1/29/24

SAVAGE VIEWS – The Mediocre Mets - Part Two

 

At this time last year, Mets fans were ecstatic that we would be serious contenders for a World Series title.  After all, our rotation was headed by two Hall of Fame pitchers.  Things did not go as planned, obviously.  

Most pundits have the Mets winning even less games in what is being called a transition year.  Let’s take a look at last year’s roster vs the projected roster for 24.

Pos

2023 Mets

2024 Mets Projected

1B

Alonso

Alonso

2B

McNeil

McNeil

SS

Lindor

Lindor

3B

Escobar

Baty

LF

Canha

Nimmo

CF

Nimmo

Bader

RF

Marte

Marte

C

Navarez/Nido

Alvarez/Nido

DH

Vogelbach

Vientos

OF 4

Locastro

Taylor

OF 5

Pham

Stewart

INF

Guilorme

Wendell

 

 

 

SP 1

Scherzer

Senga

SP 2

Verlander

Quintana

SP 3

Senga

Severino

SP 4

Carrasco

Manaea

SP 5

Peterson

Houser

SP 6

Megill

Megill

RP

Robertson

Diaz

RP

Ottavino

Ottavino

RP

Raley

Raley

RP

Smith

Smith

RP

Nogosek

Lucchesi

RP

Curtiss

Butto

RP

Hunter

Lopez

RP

Santana

Hartwig


An argument can be made that this year’s team is actually better than the team that started last year.  The offensive production for the first three months of the season was underwhelming.  Alonso, McNeil, Lindor, Marte, et al all had poor starts to their seasons.  

The catching duo of Narvaez and Nido was below par. 

Verlander and Quintana began the season on IR which propelled Megill to the Five Hole.  The pen without Diaz was a disaster.  It’s reasonable to expect bounce back years from the likes of Alonso, McNeil, Marte, and Lindor.  Although Lindor did finish strong, he struggled through the first three months of the season.

Alvarez has emerged as a potential star, while Nido is an adequate backup.  The major questions that need to be answered are whether Baty and Vientos will live up to the hype.  The feeling is that they have survived their growing pains and will be significant contributors this year. 

In the wings, should the need arise, are Acuna and Gilbert.  Also, upcoming relievers include Lavender and Gervase plus a large number of no-name additions who could provide excellent depth.  This year might see pieces like Vasil, Scott and Hamel emerge as future starters.

I like the job Stearns has done in building the team to compete in 2024 while retaining top prospects.   

The above hopefully supports my argument that our team will be very competitive this year. 

Ray

January 29, 2024

12 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

Quite a list, Ray.

Phil Bickford would be a reliever in my 26 man opening day roster list.

If healthy, this team can compete.

Anonymous said...

Mark my words,the rotation Senga,Megillah,Severino,Quintana,Houser is sneaky good.

Tom Brennan said...

Ray, if we do get Wandy Peralta, a strong pen if the pen stays healthy.

Rds 900. said...

The key here is starting healthy.

Anonymous said...

Manes two behind Senga!

Amazin Z said...

Outside of Closer, as Diaz will start the year healthy and at C with a full year of Alvarez, this is roughly the same team as last year. If healthy, and that’s a huge if with this team (Marte, Severino, Quintana, Bader, etc.), we should roughly be a .500 team. If healthy, our top hitters bounce back from bad Seasons last year, and the kids (Baty, Vientos, Gilbert, Acuna) play to their abilities we will probably be a Wild Card contender. That is asking a lot though. Anyone who is counting this team to be an 86+ win team needs to be a little more realistic. If we’re 5
or more games over .500 at the All Star Break then I can have more faith.

Tom Brennan said...

Amazin Z, we've all seen Mets' teams underachieve more often than not, for a slew of reasons. But Edwin could help us overachieve in 2024.

Amazin Z said...

Tom I do think Diaz is so good that he saves at least 5 or 6 games that we lost last year. But that still doesn’t make us a .500 team. I think we will have a better record than last year but not sure about being in the WC Race come August and September. I think a .500 record or slightly over is most realistic.

The big question and worry I have is if we’re .500 at the Trade Deadline and he doesn’t trade anyone or worse makes trades with our prospects to bring in players. Unless this team is over .500 at the deadline he should move all players on 1 year deals and keep building the farm system. This Rotation isn’t built for a Playoff run. If we made the Playoffs we’d be knocked out 1st Round. If Stearns is selling us on ‘25, ‘26, and beyond stick to the plan.

bill metsiac said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
bill metsiac said...

Q has earned the #2 slot. It should be his unless he shows he doesn't rate it.

Anonymous said...

Amazon Z This is Tom on the wrong phone again. I think we have to see how it plays out, but I feel very positive if they get Wandy Peralta and he’s healthy. I’ll get into it more on Thursday

Anonymous said...

Megillah is the key. If he is a solid #2 the rotation is good.