are on the clock!!!!

Mack Ade said...

Justin:

Yes it is but the deal is done and may be $3mil

Mack Ade said...

Keith Law just said Appel to Houston

Mack Ade said...

(I need to get this site off of Blogger...)

Anonymous said...

Seeing as how I just came back from a Jewish Lesbian wedding with a lesbian rabbi.....probably not lol

Mack Ade said...

Even the opening comments are late.

Unknown said...

Selig always looks like a hot mess

Mack Ade said...

It amazes me when they showed that shot of the Houston draft room... there are ALL the scouts with their suits and ties on and there are t least 5-6 major showcases going on right now around the USA that they should be at evaluating 2014-2015 talent... instead, suits and ties for all, martinis later.

Mack Ade said...

John Manuel and Ben Badler says Astros is Appel

Anonymous said...

After a years long work....they deserve it lol

Anonymous said...

Appel it is!

Mack Ade said...

He was the best player in the draft - it was the right move

Mack Ade said...

I'm going out on the limb here and say that the drug test cost Gray the #2 pick... my pick is Bryant to the Cubs

Justin M. said...

four and a half minutes seems excessive...

Unknown said...

Cubs stalling!

Stephen Guilbert said...

Yea that was a bit weird.

Mack Ade said...

Got that one :)

Unknown said...

Nice call Mack!

Anonymous said...

Wow.....passed on Gray.

Mack Ade said...

Rockies will pick Dominic Smith

Anonymous said...

That Adderall thing must've hurt him huh

Stephen Guilbert said...

No way. I still don't believe Dom Smith goes in the top 10 picks.

Mack Ade said...

thanks Rammy

Mack Ade said...

strangly, the Adderall should have made him a cheaper pick

Mack Ade said...

told ya it would be Gray :)

Anonymous said...

You said Smith

-_-

Anonymous said...

No way Rockies could resist passing on him.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Gray is a steal there. Nice pick. I thought the Rockies would go with pitching, I just didn't think Gray would be there.

#4 to the Twins...I'm thinking Kohl Stewart

Anonymous said...

I think Colin Moran.

Mack Ade said...

Now I would just be guessing...

Anonymous said...

Good call Stephen

Unknown said...

Moran at 5 is my guess

Mack Ade said...

one of my 'target' guys is Ryne Stanek and having 3 RHPs already gone at this point doesn't look good for my wants and needs

Unknown said...

Finally got in!

Unknown said...

Hey Gary!

Anonymous said...

Welcome Gary!

Stephen Guilbert said...

#5 I could see Colin Moran as well.

Mack Ade said...

I think the next two picks will be Frazier and Moran (in no particular order) and then we might have a few surprises...

Mack Ade said...

Hey Gary... welcome

Unknown said...

so we're all waiting for the upset pick

Anonymous said...

well....Gray dropped 2 spots...that was a small surprise.

Frazier here i think.

Unknown said...

hey guys its Mack and Sue's anniversary tomorrow wish him a good one

Mack Ade said...

good pick... watch for Moran and Shipley next two picks

Stephen Guilbert said...

DAMN. I wanted Frazier.

Unknown said...

Frazier was never going to drop down to #11

Mack Ade said...

it's following the plan to have Meadows available at #11...

Anonymous said...

Shipley to Miami next in my opinion.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Shipley to Miami makes a lot of sense.

Anonymous said...

Mack,

Miami would be the biggest risk to Meadows NOT falling to us....so hopefully he falls through

Mack Ade said...

Does Miami go anglo?

Mack Ade said...

(I am so politically incorrect)

Unknown said...

Wow. The Marlins war room has flat screen tv's! Didn't think with all their cuts they would have those 'luxuries'

Anonymous said...

They probably got them on loan from Rent a Center

Unknown said...

Lol@ Soto

Unknown said...

hey Mack have you heard anything on trading picks in the future

Anonymous said...

Wow....wasnt expecting a college pick here.

Was sure they were going HS since they wont be playoff caliber for a while.

Unknown said...

Meadows is a risk to Boston or Toronto

Mack Ade said...

Okay...

6 down... 4 to go before Mets pick

on the board... Meadows, Smith, Peterson, McGuire, Ball, Stanek, Shipley

Anonymous said...

@Gary

I believe Clubs can currently trade "competitive balance" picks

Unknown said...

Mack, where do you see the #11 pick falling into your top 25?

Unknown said...

it would be fitting that the friggin Fish are the team that'll grab Meadows ahead of us...

The Closer said...

Shipley here?

Stephen Guilbert said...

Question for you guys: If Reese McGuire is on the board, do you take him?

I freakin' would.

Unknown said...

If Boston doesn't take Meadows here, we got a good shot at him

Anonymous said...

I think McGuire is going here.

Stephen Guilbert said...

If the Royals take Bickford, we'll have some reallllyyy nice options.

Mack Ade said...

Derek: right now I have D.J. Peterson

The Closer said...

Trey Ball huh? A bit of a surprise here, but good player.

Anonymous said...

Wow....that was a small reach...

Meadows looking REALLY nice right now.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Wow Ball to the Red Sox. Meadows and Peterson still on the board.

Unknown said...

ok guys if McGuire and Meadows are on the board who do they pick.....a H.S. SS lol

Mack Ade said...

okay, you Meadows fans now have a real shot at him

Anonymous said...

@Gary

Meadows.

We already have a Catcher of the future.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Hell I'm looking at McGuire a lot now. I don't see him getting past Pitt but crazier things have happened. I thought he had a good shot of being a top 5 pick.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Soto...you do not draft for position in the first round.

Mack Ade said...

I'm not changing my initial wants..

I'm sick of first round high school players..

I'll take Shipley, Stanek, or Peterson

Stephen Guilbert said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

I agree with Meadows. But there is no guarantee d'Arnaud or Plawecki will make it to the Show and be healthy.

Unknown said...

A solid hitting, defensive catcher is a hot commodity.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Bickford do itttt

Stephen Guilbert said...

WAIT.....WHAT?!?!!

Anonymous said...

Who??? WOw....surprise surprise

The Closer said...

Mack, who is Hunter Dozier?

Justin M. said...

ok...throw your brackets out the window

Mack Ade said...

wow

Anonymous said...

This is a straight draft pool money save move.

Mack Ade said...

okay, with the Dozier pick, the Mets now are guaranteed a blue chip pick... unless they want to fuck it up

Stephen Guilbert said...

THey'll fuck it up hahaha

Unknown said...

there's our wildcard whoopee

Unknown said...

DePo better not blow this!

Stephen Guilbert said...

I swear if they draft J.P. Crawford or Tim Anderson I'm going to go to north jersey and slap Depo on the back of the head.

Unknown said...

I seriously almost threw my computer out when they picked Cecchini last year. I hope that isn't the case this year

Mack Ade said...

Closer - I had Dozier as the 10th ranked third baseman/shortstop in the draft... not even a first day pick... a complete surprse to me

Unknown said...

I think the Mets pick the best player available since all eyes are on them after they didn't want to surrender the pick for Bourn

Unknown said...

screw this up....hey guys no way we're the Mets...lol....and if they screw this up Mack will quit the team :)

Mack Ade said...

Gary willl tell you... I told him on the phone if the Mets go bad here, I'm becoming a nun

Unknown said...

DePo is pissed because that was his guy!

The Closer said...

Yup, there goes Meadows!!!

Anonymous said...

SHIT!!!

Stephen Guilbert said...

Wow I wanted Meadows.

Unknown said...

NOOOOOOO!!!!!

Mack Ade said...

sorry guys...

me?

I'd rather have all the H.S. players picked before #11 so I can say I didn't make the wrong pick...

my three college guys still on the board

Unknown said...

ok so the Royals pulled a Cecchini so maybe we're safe

The Closer said...

"DePo is pissed because that was his guy!"

Haha...good point

Unknown said...

ok Mack so your still good?

Stephen Guilbert said...

Wow I'm really starting to like Shipley this far down. Like a lot a lot a lot.

Unknown said...

Shipley or Stanek?

Stephen Guilbert said...

Ship.

Mack Ade said...

just got call... told Mets looking at Renfroe

Anonymous said...

mcguire here

jays need a d arnaud replacement

Mack Ade said...

Gary, I'm not that big on Renfroe

Unknown said...

should I laugh or cry that the Evil Empire has 3 picks before our second pick

The Closer said...

Backfire, Mets on the clock......

Stephen Guilbert said...

I go McGuire here.

Charles said...

So who do they pick? Who's the best available?

Stephen Guilbert said...

Ship or McGuire. Can't go wrong with either. I would kill for either. Please don't mess this up.

Anonymous said...

hmmm...

A lot of guys here possible.

Mack Ade said...

Guys, I'm going to go and work on, and post, the Mets pick when it is called out..

I'll be back...

Unknown said...

Mack put the gun down...tomorrow's your anniversary

The Closer said...

Backfire = bickford , stupid autocorrect

Unknown said...

Don't blow this DePo!!!!!

Charles said...

They'll blow it, they always do....

Justin M. said...

lot of Dom smith chatter on twitter... BA etc.

Unknown said...

This for Michael Bourn.... Who will it be???

Unknown said...

good one

Unknown said...

Awesome! Love this guy!

The Closer said...

Sorry guys, this was my guy! Mack will tell you, I've been talking about him for months. About time!!!!!

Charles said...

Best available?

Anonymous said...

Defining statement about their confidence in Issac Davis.

or lack of it.

Unknown said...

Mack can exhale now

Unknown said...

I hope Bobby Wahl drops to us at #48

Unknown said...

MLB comparison Todd Helton....no pressure here

Justin M. said...

Dom Smith calls Mets "an incredible team" LOL.

Unknown said...

guess a Kaminsky fall to us to much to ask for but maybe a Mack favorite in Lorenson

Unknown said...

"incredible team". LOL

The Closer said...

He's 17 and just experienced the most incredible moment of his life and on national tv. I'm surprised he said anything that resembled the English language. Poor kid was nervous

Stephen Guilbert said...

I do love this pick. Great bat, great glove, great character kid.

Really curious why Shipley and McGuire are falling this far.

Unknown said...

I like the fact he is athletic enough to move to the OF. And heaven knows how much help we need there

Mack Ade said...

Back

I just posted up an interview I did with Dominic around a year ago plus some info on him (scouting reports)

Michael S. said...

Wanted Meadows if we went HS. I'm a little bummed we didn't get him but I'll be rooting for Dom Smith.

Mack Ade said...

sorry guys - being interviewed...

Mack Ade said...

Sorry... I'm back... just got off with reporter in LA... very high on Smith

Mack Ade said...

High school pure first baseman

not happy

Stephen Guilbert said...

You don't like the pick?

Anonymous said...

Thread has died after the mets pick.

Mack Ade said...

Stephen, I think he's a great high school bat and might be the best projectable bat in the draft, but I wanted a college player that would complete the puzzle and move this team on quicker.

A pitcher like Braden Shipley would have made Queens by the end of 2014 making Syndergaard the 6th rotational pitcher... all of a sudden you can trade for all the positional players you need.

Now, we have to wait another five years and hope things don't go wrong...

I don't like it... sorry.

Unknown said...

Id prefer Shipley but it is still a good pick in my book. Now let's hope judge or Wilson falls to 48

Mack Ade said...

Soto - you still here?

Mack Ade said...

Anybody still here?

Stephen Guilbert said...

I would have taken Shipley. Then probably Peterson. Smith would have been 3rd on my list.

No wait 4th..I forgot about McGuire.

I think I'm with you..I love the pick, but he wasn't my first choice. I really really like Ship.

Unknown said...

Mack, let me ask the question now that we have a name, where does Dom Smith slot into your 25

Mack Ade said...

Stephen, Shipley was NEVER suppose to drop that low... his ETA is after the 2014 ASG... or latest OD 2015... you'd have Harvey, Wheeler, Niese, Montero, Shipley... and all sorts of trade possibilties for bats...

now... wait until 2018... if he doesn't break a leg or something...

I'm really sick of this hole approach...

well, let's see if Stanek, Eades, or Whal is still around at 48

Anonymous said...

Im still here Mack,

@Derek, I generally wouldn't add newly drafted guys to Top Prospect Rankings.

If I did, I'd probably start him around #18 - #22 to start.

Unknown said...

Maybe Boldt will drop to #48

Unknown said...

As for too early...Is too much to start wishing for Rondon from NC State to fall to us at 3 or 4 next year?

Mack Ade said...

I had Dom Smith at #13

Mack Ade said...

Derek - Boldt is injured and will probably go to school

The Closer said...

Still some really good players on the board that are falling that the Yankees are going to snatch up. Ugh

Stephen Guilbert said...

I had Dom Smith at #13 as well.

Mack Ade said...

a lot of high school kids going now... there will be plenty of college players for Sandy and Company to ignore at #48

The Closer said...

I know I'm in the minority, but I really do like the Smith pick. I want you guys to just do me a favor and go back to the immediate 30 seconds after you heard the mets draft Nimmo & Cecchini in the past 2 drafts. It could be MUCH worse.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Like they did last year with their second pick?

Oh...wait...

Mack Ade said...

Ryan - then you are happy with a pure first baseman with a 2018 ETA - that's what you got

Michael S. said...

The Nimmo pick didn't bother me. I was bummed because the Astros nabbed Springer before the Mets could. At that point I wanted Nimmo because they were hoping to get him with the pick that became Fulmer.

Cecchini? I don't know what to say about that pick.

Mack Ade said...

Soto, so where do you rank Smith Mets prospect wise?

Anonymous said...

@Mack

without seeing a single game....

#21 probably

Mack Ade said...

so, late 3 first round picks... 2 in extended and one in A-ball

playoffs in 2018, 2 years after I die

love it

Mack Ade said...

correction...

"last" 3 first round picks

Michael S. said...

I think Duda and Davis are traded sooner rather than later and a veteran is brought in during the offseason to hold down the fort until Smith is ready.

Unknown said...

hi again

David Rubin said...

Hey gang- big shout out to Mack and my last year's Draft Partner, Stephen!!! I was driving while the Mets took Smith, and Jim Bowden said he has a "70" bat, and anyone who knows him (referring to himself) knows he NEVER gives anyone a "70". Also said great kid, great make up, incredible fielder, and has the chance to grow into a 70 power bat, too. I know everyone wanted hitting help YESTERDAY, but this was a great move, getting perhaps best pure (and long-term) hitter in the draft! I like it an awful lot, and will LOVE it if we get a good college OF bat with 2nd pick!!

Anonymous said...

Damn....there goes Judge to the Stankees.

Mack Ade said...

this is like old dorm night here...

Mack Ade said...

watch the Yankees now go Wilson after Judge

Stephen Guilbert said...

Wilson or Manaea if both are around?

David Rubin said...

Somehow I was hoping that everyone would have amnesia and forget about Rob Kaminsky and he'd fall to the Mets in the 2nd round...of course, the Cards grabbed him- but I'm glad that the Yankees didn't get a chance at him.
FYI- Mack was the first person, last year, to talk about Philip Ervin, and I have heard so many great things about him over the past few days that I was almost hoping we'd take him but that would've been too big a reach.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Well Whitson, Manaea, Wilson, Williams, Hart, Denny, Eades all still on the board. Bet is one falls. Praying for Wilson

Mack Ade said...

There actually are some decent players still on the board and each team has a different definition of 'best player available' so the next 10 picks will be interesting.

After that, the draft starts to go weak.

Good names still out there... Eades, Wahl, (wild card) Covey, (wild card) Manaea, (wild card) Ziomek, Windle,

Mack Ade said...

also some decent OF talent still out there... Wilson, (wild card) Boldt, Justin Williams, Lorenzen, (wild card) Abreu

«Oldest ‹Older   1 – 200 of 227   Newer› Newest»