9/18/21

Reese Kaplan -- Big Changes for the Mets May Not Be in the Cards

Right now there are a lot of off-the-field Twitter-verse arguments going on between Mets owner Steve Cohen and a variety of anonymous critics who seem to enjoy taking potshots at the team's demise.  Cohen has pointed to an oustered Florida Marlins front office employee, so whatever is being said isn't grounds for much of anything but water cooler talk.  

However, accompanying this revelation was the now very public news that Sandy Alderson intends to be back next year.  That news was enough to cause agita among a number of fans and media representatives who were hoping to see a clean sweep of the front office in the attempt to build a new and winning direction for the Mets team.  

Even more alarming is the announcement by Sandy Alderson that he's leaning on bringing back Luis Rojas for another shot.  Bear in mind that winning was never an important ingredient for him.  Witness the Terry Collins losing years where the man was retained again and again despite his record.  Consequently, it is not all that surprising to see Alderson ponder the easiest thing to do which would be to do nothing.  

Of course, the announcement made both prematurely and without the underscored authority to proceed in this direction could just be posturing.  After all, if the Mets are serious about bringing in some new front office personnel, it could be that he wants that person to lower the ax on Rojas' neck rather than he being the bad guy.  There's nothing new in that strategy as it allows Alderson to hold his head high, shake it from side to side and say, "Hey, it wasn't my decision!"

Already people are jumping all over the Theo Epstein bandwagon as the somehow savior of the organization, but he's had some ups and downs as well.  We won't even go through the whole litany of them, but bear in mind that Jared Porter and Zack Scott were formerly his employees as well.  That doesn't sound like someone who is any better at vetting his staff than the wishing on four-leaf clover Sandy Alderson.  

Also many clubs are reaching out to promote or extend the contracts of their top front office folks to keep Steve Cohen from poaching them from wherever into Queens.  That's smart business by the other teams and something I'd like to see more of in New York given the somewhat ludicrous headlines that had less to do with winning games than it did for following featherweight strategies to try to become competitive.  

As much as I would like to see a new field manager, it is much more critical for the team to focus on the many contractual decisions they need to make for departing free agents, players whose game skills are limited in one way or another, and addressing the pitching gaps that will exist both in the rotation and in the pen.  Furthermore, something needs to be done definitively about Robinson Cano after his one year unpaid vacation.  The would-be free agent think tanks needs to arrive at a decision on Javy Baez, another one about Noah Syndergaard, another one about Jeurys Familia, another one about Jonathan Villar, and a critical one about Aaron Loup.  

I've said in the past and will reiterate that you should not solely rely on the owner's deep pockets to buy a pennant.  For every Aaron Loup deal that works, you have Francisco Lindor, Kevin Pillar, James McCann and others that do not.  The correct route is a blend of in-house or otherwise acquired young players who will be around for several years at minimal cost supplemented by some true stars earning top dollar.  There has been neither side embraced fully.  They're not the old Yankees and not the current Tampa Bay Rays.  As a project manager, I'd like to see a plan!

7 comments:

Tom Brennan said...

Improving won’t be easy. But improve they must. Get it done right for a change. Lindor doubled to wall last night. Move fences in 5 feet and say huh-bye. Help the hitters…move the fences.

RDS900 said...

Pillar has not been bad. Good numbers for a fourth OF. Really don't want Villar back. They'd be foolish not to extend Thor a QO.

Reese Kaplan said...

One of these players has 15 HRs, .224 AVG and 4 SBs worth 0.8 WAR and earns an average of $5 million per year.

The other one has 18 HRs, a .257 AVG, and 13 SBs worth 2.2 WAR and earns $3.55 million while being two years younger.

And you want back the first one? The second is the effort the team has gotten from Villar.

Paul Articulates said...

Reese stimulates a lot of thinking with this article. There are many choices to be made in the offseason. My inclination is not to make too many changes, because that begins rebuilding all over again, and the roster is still full of potential that was not realized this year.

I do think that a managerial change would help, because there were too many incorrect tactical decisions with pitching and pinch hitters. Everyone will miss a few, but Rojas missed more than he hit.

I like both Pillar and Villar for different reasons and would like to see both with the club next year. Pillar is well past his prime but provides a really strong defensive back-up for any outfield position. We know Nimmo struggles to get through a season without injury, and it may not be possible to retain Conforto with just a QO. Villar represents a good glove and great speed (though he could learn a few things from Lindor about baserunning savvy). Villar earned a spot at 3B in the second half and I think he keeps it as we try to bring up young talent to eventually fill that position from within.

Healthy starting pitching was a big issue this year, so you just can't let Thor get away. Even more important is finding a way to keep Marcus Stroman, who was the workhorse of the staff this year. He is an unrestricted free agent so it will take some $$$ to keep him, but he is a proven gem in the rotation.

Tom Brennan said...

Reese, I go with Villar, not Pillar, for another reason. Pillar is descending age-wise much like Todd Frazier. Love the guy, but we need younger. Also, Villar scored 111 runs in 2019. His ability to generate potent offense remains higher.

Tom Brennan said...

Pillar .272 OBP. THANKS BUT NO THANKS FOR 2022. Khalil Lee has a .450 OBP in AAA. Think “youth”

RDS900 said...

Final word. We need a regular third bademan which makes Villar superfluous. Pillar is a fourth OF. I rest my case.