3/30/24

Reese Kaplan -- How Do the Mets Starting Pitchers Look for 2024?


So with the 2024 baseball season for the New York Mets finally underway, it’s time to project what could be good, bad and otherwise for the coming season.  Let’s have a look first at what the Mets offer up in starting pitching.

When the prospective number one starter drops out of the preseason prior to the start of the 2024 season, it caused flashbacks of Justin Verlander, Jacob deGrom, Pedro Martinez, Johan Santana and many other Mets hurlers from the past who gave an unintended and unexpected gut punch to the team, the fans and the media who had already projected what quality innings from that hurler would mean for the team’s chances.  

Kodai Senga rapidly ascended from unknown foreign import into the ace of the staff in a single Mets season. Supporting Senga were a number of pitchers who had moments in the sun and also moments on the dark side of the moon.  

No one was doing cartwheels nor popping champagne when David Stearns reached out to secure the services of oft-injured and the horrific 2023 version of  Luis Severino.  He’s thus far been a pleasant surprise with a very solid Florida tenure, but we know that leading your team in anything in the Spring is not a guarantee of a trip north.  Ask Mark Vientos.

The addition of Sean Manaea was a bit more warmly received as he has had more good than bad in his career and the price paid for the man was eminently reasonable in today’s baseball dollars.  It would seem that the thinness of the starting rotation made the prospect of a more than one year pitcher was pretty appealing.  

His Spring pitching has also been more good than bad and the new look Manaea missing the beard and extended locks seems to be making a fresh approach to his New York Mets tenure.

More unknown to the New York fans was the trade that brought in starting pitcher Adrian Houser.  Nothing about his stat sheet jumps out as eye popping, but obviously former Milwaukee Brewers head honcho David Stearns knows him far better than anyone associated with the Mets. 

Returning southpaw Jose Quintana got off to a late start last season due to injury but from his late arrival to year’s end he delivered.  He only made 13 starts with an uninspiring 3-6 record, but the 3.57 ERA was terrific and better than his career mark of 3.74.  The Mets own Quintana for this full season and then he once again becomes a free agent as he enters his age 36 year.

Then comes the man known more for his AAAA tenure the past three seasons than his pitching talent, Tylor Megill.  The big man started out like a house afire in Florida and everyone was almost ready to question, “Kodai who?”  Unfortunately, the previous Tylor Megill returned for his last three appearances and it drove his ERA up to a good-for-Megill 3.92 level after having looked unhittable.  

The good news is that Senga is due back soon and Megill may indeed with his new pitch upped his game a bit, but for his career he’s a 4.72 ERA pitcher who yields a .268 batting average to opposing hitters.  Here’s hoping that’s all a thing of the past, but history is what it is.

Next time around we’ll look at the bullpen built to hold things down for Edwin Diaz and the rest of the Mets.  After that the somewhat offensive collection of hitters who appear as if they’re continuing the 2023 inability to get on base. 

6 comments:

TexasGusCC said...

The Mets staff reaches into the minors, as Stearns has built depth. The staff is basically the six here, and Butto, Lucchessi, AAA prospects Scott and Vasil, and injured for now Kranek and Peterson. The disappointing thing is there really isn’t the upside the Mets had ten years ago. No one can say these guys are the next Harvey, DeGrom, Syndergaard, Wheeler and Matz that took the team into a World Series.

Tom Brennan said...

The little I saw of Severino, he looked very good, and so did clean-cut Manaea. Houser and Quintana are almost undoubtedly short-termers. As Gus noted, you have 6 back up starters of average quality.

Pitching won't be this team's problem. Even with JD Martinez soon arriving, the offense is concerning to me.

Lou Gossett Jr died at 87. He was both an Officer and a Gentleman.

Tom Brennan said...

Megill has a golden opportunity, with Senga out, to wrest away the 5th starter spot.

Please keep in mind that Megill's total pro innings (minors and majors) is 440. Syndergaard threw more innings than that just in the minors, before becoming a MLB mainstay (which, of course, years later, he now isn't).

I always like to add, when it comes to ERA, that Megill has had the misfortune of pitching against Atlanta and not the Mets. 15% of his MLB innings have been against Atlanta.

TexasGusCC said...

Tom, you make a very good point about Megill’s ERA and who his opponents were. Undoubtedly, when we look at numbers we tend to just compare blindly, but it seems like pitchers can have years where they are more favored by the schedule. Too, one can have the misfortune of pitching in a bandbox and that hurts also. Ultimately, while we do account for ERA, as fans we know if a pitcher is doing the job or not.

Tom Brennan said...

Gus, good points. Megill last year was hurt mid-season, but was very good the first 8 weeks and last 6 weeks.

Also, to reinforce my point on lack of total innings, Gaylord Perry was 4-7, 4.50 his first two seasons, and 24-30 his first 4 seasons. Then it clicked. I am hoping it similarly clicks for Megill this year.

Rds 900. said...

ST stats can be misleading. Bunch of runs scored when Parsons was brought in to get the last out.