3/16/24

Open Thread: Tell Us Your Worst Call Ever

WORST…CALL…EVER! 

You’ve watched a lot of baseball, I reckon.

So…describe the WORST baseball call you ever saw.


13 comments:

Mack Ade said...

What the peanut guy used to yell out hawking his nuts ar Ebbets Field

TexasGusCC said...

https://www.reddit.com/r/NewYorkMets/comments/kmhp6q/what_the_fuck_was_that_david_wright_2010/?rdt=62867

TexasGusCC said...

David Wright’s opinion:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lhhOya8sveA

bill metsiac said...

The 1952 WS. Al Barlick, a very respected ump, was at 1B. Johnny Sain, the Yankees pitcher, hit grounder to Short.

The photo in the next morning's NYDN showed Sain's foot on the base.

Gil Hodges was stretching for the throw., and the ball was at least 6 feet from Gil's glove.

And Barlick, with an unobstructed view of the play, had his arm raised in a clear call of OUT!!

I don't think Barlick ever got over the infamy.

Tom Brennan said...

One I was actually thrilled with. We agonized in the 1985 season as the St Louis Cardinals were faultless to nose out the 98-64 Mets.

St Louis gets to the World Series, and in game 6, on the play that would have won them the WS, the ump called a guy safe at first when he was out by 18 inches.

Kansas Citywon that game 6 after that unbelievable blown call, and also game 7.

Paul Articulates said...

Dodgers' third base coach call to send both runners home against the Mets.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UGqkmqMVo-0

Tom Brennan said...

Bartick boo boo

Tom Brennan said...

Gus, funny. In Wrights first career game that I saw, in his 3rd game, vs Smoltz, he got punched out on a pitch clearly out of the strike zone. “Sit down, rook” call by the ump. I think it ended the game as a save for Smoltz.

Tom Brennan said...

Here is the video of that blown call that would have won the World Series for the 1985 Cards:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyt1xEvqqow

Mack Ade said...

Every bad call I remember was made by a guy named Harvey

TexasGusCC said...

How about that pitcher on the Tigers, Galaragga, losing a perfect game when Jim Joyce blew a play at first with the pitcher covering, and then wouldn’t ask for help? I’m sorry, but that was a pure a-hole move, not even asking for help afterwards. What a loser move.

Tom Brennan said...

That Galarraga call was SO BAD.

bill metsiac said...

How did we get through this whole thread without a single reference to Angel Hernandez?