1/22/18

Michael Friere - Roster Projection - Rough Draft Edition



We still have a few weeks to go before Pitchers and Catchers report to St Lucie for the start of Spring Training 2018.  With the slow start to the “hot stove” season, I predict that there will be a flurry of activity in the coming weeks all across MLB as teams fill out their rosters and take advantage of the surplus that exists within the market.  I also predict that the Mets will likely make at least one more move to address one or more of the open spots on the roster, whether it be via trade or free agent acquisition.

With that said, I think we can take a quick look at the current roster and put together a “rough draft” of what things may look like once we get to the regular season in late March, into early April.  Players with the dreaded double asterisk next to their names are prime candidates for replacement or movement to a different position, depending on how the next few weeks play out for our GM and our budget.

C1 - Travis d’Arnaud
C2 - Kevin Plawecki

Short of a late acquisition like Jonathan Lucroy, I think you will see a platoon between TDA and KP to start the year.

1B - Adrian Gonzalez
2B - Wilmer Flores** 
SS - Amed Rosario
3B - Asdrubal Cabrera**
MI - Gavin Cecchini**
CI - Matt Reynolds**

INJ - TJ Rivera (CI) and David Wright (3B)

The Gonzalez addition likely puts Dominic Smith back at AAA for the short term, so he can work on his game (and his physique).  I am NOT a fan of Wilmer Flores as the full time starter at 2B, but there aren’t many other options at the moment.  I hope (pray) that Sandy is working on this issue and we get a upgrade at the position (Josh Harrison, perhaps), so Wilmer can move to a utility role (CI).  

Amed Rosario is a future stud and just needs time to develop, while Asdrubal Cabrera will be miscast as the primary starter at 3B.  IF David Wright suddenly finds his health, or another suitable acquisition were to join the roster (like Todd Frazier), then the position would be in better hands and AC can move into a utility role (MI), strengthening the bench in the process. 

Another factor in the infield shuffle will be the health of TJ Rivera, who would likely supplant Matt Reynolds as the CI if and when he is ready to go.

LF - Yoenis Cespedes
CF - Juan Lagares**
RF - Jay Bruce
OF4 - Brandon Nimmo

INJ - Michael Conforto (CF)

The view of the entire Outfield has changed in the last few weeks, due to the unexpected signing of Jay Bruce and the news that the Mets are “slow playing” Michael Conforto’s return.  When MC comes back, he will be our CF because there is no where else to put him, for lack of a better explanation and an obvious example of Sandy valuing offense over defense.  That will push JL out of the lineup, which will make him or possibly Brandon Nimmo expendable.  This issue will be even more complicated because of the possible eight man bullpen that Mickey Callaway is rumored to favor.  That will limit spots on the bench and put a crunch on the roster.

SP1 - Jacob DeGrom
SP2 - Noah Syndergaard
SP3 - Steven Matz
SP4 - Matt Harvey**
SP5 - Zack Wheeler**

The top two spots are set (barring injury) and I like Steven Matz in the #3 spot, since he is the only lefty in the rotation and if healthy, I have the most faith in him when compared to Matt Harvey and Zack Wheeler.  I don’t think MH and ZW will be in the rotation for the entire year, due to health issues and/or lack of effectiveness, but I would like to be wrong.  There is some depth here in the form of Seth Lugo, Robert Gsellman and Rafael Montero, but I would prefer that they battle it out for spots in the bullpen or become trade assets for other problem areas on the roster.

LR - TBD, but my early guess would be Robert Gsellman**
LL -  TBD, not many lefties on the roster, maybe Matt Purke or Kyle Regnault**
STR - Anthony Swarzak
STL -  Jerry Blevins
SER - AJ Ramos
SEL - Josh Smoker**
CL - Jeurys Familia

Outside of 2B, and maybe 3B, left handed pitchers are the one of the biggest sources of concern on the current roster.  Steven Matz is a solid starter when healthy, but the bullpen is a bit short from the left side after Jerry Blevins, who I project as a situational lefty.  I hope (pray) that Josh Smoker can harness his control and take over the left handed set up role, but that is not guaranteed.  

There are also issues with our left handed and right handed “long relievers” that will likely pitch quite a bit if the starters are pulled after a couple trips through the lineup, as rumored.  Hopefully, someone like a Matt Burke or Kyle Regnault can catch lightning in a bottle and help fill out the bullpen.

That covers twenty-four positions, leaving one opening to be filled on the regular roster.  If they go heavy on the bullpen, then it will likely be another long reliever who can pitch multiple innings.  If not, then maybe another utility type player who can play all over the diamond?

As of this moment, Sandy needs to upgrade either 2B or 3B which will strengthen the lineup and fill out the bench by moving someone like Wilmer Flores and/or Asdrubal Cabrera to a utility role.  Picking up another lefty wouldn’t hurt, not to mention a veteran/dependable starter that can add depth to the rotation and allow someone like Zack Wheeler to move to the bullpen.

Should be an interesting month coming up, right?

    

15 comments:

Unknown said...

Cabrera is way overhated by Mets fans and is a solid hitter, who should play everyday at second or third base.

Mack Ade said...

For now... and I believe for the 2018 season, Cabrera will be our third baseman.

My guess is that David Wright will not even make it out of camp.

If he does, he will share time at third with Cabrera, who will move over to second when David plays.

Flores will play second on days Cabrera plays third.

This is in my opinion.

Reese Kaplan said...

Substitute Jose Reyes for Gavin Cecchini who will be in AAA and pencil in Rafael Montero as a long reliever until/unless he falls on his face. He's out of options and they are not likely to cut him loose if they haven't done so already.

Reese Kaplan said...

Speaking of rosters, did anyone notice that the HUMONGOUS market team, the Milwaukee Brewers, have made an offer to Yu Darvish? Wow, if only the Mets were a major market team like that...

Tom Brennan said...

Yu starting trouble again Reese??

Paul Sewald wants in on that 25 man.

Juan Lagares has plenty of time to prove his value - all of spring training, and likely at least a month into the season before Conforto returns. He needs to stay healthy and PRODUCE - or sit.

Rob said...

Please say NO to Lucroy. Travis d'Arnaud out hit and played better defense then him. Plus Jonathan is three years older and coming off a season in Colorado. This reminds me of last year when many were calling for Matt Wieters, who had a negative WAR last year. Our catchers are fine.

Mike Freire said...

I don't dislike Asdrubal Cabrera at all.....but on a pennant contender, I would love for the Mets to have players at 2B and 3B who are known for playing the position, as opposed to "being able to".

Flores and Cabrera as "super utility" types would strengthen the bench/depth of the roster and they would both get significant amount of at bats.

Oh and Lucroy is a much better player then you may think, plus he would be a bit more reliable then TDA......you may see a featured piece on this topic soon.

Mack Ade said...

Rob -

I have no problem with the two headed monster in both 2018 and 2019.

That being said, I'm looking forward to the day that either Tomas Nido or Patrick Mazeika take this job over.

Unknown said...

Agree 100%. I think Travis and Kevin give the Mets top ten catcher production this year.

bill metsiac said...

Mazeika could be here in 2 years or so. Nido must prove himself with the bat or be at AAA or at best a ML bench guy.

bill metsiac said...

David is right about Cabby. He's as young as guys looking for multi-years, and switch hitters who can be expected to hit .280 with 20 HRs have a lot of value.

He's lost some range, but otherwise is solid on D. Give him some respect.

Rob said...

I am excited for Patrick Mazeika to make the big league club in a couple of years. He reminds me of Scott Bradley for the Mariners years ago. Good hitter off the bench and can play catcher once or twice a week with hurting the team.

Reese Kaplan said...

@Rob -- there's a blast from the past. I went to high school with Scott Bradley. He was one of those All-Everything type of athletes AND an honor student AND from a prosperous family, yet he was still a very nice guy and never developed the ego you might have expected. I remember seeing the thickness of his scholarship file in the guidance office one day! We had a few funny moments on the athletic field, once me beating him in tennis and him taking out his revenge on me in track. It was good-natured, though.

Rob said...

Thanks for the awesome story. I always like a back up catcher that can hit, play a little first or third and pinch hit. Bradley was a guy that could do all of those things.

Hobie said...

Rob-

Mackey Sasser could do all of that. He just couldn't... couldn't... couldn't