9/8/22

Tom Brennan - Switching Positions to Move Ahead


                                                                    (PC - Ed Delany)

Maybe some minor leaguers could switch to an in-demand position like catcher to get ahead.

BEFORE I GET INTO MY ARTICLE, THOUGH, THE S.S. METS SHIP IS SAILING IN CHOPPY WATERS, SAILING FULL SPEED AHEAD WITH NON-HITTING TIRED VETERANS. TEAM HITTING HAS DRIED UP.  

GIVEN THAT, IF YOU HAD A GUY IN AA WHO IN HIS LAST 36 GAMES HAD GOTTEN ON BASE 74 TIMES VIA HIT AND WALK, .450 OBP OVER THAT PERIOD,  MIGHT YOU DO THE UNTHINKABLE AND CALL HIM UP TO A FALTERING OFFENSIVE SQUAD, WHICH IS A TRUE METS TRADEMARK?

WYATT YOUNG

YEAH, THAT GUY AGAIN. 

I KNOW, LITTLE 5’7” GUY, TOO INEXPERIENCED, INSANE SUGGESTION.

WHY, HE HASN'T EVEN BEEN TO AAA YET!  WAIT, WHAT? 

HE HIT .352 WITH A .446 OBP IN 19 GAMES IN AAA THIS YEAR?  

NAH…LEAVE HIM THERE…WHY BE CREATIVE AND MESS WITH FAILURE?

MOVING ON….

Sometimes, you’ve simply got to improvise.

When I interviewed AA standout Jeff McNeil in May 2018, I noted in my self-admittedly brilliant piece that he wasn’t playing the outfield, but had done so in college. 

So I asked him if he felt he could play outfield in the pros to present a diversified skill set, and he said he definitely could play the outfield.  No problem - it was his main position in college.

His ability to play both positions and hit like the dickens has turned him into a Mets star.

Juan Lagares is another example. 

40 errors in 82 games at SS at age 18? Good grief.  Good golly.  That even gave Ronny Mauricio a chuckle, I'm sure.

A switch to CF, though, and a Lagares Gold Glove followed. A switch worth millions in career earnings.

Ronny Mauricio has had 24 HRs and 79 RBIs in AA through Sept. 2. Do that at age 21 and he elicits some WOWS. 

But he plays the position Lindor owns/plays, with a whole lot more errors. 

That said, a Mets career might necessitate a Mauricio move elsewhere, say, to the outfield. That is speculation, as it has not yet occurred. But if he stays put in his position for now, when he rises to the majors, it won’t be at SS.  If he only played on Lindor days off, he'd sit an awful lot.  Like 160 games of sitting.  That wouldn't sit well with him. OF, maybe?

Who else is out there, that needs to “do a Jeff McNeil” to increase his versatility and value?

Jose Peroza is one. He had a recent, remarkable 30 consecutive on-base streak, so he’s good. Before 2022, I thought in fact that he and Baty actually were fairly even, but the 6 months younger Peroza was miserable at the plate in Brooklyn from April through June, much to my surprise.  I thought my judgment was too optimistic.

He then ignited in a blaze of fire at the plate, reaffirming to me his MLB potential. 

How’s his defense? Awesome. 

104 games at 3B, 2B, ans SS, and just 4 errors?  Dandy for a 6’1”, 220 slugger.  Heck, those look like Rey Ordonez numbers.

And he also had 9 errorless games at 1B prior to 2022. Clearly adept with the mitt.

But the Mets have lots of infielders, both on the Mets and in the minors (Brett Baty, Ronny Mauricio, Mark Vientos, Wyatt Young, Jett Willams, etc.).  That’s a big crowd. 

So, I suggest turning on WAZE, which when activated, mapped out a route that recommends a tough transition to catcher as a possibility.  No suggestion that he’s considered it, or that he ever will, so it is unlikely. WAZE could be wrong, of course. 

But….catchers who can hit are in short supply. 

His last 3 seasons, the just-turned 22 year old has HIT. He’s had 29 HRs, 53 doubles, 5 triples and 152 RBIs in 887 at bats. Fine production. A lot of those ABs have been in “tough to hit in” Brooklyn.

Considering his age and results, I think he will be a big league player. Can he catch? Not sure, but he is built like one and shows he can generate solid defense. Catching could be the ticket to a long MLB career.

As a famous orange person once said in 2016, “what have you got to lose?”

Lastly, Mark Vientos. 

His 42 career errors at 3B in just over 200 games are not at all acceptable.  First base?  5 miscues in 38 games. But Pete is there. The slow afoot Vientos, though, has played 25 outfield games, with zero errors. If he works on his speed for the outfield, and on his 3B glove like it counts like no other time, with a true urgency, maybe he can be a versatile 3 position super slugger.

McNeil did the Multi-Position Mombo and is thriving. The above 3 hitters face the same challenge. Will they rise to it? Hope so. Others may want to do likewise in the Mets minors.


9 comments:

Mack Ade said...

IMO

1. Vientos is a pure DH going forward.

2. Jett is being groomed to be our next second baseman

3. Baty will stick at third and continue to improve defensively.

4. Pete at first

5. Both Alvarez and Parada are pure catchers. I have seen no evidence that they have ever played at another position. My guess is Parada will be the long term Mets catcher here amd Alvy will be traded for 2-3 top prospects

Tom Brennan said...

Mack, that could be the breakout.

Alvarez will beat Parada to the majors by at least a year, I’d think. I look forward to two hitting catchers.

Tom Brennan said...

Nice 15-1 margin vs. Pittsburgh yesterday. Now, keep it up. Not easy without Marte and Max.

Paul Articulates said...

Jeff McNeil is a remarkable talent. He fields a ground ball like he has played IF all his life. He tracks a fly ball like he has played OF all his life. Few baseball players have that kind of ability to do both very well. That said, Tom's reasoning is good - to make a MLB club, you have to be great at your position and there must be a need at that position. The Lagares story is hopefully one that a Mauricio can repeat, because he is not an elite infielder but he does show great potential with a bat in his hand.

I look forward to the Wyatt vs Jett competition for future second baseman. You can never have enough prospects, and as they move through the system, some fall out and others rise to the top. You never know until they get there.

Mack Ade said...

Jeff will leave when he is eligible for free agency.

Take it to the bank.

Steev said...

In light of several articles on various sites, my grandson came up with the following.

Sign Alonso this winter to a long-term contract. Ge will only get more expensive.

He loves Young as the future second baseman. As pointed out above he gas had success on ebery level he has played. His downfall - when he was drafted. How good could someone drafted that low be good.

Baty os the third baseman. He will be all "Wright" playing there

He asked - why cannot Alverez and Parada be a successful combination. Vexause of the demand of the catching position, have each play 81 games at catcher. Rotate them with Alonso into the DH and 1st base.

Talk on draft day was that Jett could possibly transition to CF. Grandson loved that idea.

Ramerez should be in right field, Nimmo will end up in left foeld as he ends up hos career as a Met.

Vientos os a DG only. Mauricio cannot get on base enough. (Currently below .290 on AA). Their values will noy get higher so they should be traded this winter foe starting pitchers. The pitching staff is projected to being older and subject to injury. Need to address that this winter will the pitching prospects in the low minors develop

Remember1969 said...

Interesting stuff, Tom

To follow Mack's lead, I'll comment:

Vientos:. I see him as some other team's first baseman or DH. It just seems the Mets did not want to make space for him this year and I doubt that will change much.. Good trade chip.

Williams:. Jett and Jazz at the second sack in the NL East. I like it. Actually, I was thinking that he would make a great center fielder - Lagares 2 only better

Baty:. Ditto Mack's comment

Pete:. Ditto Mack's comment

Catcher: I cannot see either of them getting traded..they will make a catching/DH tandem for a few years. I would not argue much about Parada being at the top of the depth chart

Gary Seagren said...

On getting "Younger" didn't the Bravos bring up an 11th rounder from the 2019 draft Grissom straight from AA and he's doing pretty good.

Woodrow said...

Vientos is aDH and maybe a good one if he can cut theKs. Mauricio is a middle of he order OFer. If DeGrom isn’t signed Cohen will go after Ohtani. Alvarez,Mauricio,Vientos and Peterson.