8/19/22

Reese Kaplan -- Growing From Within -- What a Concept!


The New York Mets have not lately been a team built on working with their own homegrown resources.  Whether the front office was run by Sandy Alderson or Brodie Van Wagenen, it seemed that the club regarded its minor league prospects as trade chips rather than as future major leaguers.  While there is certainly value to that approach, the opposite perspective of building from within is equally valid.  

Look at clubs like the Yankees in their heyday, the Cardinals, the Braves and some economically constrained clubs like Tampa and Seattle who find themselves having to go as far as possible with low cost players in order to succeed.


When the trade deadline approached the Mets fans and media expected more of the same, watching highly regarded youngsters peddled away for fringe major leaguers who would help for just the balance of the season a'la the Javy Baez methodology.  

Now to be fair, Baez was not welcomed back here and has struggled mightily for his losing but well-heeled Detroit employer while the minor league fodder sacrificed for a few months of truly top notch production made by Mr. Thumbs Down have not yet come back to haunt his former employer in Queens.  That result suggests that the prospects either were not quite ready or not nearly as good as they were purported to be.

Despite the hue and cry by newspapers, bloggers and fans for the Mets to go big or go home, new GM Billy Eppler did not follow the same path as his predecessors, instead looking to tweak the roster here and there while not giving up the farm to do so.  That point is abundantly clear when both Luis Guillorme and Eduardo Escobar went down with injuries simultaneously.  

Instead of making due with an over-30 AAAA player trying to fill the starting holes created by IL stints of the regulars, the Mets tapped number 2 prospect Brett Baty to get his start in the major leagues.


Some folks were incredulous that the Mets have been so reluctant to promote their top minor leaguers while others were doing cartwheels when they finally did.  No one was rooting for the injury barrage making the promotions necessary, but what happened was beyond anyone's control and it was good to get a brief look at a man who should be a piece of the team in the near future with Baty's arrival.  

The fact that his first major league at-bat resulted in a home run which helped the Mets take their first game of this Braves series is all the more a storybook as if created by baseball-oriented fairy tale writers.  

Many are quick to point out the necessary jolt Michael Conforto made on the big club when out of injury necessity he was rocketed from AA to the majors back in the championship season of 2015.  Of course, here we are seven years later and Conforto couldn't secure himself a new job.  That result was due more to injury and salary requirements than his down year performance in 2021.  


I bring up the Conforto reminder because not every prospect advancing to the major leagues is going to flourish consistently year after year.  Conforto was an All Star back in 2017 and in 2019 showed great promise by slugging 33 HRs and driving in 92 runs.  Unfortunately he has not done nearly as well since then with slumps and injuries derailing progress.  It is now somewhat understandable why his then employer didn't make Herculean efforts to keep him around.  

As the Mets move forward towards the close of the 2022 regular season schedule it is assumed that Baty's presence is both out of necessity and an audition for his future in the major leagues.  The Mets have other infielders in their system like Mark Vientos and Ronny Mauricio who also seem capable of hitting the ball, so it's still possible that even a stellar August and September by Baty might simply solidify his option to be a big name trade chip.  

Of course, it also could spell the end for Eduardo Escobar who has had some great moments (including hitting for the cycle) but has been horrific overall for the 2022 season.  The Mets are on the hook for his $9.5 million salary for 2023 and either a $9 million salary or $500K buyout for 2024.  By Cohen standards that's not major money, but it's not pocket change either.  

For now, it's good to see a guy who swings the bat getting a chance to play regularly.  Sometimes it works out (Pete Alonso and Brandon Nimmo being two good examples).  Sometimes it doesn't (Dom Smith and a multitude of others failing to do so).  

You have to remember that championship clubs are not all veterans nor all rookies.  They are a mix of the two.  The Mets have tended to eschew rookie growth potential for veteran competency of varying degrees.  It's nice to see that trend starting to change as the fans would love to see their own homegrown players get a chance to be an integral part of their favorite ballclub.  

11 comments:

Mack Ade said...

Re: Last night

Mets Twitter is saying they lost last night due to "shoddy" defense

I disagree

Slow Dribble single in the whole are a part of the game. Runners are usually too fast to throw out on those plays

The win was the bloop hit by Harris

Not luck. Just part of the game

Tom Brennan said...

Escobar will be completely in the way in 2023. The disregarded Vientos has 20 HR, 54 RBIs, .315 in last 62 games. I’ll switch them right now.

Tom Brennan said...

Mack that’s why it is hard to win 100 in a season.

Tom Brennan said...

I saw people on FB (Fools’ Blog) already writing off Nimmo. He is the lead off hitter on a first place team. Can we see how he does down the stretch and in the playoffs first?

bill metsiac said...

If Baty succeeds this year as Conforto did in '15, the 3B job will be his in '23 and beyond unless he flops. I don't see Escobar's stock falling to the point of a DFA, but IMO he will have a new employer next year.

Vientos is a different story. I've never seen him play, but I keep reading that he's a terrible 3Bman. Can he move into an already crowded OF? Can he be useful as a DH, platooned or otherwise? Or is he best suited as trade bait?
Time will tell.

Paul Articulates said...

All good points by Reese. The farm system is getting better. Due to good discretion during the trade deadline frenzy, we actually still have MLB ready players to call up. Some of them will make it long term, some will just be a bright flash. The draft was good. It will take time for all this to develop into a system like the top teams, but it is a great start.

Atlanta has recently demonstrated another important front office tactic that will continue to make their ballclub strong. They are extending their young stars before they make themselves "too valuable" to afford. Annual salaries for guys like Acuna, Riley, Harris are well below market value for their performance. I think the Mets front office should take a close look at their own "policy" of not negotiating during the season.

Reese Kaplan said...

Take a look at the contract given to Lindor. He's worth the money he's earning, but a few years down the road can you imagine what Alonso and others will get? Locking people up early is a good idea but (witness Juan Soto) not everyone will take the offer.

Tom Brennan said...

Bill, Vientos has apparently a strong arm, but his 2 career steals tells me that he is not fleet for the outfield. He really should be a first baseman, but....The Pillar of Granite is already there.

bill metsiac said...

The Mets extended David and Jose early on, but when they tried to extend Jose a second time he wouldn't even listen to their offer before going FA.

Some accept, some reject, but until the offer is made the option of accepting is lost. I wonder why the Mets aren't trying.

Woodrow said...

How did Wrightss and Reyes contracts work out? Often its good to let guys walk or trade them in their walk year. Wright,Reyes,Conforto, Syndergard,

bill metsiac said...

They worked out very well. But considering how Jose declined after signing with Miami, I am glad we didn't outbid them.