7/11/25

MACK - MY Friday Observations - David Peterson, WAR Leaders, Draft Coverage, Emmanuel Clase, Robert Cotter, Will Watson, Sandy Alcantara, Eugenio Suárez, Wilyer Abreu, Jhoan Duran

 



We are getting real close to the draft... here's my plan. 

Beginning the morning of July 14th (next Monday), I will slip in individual anaysis reports on each of the Mets draft picks.

They will be on the top of the hour, slipped in between the regular scheduled stuff we do around here.... from 7am through noon each day.

Also, I will have two posts pre-draft on targets players the Mets may look at for their firs two picks.

Pitch Profiler                             @pitchprofiler

That's ALL-STAR David Peterson to you

 


2025 Saves Leaderboard


 
 

WAR Leaders - Left Fielder


 

WAR Leaders - Right Fielder




Trade Targets

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6467560/2025/07/02/mlb-trade-deadline-predictions-alcantara-naylor/    

Emmanuel Clase, RHRP, Guardians

Clase’s name kept coming up in the survey, which surprised me as he’s considered one of the top closers in the game. He’s also under team control through the 2028 season. Clase, 27, has a 3.28 ERA over 37 appearances and 18 saves this year.

The Guardians, who rank 26th in runs, need more offense. Perhaps they’d be willing to make a buyer-to-buyer type of trade to give up a lockdown leverage reliever for a middle-of-the-order impact bat to address this weakness.


Jim Koenigsberger                          @Jimfrombaseball

11-year-old Robert Cotter caught a foul ball one day at a Philadelphia Phillies game and, like any fan, refused to give it back – even when team officials demanded. The consequences were severe. The team had the boy arrested, not only for keeping the property, but also after accusing him of sneaking in to the game without paying for his ticket.

Cotter was forced to spend an entire night in jail until being freed the next day when a sympathetic judge found that it was “entirely reasonable” that a kid could keep a foul ball at a baseball game. And besides, the judge noted, he made a really good catch.

“I never heard of Connie Mack or Philadelphia Athletics President Tom Shibe throwing small boys into prison because they took a ball that was batted into the bleachers. They were boys. I don’t know whether you or Shetzline were ever boys, for if you were you would know how they cherish the ball they get, and you would permit them to have the ball instead of throwing them into a cell overnight. Why, I would have done the same thing myself if I had been in this boy’s place.

I wouldn’t brand this boy a thief just to help Mr. Shetzline save a $1.50 ball. If Mr. Shetzline wanted his test case, there is the decision" Judge Charles L. Brown

The Yankees sent Robert Cotter a ball signed by Bob Shawkey with a letter lauding Cotter for his “battle against injustice.”

Baseball then enacted the "Reubens Rule" when Reuben Berman, a New York Giants fan who, on May 16, 1921, refused to give back a foul ball and was thereby removed from the Polo Grounds.  Berman sued the Giants for mental and physical distress and won the court case plus $100. Robert Cotter, 75 years after his arrest that was requested by the Phillies. The the Phillies finally made things right with Robert Cotter by inviting Cotter, then a grandfather and father of six to a game. The team gave Cotter two signed baseballs, one by the entire 1998 team and one by Phillies Hall of Famer Robin Roberts.

The Phillies also declared Cotter their “fan of the century.”


Will Watson

https://www.mlb.com/news/mets-2025-draft-preview?partnerID=web_article-share

Breakout 2024 pick: Will Watson, SP, pick 203 -- The Mets selected several pitchers high in last year’s Draft, including second-rounder Jonathan Santucci and third-rounder Nate Dohm. Their early success has been less surprising than that of Watson, a seventh-rounder from USC whose velocity has ticked up to the mid-90s as a pro. Watson recently earned a promotion to High-A Brooklyn and a spot on Pipeline’s Top 30 Mets prospect list, at No. 29.


Top 40 players on market as July 31 approaches

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/5591079/2025/07/09/mlb-trade-deadline-big-board-players-postseason-2/

5                      Sandy Alcantara

Age                29

Position       SP

B/T                 R/R

Fits                 CHC, NYM, TOR

Deal likelihood

Value: Cy Young winner searching for form

Analysis:      Which version of Alcantara is actually on the market? The 2022 Cy Young winner excelled then by keeping the ball in the park and on the ground. But he took a step back in 2023, went under the knife for Tommy John surgery and has returned this year without the command that makes his mix work. He ditched his slider earlier this year and started to look like the Sandy of old – right up until he allowed 12 runs in 12 innings the last two times out.

Since June 1, the walk rate is one-third of what it was before then, and so there’s reason to believe Alcantara’s worst is behind him. He isn't a pitcher who strikes out the lineup, but he is a potential playoff starter, and the supply of those is very limited this deadline.

Owed in 2025             $6.4 million

Controlled through 2027

 

6                      Eugenio Suárez

Age                33

Position       3B

B/T                 R/R

Fits                 CHC, MIL, SEA

Deal likelihood

Value: Reliable right-handed power bat

Analysis:      Moving Suárez to acquire future help while maneuvering with other deals to buttress the roster would be the kind of thing Mike Hazen has done before, most notably when he traded away Zack Greinke in 2019 but also brought in Mike Leake and Zac Gallen. Nobody on this list has hit more career homers than Suárez or more homers since the start of 2023. Rafael Devers will end up as the best bat moved this season. Suárez has a solid case for No. 2.

Owed in 2025 $4.8 million

Controlled through 2025

 

7                      Wilyer Abreu

Age                26

Position       OF

B/T                 L/L

Fits                 MIL, PHI, SD

Deal likelihood

Value: Elite defender with pop

Analysis:      Abreu, like Duran, could become expendable in Boston thanks to the wave of young bats. But he’s also young enough (26) and under team control for long enough (2029) to be part of the Red Sox’s long-term plan, putting them in the driver’s seat for any potential negotiations.

Even if the Red Sox are open to trading Abreu, there’s no rush to do so now. He’s putting up very good numbers at the plate that are in line with his strong rookie showing, and he will be in the mix for a second Gold Glove Award and won’t even be arbitration eligible until 2027.

Owed in 2025             $244K

Controlled through 2029

 

8                      Jhoan Duran

Age                27

Position       RP

B/T                 R/R

Fits                 DET, NYY, PHI

Deal likelihood

Value: Flame-throwing closer

Analysis:      Duran has three dominant pitches and the unhittable results to match, pairing a triple-digit fastball with two swing-and-miss breaking balls for a 2.40 ERA in four MLB seasons. Minnesota’s closer for the past three years, Duran often overpowers hitters and has gone over 70 innings without allowing a homer.

Duran is one of the league’s best relievers, still cheap and under team control through 2027, so the Twins will likely ask for the moon and might be able to get it somewhere. He has the ability to transform an entire bullpen and ranks second to Devin Williams in reliever Win Probability Added since 2022.

Owed in 2025             $1.3 million

Controlled through 2027

5 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

Start moving our bags of chips to UPS. Deals are coming. The pen is pooped and Ross, Nunez and Lambert aren’t quite ready. Could McLean and Sproat switch to reliever down the stretch? Sproat excellent for 3rd straight outing.

Reese Kaplan said...

Doing nothing midseason has become Stearns' NY Mets standard MO. I'm not expecting miracles but perhaps we will see which minor leaguers they feel are expendable by month's end.

Tom Brennan said...

Getting a true closer quality reliever would be important, first in the event of a Diaz injury, and secondly, because he may go free agent at year end. I’d get two bona fide relievers. Starters? Nah. Looking increasingly likely that if needed, McLean, Sproat, and Tong will not embarrass themselves if called up to start. Manaea and Senga return this weekend. The rotation is solid enough.

Mack Ade said...

Probably not

Both Hagenman and Waddell will move to the pen once Senga and Manaea are back

Then my guess would be Hamel

Mack Ade said...

Sproat would be next