10/30/20

Mets360 - Poll: Which Mets playoff defeat was the most painful?

 


By Brian Joura October 30, 2020


There was an ESPN piece published today ranking every World Series. It’s posted in The Garden, if you haven’t seen it yet. Anyway, it’s a reminder that the Mets are 2-3 in five trips to the Series. If we asked a poll question about which was the best World Series, my guess is that it would split along age lines. Those 60 and older would vote for 1969 and those younger would choose 1986. But the flip side isn’t so cut and dried. And let’s expand it to include some playoff defeats. Here are our contenders:

 

1973 World Series – Rusty Staub playing heroically – and terrifically – with an injured shoulder, Willie Mays pleading with the umpire over a blown call, the Mets having a 3-2 lead in the series only to have the manager panic and pitch guys on short rest in the final two games. They really should have won.

 

1988 NLCS – Darryl Strawberry‘s 165 OPS+, David Cone going 20-3, an NLCS matchup against a Dodgers squad that they went 10-1 against during the regular season, leaving Doc Gooden in for the 9th inning in Game 4, Sid Fernandez throwing beachballs in Game 5. They really should have won.

 

1999 NLCS – The best defensive infield ever, the season-ending sweep to force a tie for the Wild Card, Al Leiter‘s two-hit shutout in Game 163, Todd Pratt‘s walkoff HR in the NLDS, losing the first three games of the series only to battle back, John Olerud‘s two-run single off John Rocker, Robin Ventura‘s grand slam single, falling behind by five runs in the first inning of Game 6 but coming back to force extra innings. Maybe they shouldn’t have won but it was such a fun group and a memorable series.


Continue reading by clicking here.

3 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

2015. Why? Because it is the most recent memory of that loss, and the Mets had the superior team.

Remember1969 said...

Tom, I have to disagree with you that they had the superior team.

In my opinion, the Royals had almost a perfect baseball team that October. They combined enough hitting with a lot of speed, good defense, did not strike out much, and pitched well with a particularly strong bullpen. That is the recipe for good baseball. The Mets should have learned a lesson from that whipping, but I'm not sure they did.

Remember1969 said...

BTW . my vote was the 1973 World Series loss. Up three games to two with Seaver on regular rest if game 7 was necessary and they pitched him on short rest in game 6 and Matlack on short rest in game 7. They had a rested George Stone who went 12-3 that year to pitch in game 6 and did not do it. The offense didn't do much in either of the two final games (3 runs combined), but I blame that one on the pitching set-up. Painful.