11/23/19

OPEN THREAD – Minor League Long Term Deals






Seattle Mariner 1B prospect Evan White (No. 58 on MLBPipeline)

 Top 100) is set to sign long-term deal with the team. Guaranteed $24

mil over first six years, also includes three club options. Should be

announced Monday. White hit .293/.350/.488 in Double-A this year,

also outstanding defender.




My questions to you are:


1.    Is this a good idea for the Mets?

2.    And, if it is, who would you try to sign up to a deal like this?

6 comments:

John From Albany said...

The Indians had success doing deals like this after the players showed they could play in the majors. I would do a deal like this for Pete Alonso. For minor leaguers or Pitchers it is very risky. Imagine if we had given Matt Harvey a long term deal after 2015.

Hobie said...

Sure, Jarred Kelenic.
... oh, wait.

Mack Ade said...

I have two.

1. Alonso

2. Lugo, which would probably be very affordable

Mike Freire said...

Extending young, established players like Pete usually makes sense, although the Mets were burned by the
Juan Lagares extension. If that is what we are talking about, then players like Pete and Jeff are who I would target.

However, if we are talking about prospects who have not played an inning of major league baseball then I am much
more skeptical. I think Mack estimated a very low success rate of "prospects" at some point in the past, something like
5 or 10%. IF that is the case, then you are taking an even larger chance by extending the contract of an unknown quantity
when compared to an established player.

I think the chances of getting burned are much higher then the money you would save by controlling the costs of a young
player's tenure before free agency begins, but that's just me.

Tom Brennan said...

Bad move...and if I were a 28 year old Jeff McNeil making under a million after what he has DONE, I would be very upset at the inequity of it.

Tom Brennan said...

They can do this, but the Mets can’t do much, so near the cap. A deal like this would or might change baseball’s compensation structure. If year 3 McNeil makes $1 this year, he’d have to feel angry at being underpaid...which he is, after the last 2 years.